court of appeal has ruled this can happen if a non mushin or who is legitimately being monitored abroad makes contact with an american the case was brought by an american citizen arrested in 2011 he had pleaded guilty to attempting to give material support to a terrorist organization however he questioned whether it was legal for the n.s.a. to collect information on him without a warrant former intelligence official and whistleblower william binney told us the ruling does not reveal anything new. it doesn't make no difference at all it was all under executive order $12.00 triple 3 section $23.00 c. which they used it's been signed into into effect since the reagan years the reagan presidency so they've been using that as in the as a way and also the they used the excuse that they are unable to separate. the data that's a right lie to so they've been lying to the courts all along they had the capability to sort that stuff out it's just that they don't want to because that gives them power over everyone the ability to look into all the political opponents like they did the president trump