between crime and punishment turns out to be categorically broken, because nato. see in the future, i’m sure nato won’t succeed in the last one, that’s for sure plot, yes, well, before that i can’t help but mention georgia, which 4 months before the bombing of south ossetia was promised nato membership, 4 months in 2008, april nato summit in bucharest, august this provocation, mr. saakashvili’s adventure, and ukraine, who then in bucharest in the eighth year promised the same membership, well, thank god. at some stage this did not turn the heads of the then ukrainian leaders, unlike the leaders of the coup of the fourteenth year, which took place with direct omission of state intervention nato, and the subsequent attempts to draw ukraine into the alliance in the most direct way, the refusal of any discussion of this topic with russia, everything that happened to ukraine after that. from my point of view, now a hot topic for discussion on any international platforms is implementation. the role of extras, of course, we interrupted this dialogue on our own initiative

and that's going to change the way that nato deploys its resources. you've now got troops pre positioned along the russian board . you've got more equipment there and you've got what nato calls regionalization. you've got of responsibility for these areas delegated to countries in the region so that you're not looking at making plans only from brussels. you've got responsibility right there on the front line is so teri helper, petty's nato, in comparison to just a couple of years ago as well, just a couple of years ago was 2022 and i think everything's changed since then. you know, nato started to take a closer look at russia's challenges after its 1st invasion of ukraine in 2014, but it was really this all out assault on ukraine. that focused mine's now. think about it. nato has natal countries have basically emptied their stock piles to send all the equipment to ukraine. that means they're ordering new equipment and that means they'll have upgraded capabilities. uh, should it become necessary to use it against an opponent? so in that sense they've,

, in the parliaments that are members of nato, of those countries that are members of nato, to explainerests, our position, when this dialogue turned out to be completely meaningless, when we realized that we were invited, well, almost as extras , of course, on our own initiative we interrupted this dialogue; we have not been represented in the nato parliamentary assembly for a long, long time, but then... the same failures, the same breakdowns occurred in other international parliamentary structures, where nato countries have their own the majority impose their agenda. this has already happened with the parliamentary assembly of the council of europe, which turned out to be dependent, which worked in the interests of nato countries and the european union, and this is now happening before our eyes in the osce parliamentary assembly , where we participate, where we try to declare our positions, but where are we time after time we are convinced that it is there too. dialogue becomes impossible because the majority in the osce parliamentary assembly is now, as is known, occupied by nato c

the main message ukraine-nato meeting is strong. an independent ukraine is vital for the stability of the euro-atlantic region. that is why nato promises our country a long-term support program. the ukrainian army has shown itself to be a powerful force and power on the battlefield. the only thing missing is equipment according to nato standards. therefore, it is necessary to work on it - nato secretary general jens stoltenberg is confident. however, in order to guarantee the security and defense capability of nato countries, as well as to continue providing assistance to ukraine at a sufficient level, it is necessary to create the euro-atlantic common space of the defense industry. this was stated at the meeting by the head of the ukrainian foreign ministry, dmytro kuleba. the minister of foreign affairs of germany, anna lena berbak, noted during her speech that attention to ukraine is disappearing from the public eye, and this is fatal. all the more so, realizing that russia continues shelling civilians. infrastructure. all those

therefore, this idea of ​​nato expansion was bad.ary, poland, the czech republic, and the russian leadership joined nato. was not happy about this, but it did not cause him great fears, because it was somewhere far away, but in 2004, george w. bush expanded nato to seven more countries, estonia, latvia, lithuania, romania, bulgaria, slovakia and slovenia. and then the russians said, "wait a second, you said you wouldn't expand an inch, and now you've taken 10 countries, stop. and during the munich security conference at 200." you deceived us, you said that you will not expand nato, and you continue to expand, stop, in 2008 george w. bush said: “no, no, nato will expand, and we will take ukraine and georgia." i would like to thank these wonderful people from eastern europe whom i recently met. welcome, thank you for leading by example, thank you for your courage, your. appeared here 15 years ago, today it is dedication , the democratic wave has reached georgia and ukraine, one day the call of freedom will be heard by every mind, this

and 2023 is being a transformative year for nato. we take a look at some of the changes the security alliance is under going and why it's no longer being a big us about who we consider is to be its biggest right. the other one been for zillow, and thanks for joining us. the gaza strip, thomas run health ministry says at least 50 people have been killed in his way the price of this thursday in various locations across the territory. one of the light is took place in dallas by law in central gaza. emergency crews rushing to the scene to extinguish fires in several houses. the smaller suspect it is by the strikes on the southern city of han eunice on wednesday. because it's health industry says at least 20 people dying to be attacked. as well as intensifying its operations in both south and then central garza against the militant islam is group home us recognized as a terrorist organization. by the way, send you the on the distal is rising non stop as israel intensifies it strikes, pushing into central and southern gaza. the homeless ru

