finally we point out that ms. dodd pointed out the implementation of proposition c has not resulted in a reduction of costs. we recommend you approve -- approve the ordinance that is before you. supervisor kim: -- supervisor chu: are there members of the public who wish to speak on items five or six? seeing none, public comment is closed. colleagues? >> motion to approve these items. thank you for your great work. all your work and helping to negotiate these rates. supervisor chu: we have a motion to send items 5 and 6 forward with recommendations. thanks to the department for all your hard work. we know you'll be back in july for the next set of rates. thank you. we will do that without objection. thank you. do we have other items before us? >> that completes the agenda. supervisor chu: we are turned. -- we are adjourned. commissioner: i would like to call the meeting to order. welcome to the meeting of the san francisco ethics commission, january 3, 2012. i will take role. commissioner studley, commissioner liu, comm