53
53
Oct 27, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 53
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch recognized for five minutes for opening statement. >> mr. irman, ranking member that could you ski, my name is peter j. welch. no the could be confused with anybody else. we represent the 16,000 franchised and new car and truck dealers throughout the country of the draft bill before you today contains a number of provisions that nada supports including several provisions for recall notice an completion rates. dealers support 100% recall completion rate. we commend the subcommittee for efforts to help us achieve that goal. recall system congress enacted depends on new car dealers to fix millions of vehicles now under recall. last i don't year alone, our members performed 59 million warranty and recall repairs. unfortunately we're set to break the record again today, with burgeoning number of recalls being issued. for owners of recalled vehicles, it is local dealer remedies the defect and nonconformance at no charge to the owner. when owners receive a recall notice fail to act many dealers on own initiative will contact customers to schedule a
mr. welch recognized for five minutes for opening statement. >> mr. irman, ranking member that could you ski, my name is peter j. welch. no the could be confused with anybody else. we represent the 16,000 franchised and new car and truck dealers throughout the country of the draft bill before you today contains a number of provisions that nada supports including several provisions for recall notice an completion rates. dealers support 100% recall completion rate. we commend the...
44
44
Oct 22, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 44
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch, you're recognized for five minutes please for an opening statement. >> mr. chairman, ranking member schakowsky, i'm peter kawelch. i'm president of the national automobile dealers agency. a nationwide trade association that represents the new car and truck deal earls throughout the country. the draft bill before you today contains a number of provisions nada supports. dealers support 100% recall completion rate and, again, we commend the subcommittee for its efforts to help us achieve that goal. the recall system congress enacted depends on new car dealers to fix the millions of vehicles now under recall. last year alone, our members performed 59 million warranty and recall repairs and unfortunately set to break this record again today with the burgeoning number of recalls that are being issued. for the owners of recalled vehicles, it is the local dealer that remedies the defect or noncome form answer. with a notice and fail to act, many dealers contact their customers to schedule a
mr. welch, you're recognized for five minutes please for an opening statement. >> mr. chairman, ranking member schakowsky, i'm peter kawelch. i'm president of the national automobile dealers agency. a nationwide trade association that represents the new car and truck deal earls throughout the country. the draft bill before you today contains a number of provisions nada supports. dealers support 100% recall completion rate and, again, we commend the subcommittee for its efforts to help us...
68
68
Oct 23, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 68
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> the gentlelady yield specter mr. welch, your recognize for five minutes. >> mr. chairman, ranking member schakowsky, my name is peter welch. not to be confused with anybody else. under president national automobile dealers association. n.a.b. is a nationwide trade association that represents the interest of over 16,000 franchise -- nadh -- new car and truck dealers throughout the country. the draft bill before today contains a number of provisions n.a.d.a. supports including several provisions to improve recall notification and completion rates. dealers support 100% recall completion rate and again recommend the subcommittee for its efforts help us achieve that goal. the recall system congress enacted depends on your car does to fix the millions of vehicles that are now under recall. last year alone our members performed 59 million warranty and recall repairs and, unfortunately, we are set to break that record again today with the burgeoning number of recalls that are being issued. for the owners of recall the vehicles it is their local dealer who remedies the def
. >> the gentlelady yield specter mr. welch, your recognize for five minutes. >> mr. chairman, ranking member schakowsky, my name is peter welch. not to be confused with anybody else. under president national automobile dealers association. n.a.b. is a nationwide trade association that represents the interest of over 16,000 franchise -- nadh -- new car and truck dealers throughout the country. the draft bill before today contains a number of provisions n.a.d.a. supports including...
59
59
Oct 23, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 59
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch -- so you can't yes or no? >> we don't have consensus so -- >> thank you. mr. welch, your organization has expressed concerns of the impact of the dealers. my question to you, when consumers bring their recalled cars to a dealer for repairs, and they need a loaner car, do you think dealers should be able to loan them vehicles with unrepaired safety recalls? i ask you for a yes or no answer. >> if the vehicle has been deemed to be unsafe to drive either by the oems or by nhtsa, we would not put one of those cars in the hands of a consumer. >> so that is a no? you do not think dealers should be able to loan vehicles that have -- with unrepaired safety recalls. >> no, i said if they're unsafe to drive we wouldn't put them out there. if it involved -- >> you would not loan them then as loaner cars? >> if it's unsafe to drive. if it had a, you know, a door jam sticker or a misprinted number -- >> that is not quite my answer is but i'll just go back to the first panel and nhtsa said that every recall is a safety issue. there are no frivolous recalls. it's a simple que
mr. welch -- so you can't yes or no? >> we don't have consensus so -- >> thank you. mr. welch, your organization has expressed concerns of the impact of the dealers. my question to you, when consumers bring their recalled cars to a dealer for repairs, and they need a loaner car, do you think dealers should be able to loan them vehicles with unrepaired safety recalls? i ask you for a yes or no answer. >> if the vehicle has been deemed to be unsafe to drive either by the oems or...
