mr. chapman at the time along with mr. muller and testified to this effect. it took reports from them : in the opinion was clear that as to their review there was no additional illegality with respect to phone hacking in that file. and as to the opinion that was clear : the company rested on a number of things from then on, and i certainly know in 2009 when the additional allegations came this summer the company rarely arrested. >> move right up today to to what to was discovered in the offices. >> so in 2010, after the civil litigation had put a spotlight are unearthed, if you will, to us, to the company additional, new evidence, new intermission that had not been there before. the police investigation started off. one of the things i was with back and looked at, i suppose it was in the spring by senior people at international was that file, and it was reluctant to open up and looked at, and it was very rapidly brought to our attention that this was something. >> when? >> , again, this is between april call may, june, and that's timeframe. >> into looked at

mrs. gene chapman. >> this morning we learned the airport is for so. it seems as though unemployment is going up in the northeast, our planes the decrepit isn't yet further evidence that the loss of infrastructure and jobs in the northeast, that this government economic plan is a catastrophic failure of? >> the key thing about the future of airport which is a vital airport is not necessarily who owns it but is it being invested in? is it being expanded? is it working well? that is the key question and the question i know my right honorable friend is looking at carefully. >> shayla murray. >> thank you, mr. speaker. as the prime minister in the oecd and the national institute economic and social research findings this week showing that soaring immigration was not caused by the prospect of prosperity but just by the open door policies of the last government? and what he stop it from ever happening again and? >> the honorable lady is right. the report said specifically the increase in net immigration to the u.k. was not driven primarily by the economic pe

mrs. gene chapman. >> this morning we learned the airport is for so. it seems as though unemployment is going up in the northeast, our planes the decrepit isn't yet further evidence that the loss of infrastructure and jobs in the northeast, that this government economic plan is a catastrophic failure of? >> the key thing about the future of airport which is a vital airport is not necessarily who owns it but is it being invested in? is it being expanded? is it working well? that is the key question and the question i know my right honorable friend is looking at carefully. >> shayla murray. >> thank you, mr. speaker. as the prime minister in the oecd and the national institute economic and social research findings this week showing that soaring immigration was not caused by the prospect of prosperity but just by the open door policies of the last government? and what he stop it from ever happening again and? >> the honorable lady is right. the report said specifically the increase in net immigration to the u.k. was not driven primarily by the economic pe

to know what to recesses you had with john chapman after this came to light? will we have heard from mr. murdoch, john chapman sat on the file for years. >> the original inquiry into the seventh, i believe, was instructive and be. >> window. when the evidence came to light note to your committee and be end john chapman was a news international mom wheel director reports to you, to europe recovers issue? >> yes, i do. obviously we discussed it. as soon as it tends to lead to my think it was the end of april. i was told about it. mr. chapman was fastball for his knowledge, where the fires had been and what they have not come to light before. the minister is standard committee. >> his response. >> his response at the time was that he was asked to do in investigation into the illegal inception of with swells in chief of the the recommendations which was the lead of the unit gunman agreed he felt, as our legal adviser the the lawyers involved -- >> cut you off the hook. >> conoco was an accurate review of the file. that is something that killed the effort today then netted gems were wrecked

mrs. gene chapman. >> this morning we learned the airport is for so. it seems as though unemployment is going up in the northeast, our planes the decrepit isn't yet further evidence that the loss of infrastructure and jobs in the northeast, that this government economic plan is a catastrophic failure of? >> the key thing about the future of airport which is a vital airport is not necessarily who owns it but is it being invested in? is it being expanded? is it working well? that is the key question and the question i know my right honorable friend is looking at carefully. >> shayla murray. >> thank you, mr. speaker. as the prime minister in the oecd and the national institute economic and social research findings this week showing that soaring immigration was not caused by the prospect of prosperity but just by the open door policies of the last government? and what he stop it from ever happening again and? >> the honorable lady is right. the report said specifically the increase in net immigration to the u.k. was not driven primarily by the economic pe

mrs. gene chapman. >> this morning we learned the airport is for so. it seems as though unemployment is going up in the northeast, our planes the decrepit isn't yet further evidence that the loss of infrastructure and jobs in the northeast, that this government economic plan is a catastrophic failure of? >> the key thing about the future of airport which is a vital airport is not necessarily who owns it but is it being invested in? is it being expanded? is it working well? that is the key question and the question i know my right honorable friend is looking at carefully. >> shayla murray. >> thank you, mr. speaker. as the prime minister in the oecd and the national institute economic and social research findings this week showing that soaring immigration was not caused by the prospect of prosperity but just by the open door policies of the last government? and what he stop it from ever happening again and? >> the honorable lady is right. the report said specifically the increase in net immigration to the u.k. was not driven primarily by the economic pe

mr. chapman testified to as well spent i will come to mr. crone and mr. meyerle, but the matter of tom crone, wrote to -- on a saturday which was a very busy day for "news of the world." the following tuesday where he is clearly expecting colin myler to the meaning within, which he said he can't be advocacy group are in for a holiday. when did you first see that name of? >> i didn't see that memo at the time. i first saw that memo recently since i gave evidence to you in july spent so that was a private note from tom crone to colin myler, and was not copied to? >> it was not shared with the. >> would you agree, the fact that you can't recall having a meeting, or discussion, certainly colin myler can't recall having a meeting that tom crone expect to happen, writing pretty serious memo, the question as to how these two deal with each other and whether they fall in frank with what they're up to? >> i mean, i couldn't possibly spike lee about all the conversation they might have had with each other but i just don't know. [inaudible] people have occasionally