mr. pacheco call roll please. we have a motion from the vice president to adapt the september 10, 2014, minutes on that motion. >> commissioner fung president is absent commissioner honda. >> thank you the vote is 3 to zero the minutes are adapted. >> okay. thank you. we're going to call item 4 i want to ask the interpreter to start interpreting that is appeal next youngest boozing vs. the public health department on judy district attorney street for the suspicion of a tobacco sales permit 15 day superstition from selling tobacco to minority you have 14 anybody's to present your case given the interpretation. >> (speaking foreign language.) >> your honor and commissioners when i sell a pack of cigarettes the margin the profit is about one dollar and as i might see i have already checked with the decoy why would i break the law i would be out and not fortunate enough to please look at the matter more closely and my pleading. >> are you finished? is he finished okay. i have a question pardon >> okay sorry are you fi

mr. pacheco call the roll please. on that motion from commissioner honda to adapt the august 7, 2014, minutes commissioner fung. commissioner hurtado. commissioner president lazarus. thank you >> the vote is 4 to zero those minutes are adapted. >> thank you item 4 vs. the department of public works urban ban forestry on miramar avenue appealing the try removal permit denial to remove two trees in the medium it's on the hearing we'll start with the appellant you have 7 minutes. >> good afternoon, commissioners i'm anita harris this is about differing opinions of arresting broadcast i'll be brief the west park association maintains an urban effort n located in the park westward park choose to replace those trees this man was highly repeated and served on several san francisco advisor boards he maintained and knew our trees and correcting r correctly appreciated a tree failure after many years to save those trees we now needed to replace them and there have been a number of major limb fairs in this sect after mr. hills u

mr. pacheco if mr. charles comes in to reschedule then we'll reschedule that next is the department of public works vs. the property on 699 protesting the issuance for the pacific bell of the excavation permit installing the permit for the application it is on for hearing tonight we'll start with the appellant. >> okay ms. fee would like to pass forward an identical set of photos. >> sure can we make sure we get the photos from the permit holder i don't know if there's a copy for the department as well we can take a look and pass them here's another set. >> i can share this. >> good evening madam president, vice president commissioner fung and commissioner honda my name is viola yee my property is located on the southeast corner of package and stereotyping streets i have been burdened with a disproportion share of graffiti and vandalism activities for more than 25 years my name is my property has been cited by the street management because of them the department of public works anti graffiti unit is awa

mr. pacheco call the roll please. we have a motion from commissioner fung to adapt the august 20th, 2014, minutes. commissioner hurtado. commissioner president lazarus. commissioner honda. thank you. the vote is 4 to zero the minutes are adapted >> thank you item 4 is appeal cause vs. the department of building inspection the property is on alison street protesting the issuance to a disembarkation one permit for two-story addition set back approximately 16 and a half feet from the wall it was held on august 20th but the matter was continued to allow time for the dbi to get in a site visit we'll start with the dbi and before we do. >> i have reviewed the video. >> thank you inspector duffey 3 minutes. >> i went to the property last friday following the hearing and issued a notice of violation i've got several copies here it's okay to share those? yes, please do. >> you should have them there. thank you. so i'll go ahead and read the notice of the violation then i'll speak. so i notice that work had start before the gra

mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion from commisssioner finkle to over rule dpw and deny this permit. can you repeat your basis again >> number one compliance. >> on the basis it didn't comply with article 27. >> thank you. so again to deny the permit with the finding that this permit didn't compile with article 27 the new smf ordinance on that motion to overly rule and deny this commissioner hurtado. the president is recused commissioner honda

mr. pacheco please go over the boards meeting guidelines and conduct the answering in. >> the board requestsou turn off all electronic devising. >> appellant and representatives have 7 minutes to present their cases and 3 minutes for rebuttals people affiliated must include their comments within the 3 or 7 minute period the public has up to 3 minutes that are not affiliated with the parties to assist the minutes members of the public are asked but not required to submit a business card speaker cards and pens are available on the left-hand side of the podium the board welcomes our comments and suggestions there are customer satisfaction survey forms on the left side of the podium if you have questions please speak to board staff before or call the board office loshthd on mission street room 304 between van ness this is broadcast live and sfgovtv cable channel 78 and dvds of this meeting are available for purchase directly in sfgovtv. >> thank you for your attention we'll conduct the swearing in if you intend to testify and wish to have the board give your testimony evidentiary wealthy please