58
58
Oct 28, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 58
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch: there are two reasons why this deserves our support. this is good public policy. this finally unleashes the hackles of the congress. and mr. rogers, you are going to have an opportunity through your appropriation committee, republicans and democrats, to do their job. second, it averts enormous increases in medicare part b premiums. third, it keeps social security disability funds solvent through 2022 and there are a number of other things. but the second major reason why this is so important is this, it is an agreement. we have finally come together through the leadership of speaker boehner and leader pelosi to legislate. and we have been part of a legislative body that is on strike. it hasn't legislated. and we cannot underestimate the power that is unleashed by the capacity of this congress to give certainty to the american people and to our agencies as to what comes ahead and what they have to do. secondly, what speaker boehner did and what speaker boehner did, and i am so indebted to him, he has two weapons when used is threatened and that is the threat of shu
mr. welch: there are two reasons why this deserves our support. this is good public policy. this finally unleashes the hackles of the congress. and mr. rogers, you are going to have an opportunity through your appropriation committee, republicans and democrats, to do their job. second, it averts enormous increases in medicare part b premiums. third, it keeps social security disability funds solvent through 2022 and there are a number of other things. but the second major reason why this is so...
58
58
Oct 9, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 58
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch's document into the record. i have one last question mr. horn. you told a bunch of us on this committee, after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the cast that your engineers didn't know the answer. in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineers germany in the first place. correct? >> that's my understanding. >> those people -- that information about that discrepancy never made it to germany so they can tell your people what was wrong? is that what you're deafing here to-- testifying here today? >> i don't understand. >> you said your people were trying to figure out why there was a discrepancy. there were some people who knew. those are the people who wrote that code in the first place. are you telling me that they never told your u.s. people what the problem was and why there was a discrepancy? >> people who investigated the study in detail, the study and developed software fixes w
mr. welch's document into the record. i have one last question mr. horn. you told a bunch of us on this committee, after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the cast that your engineers didn't know the answer. in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineers germany in the first place. correct? >> that's my understanding....
65
65
Oct 29, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 65
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch: there are two reasons why this deserves our support. this is good public policy. this finally unleashes the hackles of the congress. and mr. rogers, you are going to have an opportunity through your appropriation committee, republicans and democrats, to do their job. second, it averts enormous increases in medicare part b premiums. third, it keeps social security disability funds solvent through 2022 and there are a number of other things. but the second major reason why this is so important is this, it is an agreement. we have finally come together through the leadership of speaker boehner and leader pelosi to legislate. and we have been part of a legislative body that is on strike. it hasn't legislated. and we cannot underestimate the power that is unleashed by the capacity of this congress to give certainty to the american people and to our agencies as to what comes ahead and what they have to do. secondly, what speaker boehner did and what speaker boehner did, and i am so indebted to him, he has two weapons when used is threatened and that is the threat of shu
mr. welch: there are two reasons why this deserves our support. this is good public policy. this finally unleashes the hackles of the congress. and mr. rogers, you are going to have an opportunity through your appropriation committee, republicans and democrats, to do their job. second, it averts enormous increases in medicare part b premiums. third, it keeps social security disability funds solvent through 2022 and there are a number of other things. but the second major reason why this is so...
111
111
Oct 23, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 111
favorite 0
quote 0
with that, i'd like to yield in gratitude to mr. welchor his great leadership and yield the floor. peter welch of vermont. mr. welch: thank you. thank you, leader. every democrat, ironically, agrees with president ronald reagan. america pays its bills. we would never default on our creditors and jeopardize the full faith and credit of the united states and impose unnecessary additional interest costs on american taxpayers. that's number one. number two, the debt ceiling, as we know, does not authorize a nickel in new spending. it allows america to meet the obligations that it's already committed to. in fact, the price budget, tom price's budget, supported by 228 republicans, passed on march 25 of 2015, built in it a requirement that in order to meet the budget the republicans supported and incidentally i opposed and all of us here opposed, in addition to our national debt of $2 trilli. so in march, they voted for a budget that they're now sabotaging in october. you can't have it both ways. if you vote for a budget and you make obligations
with that, i'd like to yield in gratitude to mr. welchor his great leadership and yield the floor. peter welch of vermont. mr. welch: thank you. thank you, leader. every democrat, ironically, agrees with president ronald reagan. america pays its bills. we would never default on our creditors and jeopardize the full faith and credit of the united states and impose unnecessary additional interest costs on american taxpayers. that's number one. number two, the debt ceiling, as we know, does not...
