mr. marshall. >> you can start speaking. >> good afternoon, chairman. members of the board, mr. ford, my name is corey marshall of the information and financing technology division, presenting the highlights of the fourth quarter service standards and results for 2010. diving right in, we will begin with on-time performance. the increase in the third quarter is 7%, most likely attributable to the run time adjustments and headway improvements put in during september of 2009. of the lines that were surveyed and received enhancements, 77.2% online performance, the not modified lions received just of -- lines receive adjustments. the goal was 85% on the quarter. on an annual basis, the online performance inched up words from 70.3% to 73.5%. 10 lines of achieved online -- on-time performance were achieved, one being in california, the other being in the mission ltd., the 28l and 30 to stockton being the most prominent. there were 19 lines that were 70 percent approved. >> moving on to the scheduled service delivery, that is the combination of officer and equipment availability. while

mr. marshall. members

mr. marshall, thank you. president marshall: wow. [applause] president marshall: thank you. [applause] president marshall: let me just say, commissioners, i accept this on behalf of the commission because the commission came to the rescue. for me personally, that was as tragic an event as i have ever been involved in it with all my years of community service. that shooting by the police officer, who is actually being convicted of the shooting, the subsequent unrest. having grown up in los angeles, i am familiar with that kind of unrest, and to be asked to be part of helping to develop a civilian process for bart, i am just glad they turned to us, the san francisco police commission, to be able to help push this thing and craft it. let me just say, just as important for me was the call that came to when you have -- when you had a community meetings. it was very charged. i did not know if we would move the process forward, and you asked me to moderate the meetings. i just want to thank them for their trust in me. they basically said, dr. marshall, if you say it is okay, it is

mr. marshall. members of the public? >> no members of the public. wait, there he is. >> before he speaks, i would ask that any of the board members, as you go through all of these charts and statistics, any questions that you have, we can come back with more in-depth analysis. once we receive these numbers and present them to you at the end of the year, we are working on getting to the bottom of some of the trends. the positive trends and the not so positive trends. >> it should be something like this rather than seven of the jewels. >> i agree. >> good afternoon. >> first of all, my name is rob by el cabrera. it bothers me that looking at quarterly reports without copies available for the public to look at so that we can understand what you're doing. and this is especially great tool. to make sure that all of the communities and neighborhoods had reliable service, we were changing the reported standards of service, without the document in front of you, it is hard when someone talks about on-time performance, do you add it up? is there a running tim

mr. speaker, i think that general marshall was a great man and deserves recognition. in fact, he received a great deal of recognition during his lifetime. he received the nobel prize. however, mr. speaker, this congress has shown an unfortunate propensity for bringing up bills that are not exactly high priorities in the minds of the american people. . our colleagues across the ime, mr. speaker, are not even trying to deal with legislation that the american people do want and are clamoring for. the failed trillion dollar stimulus, the government takeover of health care, billions of dollars in bailouts were all pushed through by democrats in charge. but when it comes to making a budget or staving off the largest tax increase in american history, these same democrats are sitting on their hands. it would be a travesty, mr. speaker, for this body to adjourn this week and leave a $3.9 trillion tax increase looming over the heads of american families and small businesses. mr. speaker, we stand here today with more than 30 members of your own party making a simple request, let

president marshall: thank you, mr. cummings. public comment on item number 6. hearing none, we move to item number 7. vice president mazzucco: some of the commissioners thought this item was on for next week. it looks like we'll have a new commissioner, so i ask we move this to the first week of october so we'll have the new commissioner on board and it will be post-retreat. >> moving to item 7, commissioner, that is the election of commission officers. vice president mazzucco: i would move we move this to the first week of october. that is october 6. and by then we should have our new commissioner on board, we hope hope. hopefully we'll have them there fwor our retreat on october 2nd. >> do we want -- and i know that you all have been really patiently sitting on this for a long time, but do we want to move it at least a couple of weeks part that, so that the new commissioner actually will have an opportunity to be at a few meetings and see how things are going and make an informed vote himself? commissioner chan: the only thing is, the new president's term is

president marshall: we can discuss that at our retreat. commissioner hammer: when you facilitate it, mr johnson. you have to volunteer to facilitate it. president marshall: any other further public comment? then item 5, please. >> item 5 is presentation of the department's bi-monthly report regarding the audit of the secure communities program under commission resolution 73-10. >> good evening, members of the commission, o.c.c. director hicks, members of the audit. my name is gordon brusso. i'm the i.d. manager for the plud police department. as you know, this is the second report on on a secured commuents audit, and the first report covers only three weeks, for the month of june. this report is going to be covering two separate four-week periods for -- of data for july and august of 2010. the slides that i'm going to present here address the police commission resolution 7310, and i have labeled each slide according to the resolution number that it matches, and there is some sub sections -- subsections of those. i have also identified the july 5's with an orange background, and the augu

commission president, joe marshall, commission vice president, thomas mazzucco, commissioner petra dejesus. also with us tonight is chief gascon. mr. president, you have a quorum. but president marshall: this is the meeting for september 15, 2010. lieutenant, please call item no. 1. secretary reilly: the monthly statistical support for the period of january 1, 2010 through july 21 -- 31, 2010. president marshall: commissioners, any question about the items on the consent calendar? seeing none, i will entertain a motion for approval. thank you very much. lieutenant, item number two, please. secretary reilly: item two is for general public comment, where members of the public address the commission for a time period determined by the chair on items that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission but do not appear on the agenda. president marshall: public comment, please. >> commissioners,"r my name is francisco. some of you know me pretty well, and for those of you who are new, i hope you get too

