mr. wiener? >> no. >> mr. wiener, no. >> mr. matheson? mr. butter field? >> no. >> mr. butter field no mr. mallson? >> no. >> mr. mallson no mr. barrow? >> no. >> mr. barrow votes no mr. hill? mr. hill, no. ms. matsui? ms. matsui no ms. christensen? no. mrs. castor? ms. castor no. mr. sarbanes? no. mr. sarbanes no mr. murphy of connecticut? mr. murphy, no. mr. space? mr. space, no. mr. mcnortherny? mr. mcnortherny, no. mr. braillely? i'm sore. i apologize. ms. sutton? >> no. >> ms. sutton, no. mr. brayly? mr. brayly votes. no mr. welsh? mr. welsh no. mr. barton? mr. barton eight. mr. hall? mr. hall, eight. mr. upton? mr. upton, eight. mr. stern? mr. stern, aye. mr. deal? mr. deal aye. mr. whitfield? mr. whitfield aye. mr. ship cuss? mr. shattuck. mr. status aye. mr. blunt? mr. blunt, aye. mr. boyer? mr. boyer, aye. mr. rod dan know vich? mr. rad done know vich, aye. mr. pitts? mr. pitts, eye. ms. bono max? ms. bono max aye a. mr. walden? >> aye. >> mr. walden, aye. mr. terry? mr. rogers? >> aye. >> mr. rogers, aye. mrs. my rick? mrs. my rick aye. mr. sullivan? mr. sulli

mr. wiener if he still wants to be recognized. >> the gentlelady e gentlelady yields to mr. sarbanes. >> i thank the gentlelady for yielding. i think our concern about this amendment is on its face it seems pretty straight forward and intuitive and in the context in which you placed it has some attraction i guess but i am concerned about the way it could be interpreted, and you have heard one expression or concern about the interpretation that could be made with respect to this amendment and might prevent you from taking steps with respect to harmful care. i can envision a scenario -- >> debate from earlier today on amendment offered by mike rogers. we are back in the committee room life. we see chairman henry waxman getting the mark upstarted again. live coverage on c-span2. [inaudible conversations] >> without objection the amendment will be considered and the gentle lady from california is recognized. >> thank you mr. chairman. you know, i would prefer if it isn't to bring the abortion debate into the health reform debate, but from years of experience and this body and co

mr. wiener.udible conversations] [inaudible conversations] the chair recognizes and eshoo from california, do you have an amendment at the desk? >> i do, the amendments at the desk is members 001 eshoo. >> without objection the amendment will be considered as read and the gentle lady is recognized to explain her amendment can i thank you mr. chairman. i'm very pleased to offer this amendment which is really the culmination of nearly three years of work to create a regulatory path way before fda approval of by a similar or follow on biologics. i know that this is an issue which you also cared deeply about mr. chairman, and while we have different views on some of the details of our legislative approaches we both share the same goal of bringing new competition and lower prices to the biotechnology sector. along with representatives inslee and the ranking member of this committee mr. barton, early this year we introduced the pathway for by a similar site which now has 142 bipartisan co-sponsors. thi

mr. wiener? mr. wiener, no. mr. matheson? mr. matheson, no. mr. butterfield? mr. butterfield, no. no.e rose? mr. barrow, no. mr. hill? mr. hill, no. ms. matsui? ms. matsui, no. mrs. christensen? mrs. christensen, no. ms. katzer? ms. katzer, no. mr. sorbet? mr. sorbet, no. mr. murphy of connecticut? mr. murphy, no. mr. spade? mr. mcnewer ne? mr. mcnewer ne votes no. ms. sutton, no. mr. braillely? mr. braillely, no. mr. welch? mr. welch, no. mr. barton? mr. barton votes aye. mr. hall? mr. hall, aey. mr. upton? mr. upton, aye. mr. stern? mr. deal? mr. deal votes aye. mr. whitfield? mr. whitfield, aye. mr. schimpf kiss? aye. mr. blunt? mr. buier? mr. buier votes aye. mr. redone vits? mr. redone vits, aye. mr. pitt? mr. pitt, aye. ms. bono-mack? aye. mr. walden? mr. walden, aye. mr. terry? mr. terry votes aye. mr. rogers? mr. rogers, aye. mrs. myra? mr. sullivan? mr. sullivan votes aye. mr. murphy of pennsylvania? mr. murphy, aye. mr. burr xres? mr. burgess, aye. ms. blackburn. ms. black burn votes aye. mr. gingrey? mr. gingrey, aye. mr. skully? mr. skully, aye. mr. markey? mr. markey vote