49
49
Oct 9, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 49
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch's document into the record. i just have one last question because you told the whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014 everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the past that your engineers didn't know the answer but in fact the discrepancy was because of a willful act of engineers in germany in the first place, correct? >> that's my understanding. >> and that information about that discrepancy never made it to germany said they could tell your people what was wrong? is that what you are testifying to hear today? >> i don't understand what you're trying to say. >> he said your people were trying to figure out why there was a discrepancy but there were some people who knew and those people who wrote that deceptive -- in the first place pretty telling me that they never told the u.s. people what the problem was and why there was a discrepancy? >> this was an investigative stud
mr. welch's document into the record. i just have one last question because you told the whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014 everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the past that your engineers didn't know the answer but in fact the discrepancy was because of a willful act of engineers in germany in the first place, correct? >> that's my...
45
45
Oct 8, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 45
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch's document into the record. >> so ordered. >> mr. horn, you told a whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the tasks, that your engineers didn't know the answer. but in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineer in germany in the first place, correct? >> that's my understanding, yes. >> and those people, that information about that discrepancy never made it to germany so they could tell your people what was wrong, is that what you're testifying to here today? >> i don't understand what you're trying to say. >> well, you said your people were trying to figure out why there was a discrepancy. >> right. >> but there were some people who knew. and those were the people who wrote that deceptive code in the first place. are you telling me they never told the u.s. people what the problem was and why the discrepancy? >> the people who in
mr. welch's document into the record. >> so ordered. >> mr. horn, you told a whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the tasks, that your engineers didn't know the answer. but in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineer in germany in the first place, correct? >> that's...
122
122
Oct 8, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 122
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> gentleman kneeled yields back and recognize mr. welch f. >> thank you for coming here. we've got vw customers. we've got vw dealers in red states and in blue states and they're mad as hell. some of the questions that came to me from vermonters, and i want to submit this to the record, and ask you, vw, to this answer these questions from vermonters. but let me just give you a reflection of what these say. number one, what will you vw be reading when you're in jail? number two, i just wonder what the hell you were thinking. three, how can we help out vermonters who got these lemons? four, why should the united states allow you to sell vehicles in this country? five, vw is the lance armstrong of the industry. these questions go on and on and reflect the white-heat anger that folks have about the deception. one last question, how do you sleep at night? how do you call yourself a member of the human race when you knowingly poisoned the planet. then i talk to some of our vw dealers, they care about their customers. and i know you individually do as well. and one of the dealer
. >> gentleman kneeled yields back and recognize mr. welch f. >> thank you for coming here. we've got vw customers. we've got vw dealers in red states and in blue states and they're mad as hell. some of the questions that came to me from vermonters, and i want to submit this to the record, and ask you, vw, to this answer these questions from vermonters. but let me just give you a reflection of what these say. number one, what will you vw be reading when you're in jail? number two, i...
92
92
Oct 8, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 92
favorite 0
quote 0
i now recognize mr. welch for five minutes. >> thank you very much. sir, thank you for coming in.but i just want to express to you some of the things that i've been hearing from vermonters. first of all, we've got vw customers, vw dealers, in red states and blue states, and they're mad as hell. some of the questions that came to me from vermonters, and i want to submit this for the record and ask you, vw, to answer these questions from vermonters. let me just give you a reflection of what these say. number one, what will you, vw, be reading when you're in jail? number two, i just wonder what the hell you were thinking. three, how can we help out vermonters who got these lemons? four, why should the u.s. allow you to sell vehicles in this country? five, vw is the lance armstrong of the industry. these questions go on and on and reflect the white heat anger that folks have about the deception. how do you call yourself a member of the human race when you knowingly poisoned the planet? then i talked to vw dealers. they care about their customers. i know you individually do as well. on
i now recognize mr. welch for five minutes. >> thank you very much. sir, thank you for coming in.but i just want to express to you some of the things that i've been hearing from vermonters. first of all, we've got vw customers, vw dealers, in red states and blue states, and they're mad as hell. some of the questions that came to me from vermonters, and i want to submit this for the record and ask you, vw, to answer these questions from vermonters. let me just give you a reflection of what...
