permitted in 1995 when owned by the hawkins replace the decking and the most deck was illegal built by mr. skais i didn't himself in 2008, he had an approval for a reroof there's no indication he built a roof deck but he did anyway and he didn't rebuild it the way it was he extended it to the north side and the issue before you today is if you want to approve that roof deck that's fine but some of the neighbors my may object he encroached across the property line into the neighbors property this is also from the gentleman's graft it's a good graphic a two inch gap between the buildings the assumed property line is halfway between them they have to gap nobody knows the property line so you don't encroach on someone's property, however, when this deck was built the column the corner post put on the edge of the roof and covered with first lap siding and piece of trim the trim has been taken off to the encroachment is three-quarters of an inch long. >> thank you yourself time is up. >> thank you is there any public comment? in support of the dr requester? i believe there's one public commenter >> we