mr. chair commissioner hur and i think we've had it out certainly with the statute of limitations in termsf further beating of that horse i can't imagine what can be addressed to the discussion tonight tonight. >> motion on the table. >> call the question. >> you want to - you have the motion. >> my motion we not authorize mr. sincroy to send out the leaders or letter saying the marietta matter is waved because of the statute of limitations we not approve the letter. >> all in favor, say i. >> i opposed i opts because my amendment was not included. >> so the motion is carried that the letter not go out the other issue i think that is - >> can you stayed the vote we couldn't tell. >> 4 to one. >> okay. thank you. >> the other question is whether or not we want to continue to take any action in the farrell matter there's sort of. >> double negative hanging somewhere in terms of don't say require a motion we're not going to take further action i think the opposite would be true if we're going to take further action someone will move we take further action and this is not going to be me. >> as