40
40
Oct 27, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 40
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. peter welch, president of the national automobile dealers association and mr. michael wilson, the ceo of the automotive recyclers association. we do appreciate all of you being here with us this morning. we're grateful for your forbearance during the first panel. and we'll begin with mr. bane wol, and you're recognized for five minutes. >> thank you. given the size of this panel, i'm reminded of what former senator john warner said when he became elizabeth taylor's sixth husband. he said i know what to do, i'm just not sure how to make it interesting. so here i go. thank you for the opportunity to testify today on behalf of 12 global oems based in the u.s. and europe and's yeah. our companies represent about 75% of the marketplace. our industry will put about a billion, a billion new cars on the road over the next decade around the world. with more than 15% of those on the road in the u.s. that's a lot of steel and aluminum and an astounding amount of production and massive job implications. but even more striking than scale is a game changing ability that will
mr. peter welch, president of the national automobile dealers association and mr. michael wilson, the ceo of the automotive recyclers association. we do appreciate all of you being here with us this morning. we're grateful for your forbearance during the first panel. and we'll begin with mr. bane wol, and you're recognized for five minutes. >> thank you. given the size of this panel, i'm reminded of what former senator john warner said when he became elizabeth taylor's sixth husband. he...
527
527
Oct 21, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 527
favorite 0
quote 3
mr. welch: it only has to do with whether america will pay its bills for obligations already incurred. many of those obligations, by the way, are for expenditures that i vigorously opposed, trillions of dollars on the wars in iraq and afghanistan. unpaid for. trillions of dollars in tax cuts for the very wealthy that -- unpaid for. but the united states of america in good times and bad, through republican presidents and democratic presidents, and republican-led and democratic-led congresses has always paid its bills. always. we have done it for two reasons. first, it's the right thing to do. a promise made is a promise kept. an obligation incurred is an obligation honored. -- peaker, a nation confident nation keeps its words. a confident nation pays its bills, not some of them, it pays all of them. second, running from our creditors, stiffing them, picking and choosing who to pay among them is as fiscally reckless as it is dishonorable. this new theory that america can actually consider it feas
mr. welch: it only has to do with whether america will pay its bills for obligations already incurred. many of those obligations, by the way, are for expenditures that i vigorously opposed, trillions of dollars on the wars in iraq and afghanistan. unpaid for. trillions of dollars in tax cuts for the very wealthy that -- unpaid for. but the united states of america in good times and bad, through republican presidents and democratic presidents, and republican-led and democratic-led congresses has...
42
42
Oct 23, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 42
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. peter welch, president of the national automobile dealers association, and mr.michael wilson the ceo of the automotive recyclers association. we do appreciate all of you being here with us this morning. we will begin this panel with mr. bainwol. you are recognized for your opening statement please. >> thank you chairman, ranking member schakowsky and members of the subcommittee. given the size of the panel i'm reminded of what the former senator john warner said when he became elizabeth taylor's sixth husband. here i go. thank you for the opportunity to testify on behalf of the 12 global. our company our companies represent about 75% of the marketplace. our industry will put about eight days for a billion new cars on the road. with more than 16% of those in the u.s.. that is a lot of steel and aluminum and an astounding level of massive jobs and duplications. but even more striking than the scale is the game change game changing innovation mobility. they are generating enormous social benefits. the companies are investing about $100 billion a year in research in
mr. peter welch, president of the national automobile dealers association, and mr.michael wilson the ceo of the automotive recyclers association. we do appreciate all of you being here with us this morning. we will begin this panel with mr. bainwol. you are recognized for your opening statement please. >> thank you chairman, ranking member schakowsky and members of the subcommittee. given the size of the panel i'm reminded of what the former senator john warner said when he became...
76
76
Oct 2, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 76
favorite 0
quote 0
welch and i yield back my time. thank you. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back. the gentleman from california. mr. royce: i yield one minute to the gentleman from illinois, mr. doled. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from illinois is recognized for one minute. want to thank my good friend from california, the chairman, for yielding me the time and also want to thank my good friend from pennsylvania for bringing this piece of legislation. supporting victims of iranian terrorism is a cause that every single member of this body should be able to support, regardless of where they stand on the iranian nuclear agreement. under no circumstances should we be ignoring the victims of iran's terrorism while simultaneously rewarding the greatest state sponsor of terror the world has seen. make no mistake, under this administration's agreement with iran, iran will be receiving approximately $150 billion in sanctions relief in new funding almost immediately while american victims of iranian terrorism, whether it be bombings, kid nappings and the like -- kidnappings and the like, murder, are going basicall
welch and i yield back my time. thank you. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back. the gentleman from california. mr. royce: i yield one minute to the gentleman from illinois, mr. doled. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from illinois is recognized for one minute. want to thank my good friend from california, the chairman, for yielding me the time and also want to thank my good friend from pennsylvania for bringing this piece of legislation. supporting victims of iranian...
