ms. warren. mr. whitehouse, mr. wicker, mr. wyden, mr. young. >> the minorit majority leader is recognized. administered as soon as possible. >> the proclamation. >> all persons are commanded to keep silent on pain of imprisonment while the house of representatives is exhibiting to statesate of the united articles of impeachment against donald john trump, president of the united states. >> the majority leader is recognized. >> on my behalf and that of the distinguished democratic leader, i'm about to propound several unanimous consent request that will assist with the organization of the next steps of these proceedings. they deal largely with necessary paperwork incident to the trial. consent that the summons be issued in the usual until 6:00 p.m. on saturday, january 18, 2020 to file his answer with the secretary of the senate and the house of representatives have 20,l 12 noon until january 2020 two file with the secretary of the senate. the secretary of the senate be authorized to print those documents filed by the parties together to b

ms. warren customer take a listen. meant the principal gave you a handshake, wished her well and hired some bells for the job. her father, my papaw had high cheekbones, like all of the indians do. david: well perhaps ms. warren has a different definition for liar, maybe these aren't lies but a form of storytelling. the times editorial board said ms. warren is a gifted storyteller. indeed she is. her reaction former california republican party chairman and author of divided area, tom. california is the land of storytelling in hollywood, that is what they do. but there is a difference between storytelling, telling a good yarn, and being a manipulative liar. can they tell the difference between the two? >> well it's hard for americans because half the country does not hear the truth about this when you hear from cnn and the rest. remember barack obama's book we did not have a real people they were fictionalized people brought together. so the left seems to have this -- they are lying for the right reason but anything dona

ms. warren. mr. whitehouse, mr. wicker, mr. wyden, mr. young. >> a senator not in the senate chamber at the time the oath was administered, to the other senators, will make that fact known to the chair so the oath may be administered as soon as possible. >> the started in arms will make a proclamation -- the sergeant in arms will make the proclamation. here ye. all persons are committed to keep silent. while he house of exhibiting to the senate articles of impeachment against donald trump, president of the united states. >> the majority leader is recognized. >> for the information the senate, on my behalf and that of the democratic leader, i am about to propound several unanimous consent requests that will assist with the organization of the next steps of these proceedings. they deal largely with necessary paperwork, incident to the trial. therefore, i ask unanimous consent the summons be issued in the usual form, provided to the president may have until 6:00 on saturday january, 18 to file his answer with the secretary of the senate, whi

ms. warren right now are the democrats best equipped to lead that debate. any hope of restoring unity will require modesty, willingness to compromise and support the many demographics that make up the democratic coalition. for senator klobuchar that's acknowledging the depth of the nation's dysfunction. >> the decision is a blow to the front-runner and former vice president joe biden. the editorial board writes his agen agenda tinkers at the issue of health care and climate but merely restoring the status quo will not get america where it needs to go. and "the times" writes, quote, three years into the trump administration we see little advantage exchanging one over promising divisive figure in washington to another. >> both almost 80 over social security, sanders directly attacking biden's record but also forced to admit a video his aides supported should have more context. >>> two police officers shot and killed responding to domestic violence call in hawaii. authorities say the first officer to arrive outside a home found a stabbing victim. when she and

warren and amy klobuchar. >> "the times" editorial board writing, quote, ms. klobuchar and ms. warren right now are the democrats best equipped to lead that debate, may the best woman win. >> it tinkers at the edges of critical issues, but, quote merely restoring the status quo will not get america where it needs to go. and an almost trumpian take down of senator bernie sanders. "the times" writes we've seen little advantage to exchanging one divisive figure for another. >> sanders directly attacking bidens record but also forced to admit a video that one of his aides promoted probably should have had a fuller context. that video supposedly showed biden back cuts to social security. in reality biden was mocking cuts proposed by former republican house speaker paul ryan. what's interesting about that times endorsement is yes they didn't pick a clear winner there but in iowa where you pick first and second is important, so that could be part of the thinking there as you go into it because you may be able to claim victory without actually getting the most votes. >> and see what hap

ms. warren, mr. warner mr. whitehouse, mr. wicker, mr. wyden, mr. young >> any senator who is not in the senate chamber at the time the oath was administered to the other senators we will make that fact known to the chair so the oath may be administered as soon as possible. >> the sergeant at arms will make the population. >> hear ye, hear ye, hear ye, all persons are commanded to keep silent on pain of imprisonment. while the house of representatives exit exhibiting to the senate of the united states articles of impeachment against donald john trump, president of the united states. >> majority leader is recognized. >> mr. chief justice, for the information of the senate on my behalf and on that of the english democrat leader i'm about to propound several unanimous consent request level as us with the organization of the next steps of these proceedings. they deal largely with necessary paperwork incident to the trial. therefore i ask unanimous consent the summons be issued in the usual form provided so the president may have until 6:00 p.m. on satur

