mr. frank jordan's era, we were cleaning the streets. actually cleaning the sidewalk. [chime] president olague: thank you, sir. >> my name is charles bolton, i have been a community organizer for over 40 years. i think that unfortunately, the folks that support the project have made the unfortunate distinction here today. they make it sound like if you rule to basically not allow the rooftop garden, that this is going to basically destroyed his business and keep him from doing all of the good things he has done over the years. i don't think that is the case. i think the case is whether or not the residents in the area should have stood subsidize his business and his profit for their discomfort. there is no way they you can control the noise levels of that rooftop area. i don't care if you come up with some sort of nasa sound baffle, you will have noise. you either go back and redesigned the noise criteria, or you deny it today. >> commissioners, this is a simple question of where one party's rights begins and ends, and where other parties rights begins and ends. it is