177
177
Oct 1, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 177
favorite 0
quote 1
welch and i yield back my time. thank you. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back. the gentleman from california. mr. royce: i yield one minute to the gentleman from illinois, mr. doled. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from illinois is recognized for one minute. want to thank my good friend from california, the chairman, for yielding me the time and also want to thank my good friend from pennsylvania for bringing this piece of legislation. supporting victims of iranian terrorism is a cause that every single member of this body should be able to support, regardless of where they stand on the iranian nuclear agreement. under no circumstances should we be ignoring the victims of iran's terrorism while simultaneously rewarding the greatest state sponsor of terror the world has seen. make no mistake, under this administration's agreement with iran, iran will be receiving approximately $150 billion in sanctions relief in new funding almost immediately while american victims of iranian terrorism, whether it be bombings, kid nappings and the like -- kidnappings and the like, murder, are going basicall
welch and i yield back my time. thank you. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back. the gentleman from california. mr. royce: i yield one minute to the gentleman from illinois, mr. doled. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from illinois is recognized for one minute. want to thank my good friend from california, the chairman, for yielding me the time and also want to thank my good friend from pennsylvania for bringing this piece of legislation. supporting victims of iranian...
70
70
Oct 27, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN2
tv
eye 70
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. republican, took me under his wing and guided me. and i'm privileged to serve now now -- i mean, our whole vermont delegation is here. senator sanders, congressman welch and myself. not many other states could do that and fit all of them in this body. and lastly, madam president, i remember what a thrill it was to tell my wife, marcel, when i cast my first vote. and now 40 years later, i can still tell her about the 15,000th vote, and shns, she and our -- she knows, she and our children and grandchildren, are the most important people in my life. so, madam president, i don't want to delay the senate's work further but i thank you all. i thank you for friendships that have meant more to me and my family than i can possibly say. and i look forward to continuing serving here. thank you, very, very much. [applause] the presiding officer: under the previous order, the question occurs on amendment number 2587, offered by the senator from vermont, mr. leahy. a senator: ask for the yeas and nays. the presiding officer: is there a sufficient second? there appears to be. the yeas and nays are ordered. there's two minutes equally divided. mrs. feinstein: madam p
mr. republican, took me under his wing and guided me. and i'm privileged to serve now now -- i mean, our whole vermont delegation is here. senator sanders, congressman welch and myself. not many other states could do that and fit all of them in this body. and lastly, madam president, i remember what a thrill it was to tell my wife, marcel, when i cast my first vote. and now 40 years later, i can still tell her about the 15,000th vote, and shns, she and our -- she knows, she and our children and...
420
420
Oct 2, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 420
favorite 0
quote 0
welch. not surprisingly, however, not one dime has been paid to the family yet, today we stand before this country. we find ourselves dealing with an administration that wants to lift sanctions. mr. speaker, i am beside myself to think that this nation -- of this nation that we've become. america's built on bravery and freedom, and it's because of the unwavering strength and sacrifice of men and women in the military. i am forever proud of our soldiers, and i know my colleagues are here as well today too. that's why we can't let the iran terror continue, and we need to do whatever we can to address the victims like ken welch and i yield back my time. thank you. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back.
welch. not surprisingly, however, not one dime has been paid to the family yet, today we stand before this country. we find ourselves dealing with an administration that wants to lift sanctions. mr. speaker, i am beside myself to think that this nation -- of this nation that we've become. america's built on bravery and freedom, and it's because of the unwavering strength and sacrifice of men and women in the military. i am forever proud of our soldiers, and i know my colleagues are here as well...
73
73
Oct 16, 2015
10/15
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 73
favorite 0
quote 0
mr. welch's document into the record. >> so ordered. >> i just have one last question, mr.rn, because you told a whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the tasks, that your engineers didn't know the answer. but in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineer in germany in the first place, correct? >> that's my understanding, yes. >> and those people, that information about that discrepancy never made it to germany so they could tell your people what was wrong, is that what you're testifying to here today? >> i don't understand what you're trying to say. >> well, you said your people were trying to figure out why there was a discrepancy. >> right. >> but there were some people who knew. and those were the people who wrote that deceptive code in the first place. are you telling me they never told the u.s. people what the problem was and why the discrepancy? >> the people w
mr. welch's document into the record. >> so ordered. >> i just have one last question, mr.rn, because you told a whole bunch of us on this committee that after that west virginia university study in may of 2014, everybody was running around trying to figure out what was going on with these cars and why there was a discrepancy between the tasks, that your engineers didn't know the answer. but in fact, the discrepancy was because of a willful act of some engineer in germany in the...