ms warren. mr white house. mr wicker no mr wyden. mr young no mr blumenthal. are there any senators in the chamber wishing to change his or her vote. if not the yeas are $49.00 the nays are $51.00 the motion is not agreed to. so that's the senate to the voting to defeat the motion to cool witnesses in the trial of the impeachment trial of president donald trump which means that this is effectively the end of the road so they will now be moving to vote eventually on a on the charges themselves. on the impeachment charges let's bring in. who is on capitol hill so it goes into recess and that vote of 51 to 49 and i suppose no surprises because if we were starting to hear in the last couple of days that mentum was going against the democrats and that they weren't going to win the possibility of bringing in further witnesses. that's right and that's despite today's latest development which was a report from the new york times that john bolton who had been at the top of the list most coveted by democrats to testify before the trial the new york times reporting that

ms. warren: ok, ok. so i just want three things.ack the corruption head-on so we can make the changes we need to make. make some structural change in this economy. and protect our democracy. because this is how, this is how we make certain that this government isn't just working for a handful at the top. this is about how we make certain that this government hears every voice and counts every vote. that's the america we're going to be. [cheers and applause] that's the america we're going to be. so i tell you, i'm in this fight all the way. i'm in this fight from the heart. who else is in this fight from the heart? because this is the kind of people we are. and when i think about this fight, i want you to know what i think about. i think about toasters. [laughter] you aren't surprised by this? no. i want to tell you a story about toasters. so, -- yeah, you didn't see that coming, did you? you said, kind of know how this goes. no, toasters. because here's the deal. back when i was a young mom, toasters could actually burn down houses.

ms. warren. mr. whitehouse, mr. wicker, mr. wyden, mr. young. >> the majority leader is recognized. >> a senator who is not in the senate chamber at the time the oath was administered to the other senators will make that fact known to the chair so that the oath may be administered as soon as possible. >> the sergeant at arms will make the proclamation. >> hear ye, hear ye, hear ye, all persons are commanded to keep silent on pain of imprisonment while the house of representatives is exhibiting to the senate of the united states articles of impeachment against donald john trump, president of the united states. >> the majority leader is recognized. >> for the information of the senate on my behalf and that of the distinguished democratic leader i'm about to propound several unanimous consent requests that will assist with the organization of the next steps of these proceedings. they deal largely with necessary paperwork incident to the trial. therefore, i ask unanimous consent that the summons be issued in the usual form provided the presid

ms. warren. mr. white house. mr. ricker. mr. wyden. mr. young. >> and there you have the votes. we did not hear any crossover votes there. this is on the motion by the senate majority leader mitch mcconnell to table or set aside the senator schumer amendment for documents. he already has an amendment, a second moment in the pipeline ready to go for witnesses and state department documents. at this photo -- we hear anything. anyone who it was expected to cross over it like it romney, collins, murkowski. this will go along party lines. >> there are going to be a number of amendments offered. the next one is going to be about bringing in the state department officials. everything that they did not get in this trial process and want to get here, they are trying to get through. we expect that we will see this summer routine of tabling. let's listen. >> if not, the are 53. of the names 47. the amendment is table. the democratic leader is recognized. >> mr. chief justice. i send an amendment to the desk from doctors and record from the state department and i asked her to be read. >> th

ms. warren right now are the democrats best equipped to lead that debate. may the best woman win.f the democratic candidates marched arm in arm through columbia, south carolina, to honor the reverend dr. martin luther king, jr. on this holiday that commemorates dr. king. that demonstration of arm in and arm unity underlines a point made by "the new york times" endorsement editorial. "the times" says when we spent significant time with the leading candidates the similarity of their platforms on fundamental issues became striking. our next guest john favreau was the chief speechwriter for senator barack obama and then president barack obama, which means john favreau has had a hand or more in some of the best speeches in presidential history. but speaking to american voters by the tens of millions through presidential speeches is a very different thing than speaking to them one-on-one. that is what john favreau is doing now in focus groups around the country for his podcast, the wilderness on cricket media in which he's learning more about voters now than he ever has before. here's a

ms. warren. >> no. >> mr. whitehouse. >> no. >> mr. wicker. >> aye. >> mr. wyden. >> no. >> mr. young. >> aye. >> does any senator wish to change his or her vote? if not, the yeas are 53, and the nays are 47. the amendment is tabled. >> mr. chief justice. >> the democratic leader is recognized. >> i send an amendment to the desk to prevent the selective admission of evidence and provide for appropriate handling of classified and confidential materials, and i ask that it be read. it's short. >> the clerk will report. >> the senator from new york, mr. schumer, proposes an amendment number 1290 on page 2 between lines and 4 and 5, insert the following. if during the impeachment trial of donald john trump any party seeks to admit evidence that has not been submitted as part of the record of the house of representatives and that was subject to a duly authorized subpoena, that party shall also provide the opposing party all the other documents responsive to that subpoena for the purp. e for the purposes of this paragraph, the term duly authorized subpoena includes knee subpoena issued

