mr. macshane. you say that as recently as december 2010 they wrote an article about that relationship despite the fact that it had ended some months earlier as i understand it. what is your view? >> i think it depends entirely on the context and it seems to me that there was a difference between somebody who is in the public eye like a politician say, who make sino what i would call traditional family values a part of his or her political platform. somebody saying the sanctity of marriage is very important, and people shouldn't have co-habitation all relationships or anything like that, and they have been kind of pose with their family in their election literature and so on, then i think maybe that's a different situation. but the point is that neither dennis nor i ever kind of courted the press and invited them into our lives. quite the opposite. on each of the occasions and is a gone on at a low level for about 20 years. i've had phonecalls and then approached by journalists and they always come

mr. macshane? >> i think the latter. my kind of cassius is made as proof of much much higher.o they got interested in him. once they got interested in him, they got interested in me. so i spoke on the collateral damage. >> okay. thank you. thank you very much. >> i think we need a short break. >> yes, i think that's sensible. i'll be content just to let people have a break. i will say the same two witnesses who are coming. this is not always entirely pleasant audience. thank you. [inaudible conversations] [inaudible conversations] >> i swear by almighty cut the evidence he gave me the whole truth, the full truth and nothing but the truth. >> sure your full name. ! graham julian shear. >> you have provided a statement november 2011 that states the truth at the end of that statement. do you confirm the truth of that statement? >> i do. >> thank you very much. first i will ask you to please tell us about yourself. >> i am a solicitor and partner at international law firm based in the city of london. a qualified in 1989. i practiced initially commercial lot and then became a comme