all right professor kevin clements from the national center for peace and conflict studies thank you for being here with us in programming sharing your views with us thank you. a u.n. investigation has declared that israel used excessive force during its raid on a gaza about a flotilla last year however the report obtained by the new york times found that israel's blockade of gaza is legal nine activists were shot dead by a commandos who boarded the turkish ship i just costlier has a story. the most significant findings of this u.n. report deal with a great israeli commando unit handled the raid on board the mother that was the largest missile that took part in that there's a turner and it was the vessel on which a nine turkish citizens were killed to quote recorded it is really in an excessive and reasonable manner and that the loss of life was an acceptable now the report says it has forensic evidence that points to the fact that those who have been killed were shot multiple times in the past and at close range and it criticizes the papers that israeli submitted for not adequately