marshall: next speaker, please? >> good evening, commissioners, mr. president. my name is rodney. i live a couple blocks down the street. i tried to visit you every time you come to my neighborhood. i would like to thank the commission for invitee and chiefg gaston -- for inviting chief gaston. there is a different way the criminals react to your performance. i'm grateful for the chief, as my neighbors are. the last time i was here was the last time the commission was here. it was a subcommittee on violent crime. president marshall was here. i appreciate you coming in. the commander general did some work with us. there was work with presentations. it helped tremendously. i would like to welcome the captain. he is a cop's cop. he has been here about two months. i have spoken with about 30 officers. people's faces light up and say he is a great guy. we have nothing but good things to look forward to in this district. it is probably the smallest police district in the united states. it probably makes the most felony arrests of any station in the united states. i would think the commi

mr. mack, professor black speakers on the question of marshall would be doing, i think ron wins was right. is a pragmatist. he knew how to get to court. but he was also an organizer. had a book i would recommend to all of you is a book by patricia called every point. it's the first one volume complete on, complete history o the naacp up until 1960 published last year. one of the things, when the point she makes in the book is that marshall traveled a lot he would travel 25,000 miles in one year. he was often not in the national office. he was out speaking to local black communities. he was organizing. he was getting behind the cases. and he was organizing them to resist jim crow. and we think about lawyers we tendo think about them as not being organizers. and it turns out that thurgood marshall who was a super lawyer, was also a super organizer. and what i think about sort of where is the grassroots organizational improvisational energy today, it's in folks who are, let me say, not at all put off i want michelle alexander has described. and one of the things i think he would say to us to

[applause] president marshall: further public comment on this item? hearing none? mr. craven. i think the they want you for -- i think the lawyers call it redirect. would you answer a few ques questions that may have emerged. >> i don't think there is anyone in the room that does not think the patrol specials are trying to do a good job. i don't think there is anyone in the room that doesn't think threr doing the best job they can and that they are trying to help the citizens of san francisco. i did not know anything or understand anything about the patrol specials, and i have come to learn a lot about them, and there is a minimal of them out in the city. obviously the public wants the patrol specials or obviously they wouldn't be employed or have complinets. my commitment is i have met with most of the patrol specials in the room back in the hall of justice. my certain is i f as i told the news today, i concur with some of the recommendations in the report, but my concern is that patrol specials are supposed to wear air certain kind of uniform, we need to be held accountable.

fire marshals discovered the material accidentally after searching the apartment after a neighboring fire. >> mrobama defending his recovery efforts to continue cutting tax cut $for the wealthy. >> a leb nose man has been arrested for allegedly placing a back path he thought contained explosives near wrigley field. he also talked about poisoning lake michigan, scomploegd a sky scraper and hurting the mayor of chicago. >> there's a new push to get people to put down the phone behind the whole. we have seen it on the road. triefers behind the wheel. the second annual distracted driver summit. they are hoping to put the breaks on distracted driving all together. on a mission to keep driver's focussed. their daughter was killed on her way to meet her wedding planner. j we were very angry. our daughter was taken from us by someone who was texting. >> in hopes of reducing those numbers, local also address those challenges and identify opportunities for driving efforts. hoping for a change in attitude. they would like to see distracted driving is just as dangerous as drunk driving. >> we are living pro

mr. mack, professor black speakers on the question of marshall would be doing, i think ron wins was rightew how to get to court. but he was also an organizer. had a book i would recommend to all of you is a book by patricia called every point. it's the first one volume complete on, complete history of the naacp up until 1960 published last year. one of the things, when the point she makes in the book is that marshall traveled a lot. he would travel 25,000 miles in one year. he was often not in the national office. he was out speaking to local black communities. he was organizing. he was getting behind the cases. and he was organizing them to resist jim crow. and we think about lawyers we tend to think about them as not being organizers. and it turns out that thurgood marshall who was a super lawyer, was also a super orgazer. and what i think about sort of where is the gssroots organizational improvisational energy today, it's in folks who are, let me say, not at all put off i want michelle alexander has described. and one of the things i think he would say to us today is we need to get or

mr. mack, professor black speakers on the question of marshall would be doing, i think ron wins was right. is a pragmatist. he knew how to get to court. but he was also an organizer. had a book i would recommend to all of you is a book by patricia called every point. it's the first one volume complete on, complete history of the naacp up until 1960 published last year. one of the things, when the point she makes in the book is that marshall traveled a lot. he would travel 25,000 miles in one year. he was often not in the national office. he was out speaking to local black communities. he was organizing. he was getting behind the cases. and he was organizing them to resist jim crow. and we think about lawyers we tend to think about them as not being organizers. and it turns out that thurgood marshall who was a super lawyer, was also a super organizer. and what i think about sort of where is the grassroots organizational improvisational energy today, it's in folks who are, let me say, not at all put off i want michelle alexander has described. and one of the things i think he would say to u

mr. coates he is not some right wing guy he worked for the voting rights project of the aclu. and in 1991 he received a thurgood marshall decade award from the naacp. this is not a man with an ideological ax to grind. the entire case is troubling but also stupid. those black panthers should have been prosecuted. there is no doubt about it everybody knows that if a klan guy was outside a place with a club he would have been prosecuted. you can draw your own conclusions here. there is no question that this story is a major enembarrassment for the justice department and the obama administration. and that's the memo. now for the top story tonight, let's bring in megyn kelly who continues to follow this situation, be annoyed by it coates they didn't want him to testify. they told him not, to right? holder told him don't do you. this his bosses at the department of justice told him not to comply with the subpoena. he listened to those orders since december. it's been a year since he listened to those orders. a source close to him tells me he basically had had enough. he said i have to comply with the law. >> bill: i want to b