some of the exchanges between elizabeth warren and mr sanders were particularly frosty, with ms warrenase welcome tonight's candidates. and then there were six. six white people on the cnn stage for the last democratic debate before the voting begins. but it was the issue of gender that was the focus of a row between the two left of centre candidates, bernie sanders and elizabeth warren. after senator sanders was accused of saying a woman couldn't beat donald trump. why did you say that? well, as a matter of fact, i didn't say it. and i don't want to waste a whole lot of time on this because this is what donald trump and maybe some of the media want. the sanders campaign first called the accusation ludicrous, then said there had been crossed wires. elizabeth warren sidestepped an outright row. what did you think when senator sanders told you a woman could not win the election? i disagreed. can a woman beat donald trump? look at the men on this stage. collectively, they have lost ten elections. the only people on this stage who have won every single election that they've been in are the

ms. warren, mr. whitehouse, mr. wicker, mr. wyden, mr. young,. [silence] [silence] [silence] 's. >> the yeas or 53 the nazar 47 the motion is tables. >> the democratic leaders recognized. mr. chief justice i send at to the desk to have a subpoena for jon michael mick mulvaney. >> clerical report. >> the senator from new york mr. schumer poses an amendment number 1287. at the appropriate place in the resolving clause insert the following. section notwithstanding any provisions of this resolution pursuant to rules five and six of the rules of procedure and practice in the senate. when sitting on impeachment trials the chief justice of the united states met through the secretary of the senate will issue a subpoena by taking a testimony of jon michael mick mulvaney, and the sgt at arms is authorized to utilize the services of the deputy sgt at arms or any other employee of the senate and serving the subpoena authorized to be issued by this section. >> chief justice the. >> the geordie leaders recognized. >> i would ask for a 30s minute recess to deba

ms. warren. >> aye. >> mr. whitehouse. >> aye. >> mr. wicker. >> no. >> mr. widen. >> aye. >> mr.ng. >> no. >> mr. blumenthal. >> aye. >> are there any senators in the chamber wishing to change his or her vote. if not, the yeas are 49, the nays is 51. the motion is not agreed to. >> under the previous order the senate stands in recess subject to the call of the chair. l of tr so that's ball game, as close as we're going to get to ball game for the foreseeable future and wherever john bolton is, he's off the hook for appearing before the senate. >> i don't think that's good news to john bolton. i don't think that's good for the country and i don't think that's good for the 51 republicans who just voted against hearing testimony from a firsthand witness that the conduct that isn't in dispute. the republican defense descended into yeah, he did it, but don't impeach him. >> here we are. this is a new beginning in this conversation, and as i said a little bit earlier today, it's time for the american people to step into this, and the senate has acted, the only thing left now is to acqu

ms. warren, aye. mr. whitehouse, aye. mr. wicker, no. mr. wyden, aye. mr. young, no. mr.hange their vote? if not, the ayes are 49 and the nays are 51. the motion is not agreed to. under the previous order, the senate stands in recess subject to the call of the chair. >>> all right. that is it. history has just been made, and the very important motion to get witnesses and new evidence allowed in the trial of the president of the united states fails 51-49, and not a surprise. we anticipated that only two republicans would vote in favor, susan collins and mitt romney and as a result, it did not get what they needed. they needed 51 in order to pass it, and they had 51 opposed. >> when you are stepping away from the move to remove president trump from office, and that is difficult, because of the context, and to step away from the qualms of the way that the house impeachment managers have conducted the case or how the house democrats have conducted the impeachment, and just looking at the motion, and what this motion was doing which is to allow subpoenas for further witnesses

warren interaction? this debate 202 seems for month has been about medicare for all, health care. >> this was a collisiond desti to happy. they're fishing in the same pond for a lot of vot msthey shay of the same views of what's wrong with the system. they have some different prescriptions on how to fix it. but they have a similar world view about a rigged o syster the influence of money. it's not likely that the finalists forhe democratic nomination, i won't say that definitely, but are going to be the two most liberal candidates in the race. both in iowa and new hampshire they're competing very much robert: is vice president biden, buttigieg and bloomberg are they all watching? >>s think thaght because iowa is so fluid right now. any one o four candidates seems to be in a position to either win iowa or finish fourth. and the consequence is siv for -- significant for both of them. i think if t let the story forle w be sanders vs. warren he's happy witht that. they've got two and a half weeks to make the final sale and some of the h are stue and some of them will be out in iowa. robert: how will that affec president biden's campaign? >> he's taking questions but struggled