mr. yagmire, the deck for number 5 was quote-unquote illegal. mr. yagmire has refused to disclose where he obtained that erroneous member from which member of the h.o.a. whether it's from the president or some other member, he ended up submitting a permit application which has that false information on it. they've now acknowledged it's false information. and it was submitted without msr approval and without a vote of the h.o.a. the permit application was submitted in september. the permit was issued in december of last year. i was contacted by ms. cannon in early november and after looking at her ownership, documents or deed, and the other h.o.a. documents, i contacted mr. yagmire and the h.o.a. president to request the permit with the false information be withdrawn, the false information is the claim that the deck is somehow illegal. which asked that it be withdrawn or amended. the h.o.a. refused my request and the permit was issued on december 18th of last year and we had no choice but to file this appeal. in my brief, which i hope you had time to