ms. flemming is prepared to go we know you haven't had a lot of time to go through the work frankly we had it compressed but we think that is worthwhile if you're going to consider to go through some of the changes in some detail and that ms. fleming and others are presented to p do that not necessary. >> thank you. superintendent deputy although, i want to review the material to make sure we're on the sampling so to speak to we're looking at version number two, that was spent earlier with a couple of small corrections per the e-mail two packet for our review one the actual proposal for your consideration this evening which excludes a narrative and spreadsheet and the second packet which i'll be speaking to and reviewing totally tonight is the supporting material there are copies for the members of the public and the proposed spend plan is online on the peace website the easier way to do a search for peace cac and you'll find it by navigating to the page know that if you're on a computer commissioners i can navigate through the consonants through the table contents and the first part is th

flemming votes no. mr. gibson? mr. gibson votes aye. mr. walls? mr. walls votes aye. ms. heart? ms. heart votes no. mr. o'rourke? mr. o'rourke votes aye. mr. scott? mr. scott votes no. mr. brooks? mr. brooks no. mr. nugent? mr. nugent votes no. mr. ashford? mr. ashford votes aye. mr. multon? mr. multon aye. mr. burns? mr. burns votes no. mr. graves? mr. graves votes no. mr. zin is an aye. ms. mcfally? mr. knight? mr. mccarthy? mr. russell? mr. russell votes no. >> clerk wall the role of any members who missed the first vote? >> there were no members. >> how am i recorded? >> you are recorded no. >> i would like to change to a yes. >> gentlemen from california? >> he is recorded as a no. >> gentlemen from georgia, mr. johnson. >> mr. johnson is recorded a no. >> any other members? i am sorry gentlemen from rhode island? >> he is recorded yes. >> any other members wish to be recognized? >> clerk will report the tally. >> 33 aye votes and 30 no votes. >> and the amendment is adopted. the question comes on amendment number 21-r1 by the gem gentlemen of texas. >> chairman? chairman votes no. mr. smith? mr. smith votes a