mr. byrd. clicks thank you, mr. chief justice. may it please the court, court, respondents are not saying we are not ready. they are echoing questions that justice breyer was asking how to define marriage, about who gets to decide that question the people acting through the democratic process with the federal court and we are asking to affirm every individual fundamental liberty interest in deciding the meaning of marriage in this whole case turns on the question -- >> know what is taking that away from anybody. refuse not to marry. talking about the fundamental liberty interest clicks i thought i i thought i heard the answer to the question being given 2000 years of the democratic ballot box quite simple. what i heard was marriage is fundamental. certainly that is true. and marriage as the states administer it is open to vast numbers of people who both have children, adopt children, don't have children call of the place. there is one group of people whom they will not open marriage to. they have no possibility to participate in t