dr. pedro resca. and this order and citation required -- would have required mr. resca or dr. resca to withdraw from the mine until such time as he could receive some refresher safety training. in this case, performance coal alleged that the order and citation were issued in retal for a complaint which they, performance coal, had filed, regarding an incident which took place in the mine and involved dr. resca. again, in this case, we found that the citation and order were not issued as a result of any retaliation by mr. page or anybody in msha. it was issued as a result of the personal observations of several msha inspectors regarding dr. resca's conduct and behavior in the mine. and i would note that this was the order and citation that was also cited by the umwa in their complaint to us, all be it from a very different perspective. the third incident involved a meeting between dr. -- between mr. page and dr. shemel to discuss the resca citation and order, and that took place because dr. resca was a subcontractor for dr. shemel. during this meeting, mr. page allegedly threaten