mr. salgado and mr. calabrese, do you agree there's a need for legislation that creates a legal framework for how and when law enforcement can access data stored abroad? >> i can speak for google on this. we think that there is a need for legislation that addresses the access by u.s. law enforcement of users who are not in the united states who are not u.s. citizens. the focus on where the data is stored doesn't make sense to us. we think it's would lead to some bad results. but putting aside that one feature of the leeds act, we think there are ways to structure in that don't take into account and aren't so wed to data localization as the feature that would still satisfy the spirit and ames of the proposal. >> do you agree with that? >> first, he appreciate your support for the leads leahy bill as underlining and being added to by your leeds act. certainly this is a complicated area. cdt believes that you started an incredibly important conversation. you've created some tools in terms of em lat reform t

mr. salgado work at yahoo! antarctica served as special counsel in computer crime and intellectual property section, doj cookies also been a law professor at stanford, georgetown, george mason. he received his undergraduate degree university of new mexico, law degree at yale. next is mr. calabrese, vice president of policy for the center of democracy and technology. before joining cdt he worked as a legislative console, american civil liberties union, washington office. before that he was legal counsel massachusetts senate majority leader. mr. calabrese graduated from harvard and law degree from georgetown. finally, ms. espinel, president and ceo, the software alliance which advocates on behalf of software industry before governments. she has previously served for over a decade in the white house under both republican and democrat administrations including being nominated to be the first u.s. intellectual property enforcement coordinator. she graduated from georgetown's school of foreign service, has an lom fro

mr. salgado, we heard some discussions about the case in 2010 essentially vindicated that your position that the digital due process coalition and also shares the words required whenever law enforcement seeks a subscriber content. and while the decision is binding law technically only in the sixth circuit, doj and federal agencies testified that they are following its nationwide. so could you just provide benefits to speak to why is the statutory reform still necessary? >> it's true that the law right now the constitutional law and the way we are behaving does reflect a a warrant is required by the agencies the be basically agencies or criminal agencies in order to get the content of communications we think that's right that we have an unconstitutional provision and we can fix that. we have a very elegant way in the current bill that takes care of those quickly, easily. doesn't actually change the way that agencies are going to be responding and the way that they they have been for the last five years. we certainly appreciate the concerns that have been raised in a rather long debate over th

mr. salgado worked at yahoo!. and prior to that served as special consult in commuter crime and intellectual property section doj. he has also been a law professor at stanford, georgetown, george mason. he received his undergraduate degree university of new mexico, law degree yale. next is chris sal calla breecy. he worked at the american civil liberties union. before that he was legal council massachusetts senate majority leader. mr. cala bx rese graduated from harvard and a law degree from georgetown. finally victoria espinel, president and ceo software alliance which advocates on software industry before governments. she has previously served for over a decade in the white house under both republican and democrat administrations, including being nominated to be the first intellectual property enforcement coordinator. graduated from school of foreign service, has an llm from the london school of economics and a law degree from georgetown. i want to thank all of you for appearing. let's do it in the order that yo

mr. salgado worked at yahoo, and prior to that served ago special counsel. campaign 2016. taking you on the road to the white house. >> at the oversight role of congress and u.s. intelligence and national security manners -- matters. david sanger of the new york times moderates this discussion. and welcomemorning to day two. we continue our examination of the state of u.s. intelligence thosehe perspective of who provide oversight from congress. congress plays a critical role in ensuring the health and operation of intelligence. the house are meant select community -- committee on intelligence [indiscernible] we are pleased to have congressman devin nunes and the ranking minority member congressman adam schiff with us this morning. they represent the great state and have long and distinguished records of performing rigorous oversight of intelligence in the interest of accountability and transparency. our distinguished panelists are joined by david sanger, chief washington correspondent for the new york times. we are thrilled to have you with us today is well. >> thank you a

mr. salgado worked at yahoo, and prior to that served ago special counsel.