mr. chair ms. crow would you step back our practices going forward. >> so you were had mentioned that that the department goes through past requests and matches them against the ongoing investigations to help guide with you with the response did you in the past accredit this specific ordinance or the exception that will apply to any other questions that unfortunately you'll noted be able to honor is there a history ever you're not being specific. >> i was responsible for responding to the public information request only temporarily awhile our public information officer was on maternity leave imagines a general practice we do not withhold documents it is unusual for that but i'll have to look at the records and see how often that issue arises. >> you didn't look to throw the actual responded. >> only the prior response. >> no, i have not. >> okay. >> commissioners that is. i think the gentleman wanted to say something jess deputy city attorney i want to clarify maintained and maybe answer some of the com