ms. shlaes, any reaction to that? >> guest: i have the supply orientation so i would ask and a lot of us would ask, what would make someone want to supply something to supply a job, to supply a new-product? keene is arguing more from a keynesian perspective. i would argue from a classical perspective then when you have spending like that what happens if there are all kinds of distortions in the economy? to put it in common sense terms you don't know what the next emulous is coming if you are a little firm. you don't know where it will be. you know tax increases are coming to pay for the stimuli. you are worried about the health care situation. maybe that will help their business to have help from the government but it might put a mandate on you so you don't, you to not contribute to the economy and that very much is what is impeding our recovery. stimulus there gets in the way as opposed to helps. you can see purchases advanced over time. the government gives you get big enough offer you will buy a car this summer whe