naim gina, whose research areas include the geopolitics of the minar region, security studies and southorth for their unholy support of apartied israel. i think that the the western states certainly on the wrong side of history, i mean, what we saw happening on the 7th of october was the beginning of new phase in the palestinian struggle, and those don't see that and don't realize that in fact, this whole past six weeks, is the beginning of new phase, and and a step closer to palestinian liberation and feel that history should be held back by you know. the uncritical support of israel as we getting from the united states, they certainly are on the wrong side of history, i think that it's good that south africa has decided that it will more firmly be on the right side of history and will more firmly follow the values that are articulated in our constitution. look, the south african position, i must say is not is not all that the solidarity movement in south africa is calling for, for example, one of our big issues here that is being... raised by the solidarity movement is the fact that e