mushlth dph has stated the rules and the inspector didn't follow the rules when we took the murmentd secondly, dph as repeating said the refusal noise o a only above a limit they arrived at this number by using a ambient value radioactively measures were taken by dph the ambiance number has not been used by maintain other than dph dph has stated the noise from the cooking fan is not high many people have come before the board and said rooster tails fan is loud including the resident living in the same building as rooster tail it's documented in the record we have had to ensure that noise problem for 3 years please help us overturn this surveillance to the timeline for rooster tail to complete remetal action as quickly as possible thank you very much and mr. charles is available for questions. >> okay. we'll hear from the permit holder. >> commissioner president lazarus we have some letters of support i wonder if we might pass them out fine. >> so the letters are they from members of the public and, yes also an inspection report and that was not submitted before because a it was on a monday th