mr. pacheco i'm cynthia goldstein we have one vacancy when a vacancy exists the board may have a vote ofentatives that have matters before the board and the senior building inspector and jeanine from the if the department of health and mr. pacheco at this point will you go over the boards meeting board guidelines and conduct the swearing process. the board requests you turn off all electronic devices appellants and permit holders and representatives each has 7 minutes to print e present their cases and 3 moinz minutes for rebuttals. members of the public who are not affiliated with the parties have up to 3 minutes to address the board to assist the board the members of the public who wish to speak are asked but not required to present a card to the staff. speakers and pens are available on the left side of the podium the board welcomes your comments and questions dollar survey forms on the left side of the podium if you have questions please speak to board staff before the board meeting or call the board office on mission street room 304. this meeting is broadcast live on sfgovtv cable c

mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion from commissioner fong to uphold the denial on the basis the tree is healthy and on that motion on that basis commissioner hurtado president is absent, commissioner honda. >> thank you the vote is 3 to zero this september 17, 2014, is upheld on that basis. >> thank you next item item 67 is a jurisdiction request for the subject property the board received a letter taking jurisdiction over the jurisdiction permit which waltz issued by the department of public works on april 2014 the appeal period end and this request was filed on june the permit holder is

mr. pacheco. >> the motion is from the vice president to uphold both denials and you said is the basis that the denials are appropriate or referencing the new ordinance. >> the new ordinance. >> both denials on the new smf ordinance. >> so on that motion to uphold both denials on that basis. commissioner fung. and wanting is recused. commissioner honda. thank you. the vote is 3 to zero both denials are upheld >> vice mayor there is there's no further business. before the board. >> thank you we're days and t interfere with equipment in the room. please rise for the pledge of allegiance. of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all i'd like to take roll. president mazzucco commissioner turman. commissioner marshall. commissioner dejesus. commissioner loftus. supervisor tang. in route. mr. president, you have a quorum and we have the chief of police chief suhr and the office of complaint joyce. welcome to the september 3, 2014, police commission meeting with all due respect call the consent calendar

mr. pacheco >> so again, a motion from commissioner fung to grant this appeal and deny the permit and again, with the finding the permit didn't come ply with the new smf ordinance on that motion commissioner president lazarus. the president is recused commissioner honda >> thank you. the vote is 3 to zero this permit is denied with that finding thank you. okay. so we have two items remaining that is 9 ab appeal. and both at&t california versus the department of public works use and mapping 1411 is the denial of the utility excavation permit for the public right-of-way relate to a mount facility and the next appealing the denial on may 28, 2014, of the utility excavation in the public right-of-way with a mounted facility since those are denials we've started with at&t mr. johnson you'll start and have up to 14 minutes to present our case. - your case. >> thank you, commissioners. can i request that the exhibit be placed on the overhead i'd like to begin by addressing the departments brief and correct a few things for the administration record. there are some statement in the departments brie

mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion from commissioner fung to over rule the denial and plant the permit removal without replacement with the finding that the palms are fixtures and not street trees. >> the palms in containers are fixtures you are turns. >> with that, paemgz and containers are fixtures and not street trees on that motion to overrule with that finding commissioner hurtado. commissioner president lazarus. commissioner honda. no >> the vote is 3 to one because of the boards vacancy this denial t is overly ruled this permit shall issue with that finding thank you. >> okay. thank you he. move on to item number 6. this is appeal matthew vs. the department of public works bureau street and mapping on missouri street protesting the issuance of july to bell engineering of a utility excavation permit to install a new permit this is with the appellant >> commissioner i'll recuse myself in the past it is the conflict and ask commissioner hurtado to chair this portion. >> thank you. the other microphone, sir >> use the other microphone please. commissioners. >> would you like copies of the p

