ms. goldstein. i had a history prepared for this particular project. she mentioned to me that it would be up to the board if they would accept it and if they do i should come up with 11 copies and i have those. if you would allow me to leave that. >> did you say it's a chronology? >> partly narrative and partly chronology. >> how many pages? >> it's about 7 pages. >> did you just now prepare it? >> i prepared it before and submitted it and ms. goldstein told me she told the other side that they could not submit in a letter and then both of you should prepare and leave it up to the board and the board will be able to decide whether to accept it. >> does anyone care for it? okay. >> i don't have a problem taking it. >> okay. that is other side seen it? >> yes. it was e-mailed to you. it is what was e-mailed to you. >> let's leave it out for now. >> it's true. >> okay. >> why don't we set it aside and if we need it for our deliberations we'll ask to view it. >> okay. ladies and gentlemen, this is a case that has become quite iconic. this is a third time t

ms. goldstein we wanted to put this off and make sure we're going to do the best we can. we have a standing objection with or berry well, they have a $600,000 contract to remove trees in golden gate park. a number of mta imply book violins that i want to go through quickly if you'll allow me to i have only 3 and a half manipulates. or berry well, is spoept to have a certified flager. they don't have one that person needs to be certified by the state they've never provided a flager especially one that's certified and they have to provide a san francisco police officer to direct traffic that's required by the blue book session 3.4 of the blue book. another issue not considered by the mta is the fact increase has to be a sidewalk closer. generally accordingly to the mta blue book they'll not issue a permit if the entire sidewalk is going to be shut down. that hadn't been credited in the issuance of this permit. also when a walk is shut down they have to have a police officer there directing traffic you might ask or berry well, if they're willing to pay for a san francisco po