mr. pacheco >> so again, a motion from commissioner fung to grant this appeal and deny the permit and again, with the finding the permit didn't come ply with the new smf ordinance on that motion commissioner president lazarus. the president is recused commissioner honda >> thank you. the vote is 3 to zero this permit is denied with that finding thank you. okay. so we have two items remaining that is 9 ab appeal. and

mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion from commisssioner finkle to over rule dpw and deny this permit. can you repeat your basis again >> number one compliance. >> on the basis it didn't comply with article 27. >> thank you. so again to deny the permit with the finding that this permit didn't compile with article 27 the new smf ordinance on that motion to overly rule and deny this commissioner hurtado. the president is recused commissioner honda >> thank you. the vote is 3 to zero dpw is recovery e over rules and the permit is denied. >> madam president can we take >> welcome back to the september 10, 2014, of the san francisco board of appeals we're now calling item 7 john and teresa versus the department of public works with the planning prowling approval on union street pretending the alteration recreation and parks department the roof handle rail inform comply with the complaint. and we will start with the appellants. we have 7 minutes to present their case to the board. >> i do have a couple of houvenz if you'll be interested in one what from our packet and another is a survey. >>

mr. pacheco. >> the motion is from the vice president to uphold both denials and you said is the basis that the denials are appropriate or referencing the new ordinance. >> the new ordinance. >> both denials on the new smf ordinance. >> so on that motion to uphold both denials on that basis. commissioner fung. and wanting is recused. commissioner honda. thank you. the vote is 3 to zero both denials are upheld >> vice mayor there is there's no further business. before the board. >> thank you we're (clapping.) sociogood morning, everyone. good morning. good morning. my name is harlan kelly the director of the public utilities commission i'm excited to welcome you here today, it's a diverse group we're going to talk about the issues we're looking and facing the drought. the puc you're in headquarters of the puc it's a if you don't know about the puc we're responsible for water wastewater and power our water system is a vast water system we provide water to 2.6 million yourselves in the bay area not only in the retail but wholesale swill as the a regional issue we talk about the water not only

mr. pacheco >> we have a motion from the vice president to uphold this 25 day suspension on the basis it's reasonable under the circumstances. on that motion >> commissioner fung. commissioner president lazarus. commissioner honda. thank you. the vote is 4 to zero the 25 die suspension is upheld >> thank you. the next item is item 6 appeal shawn at the scene properties vs. the department of building inspection for the properties on stephen son street denying the alteration permit for a new street address in question 1 10th street we can hear if the appellants agent you have 7 minutes >> good afternoon, commissioners my name is pat. i'm a licensed civil engineer representing the shoring at the scene company. this is basically a civil engineering policy how you address to the city in my private life my brother and i are the leading authorities on the streets in san francisco we're recreating the history in san francisco if you see maps on san francisco that's our recreation before 1906 when everything burdened or burned we've loaned the documents to the bureau and the mapping has original re

mr. pacheco. >> we have a motion in the vice president to grant the appeal and overrule the dpw and deny this permit and with the finding this permit didn't to the ply with the new smf ordinance ordinance 76 dash 14 anything else on that motion to overly overrule commissioner fung the president is absent commissioner honda thank you vote is 3 to zero because of the boards vacancy only 3 votes are needed this permit is over ruled with those finding thank you. >> okay cynthia goldstein will it makes sense to take item 12 before the break. >> i'm not sure the parties are here is the appellant attorneys in the room sure. >> so what we will do to call whether or not a continuance is needed i'll call items 12 abc all of them filed by marie vs. the department of building inspection some with the department approval on filling burn street to zoning property, llc of an alteration priority to convert to a single-family home with new stairs and staircases and an alteration for the units and also a plumbing permit for a forced air furnace we can hear from the permit holders attorney they make a requ

mr. pacheco i'm cynthia goldstein we have one vacancy when a vacancy exists the board may have a