in nato. this unity this solidarity, this mutual support impressed the whole world, the entire international community. now slovakia is changing its rhetoric a bit. hungary and the netherlands will probably also follow this path. can we say that support for ukraine is fading, or is it as strong as before? that nato allies will continue to provide substantial and significant support to ukraine, two big steps were announced only last week, germany and the netherlands announced that together they will provide 10 billion, and these are new payments. nato allies have formed a coalition of support to provide ukraine additional pppo systems. in romania, we have just established a training center for ukrainian pilots, where they learn to fly the f-16. there is also a constant flow of ammunition and weapons to ukraine. of course, there is an urgent and ongoing need for more, but allies are demonstrating not only in words but also in deeds that they continue to support ukraine. to be honest, the unity t

of nato.esterday, zelenskyi met with biden and biden said that ukraine will become a member of nato after the victory over russia. let's listen to what the president of the united states of america said. for now, we have to make sure that ukraine will win the war. as you know, we launched a joint. aid program with president zelenskyi and g7 leaders in vilnius, identifying long-term commitments to support ukraine's defense needs. we also held an industrial defense conference last week in washington to accomplish this critical task, so let's move one step at a time. mr. serhiu, regarding nato, regarding prospects in the north atlantic alliance? in ukraine, well , it seems that no one has any doubts that ukraine should be in nato, there were different theories that ukraine could join nato with part of the territory that is not occupied, part of it is occupied, then join of the part that will join the north atlantic alliance, but we see that the united states of america and other members of the no

nato is monitoring this situation.enberg said that he spoke with andrzej duday about the missile... president in poland, and you talked about the fact that the north atlantic alliance cannot understand that what is happening periodically. with the flight of russian missiles on the territory of poland and russian missiles on the territory of romania, the countries that are part of the north atlantic alliance, this is actually the war of russia federation, that is, if they didn't even destroy anything there and that rocket turned around and returned, as they say, towards the ukrainian state, but a provocation by russia is also a war, that's right, i'll say it. three positions: first, i do not want to interfere in the internal affairs of poland, our partner, but i can predict that heads will fly there, because we reported all these conversations there, we said that when they fly 40 km deep into your territory, missile 4, mach 5 flies, well, if the x-22, or well, the kha-101 is slower, but that's all exactly, at first they

so is it possible for ukrainian politicians to dream about nato?ll talk about this with the ambassador russia in belgium, alexander takovinin , alexandrevich, hello, what do you think , is it still possible for ukraine to still have nato foreign ministers in brussels differ from the previous ones in the sense that they are already demonstrating their previous obsession with the conflict in ukraine and confrontation. the vector of development of international events, because they had to discuss the situation in the middle east and the role of china, but in general it must be said that the general course is to continue the confrontation with russia and to continue feeding ukraine with weapons. and its support for the fight - with russia as an advanced bridgehead, this course was maintained, here is an attempt by at least two foreign ministers ... to propose a review of such a policy, so far it has not yielded results, as the public minister of foreign affairs said, many participants in the meeting, like him put it, quietly, they recognized the failur

ukraine now says that our path to nato is written in our constitution.is absolutely obvious that nato is not ready to take over a country where the war is ongoing. there are some statements from former general secretaries. or current advisors about the fact that come on, maybe we will consider the option of guaranteeing the fifth article for those territories that are not occupied, well, it's like nato in exchange for territories, let me understand this whole big flow of information, what is the real perspective of ukraine? i don't want to go too deep, because this specific conversation is professional, but i remember this case when the head of the office of the general secretary of a non-… alliance, not a representative of the allies, the head of the office of the general secretary, that is, the person who helps him organize the work of the general secretary, nice person, i know him well, he really said in one of the conversations that maybe it was necessary to think and take ukraine and the part that is still under control, we criticized him, simply no

nato is monitoring this situation. stoltenberg said he spoke with ange i think about the missile incident in poland. so you talked about the fact that... the north atlantic alliance cannot understand that what happens periodically with the flight of russian missiles into the territory of poland and russian missiles into the territory of romania, the countries that are part of the north atlantic alliance, is actually there is a war with the russian federation, that is, if they didn't even destroy anything there and that rocket turned around and returned, as they say, to the ukrainian state. but a provocation by russia is also a war, right? well, i'll say three positions: first, i do not want to interfere in internal affairs. our partner's poland, but i can predict that heads will fly there, because here are all the conversations, we reported there, we said, when they fly 40 km deep into your territory, a mach 4.5 missile flies, well , if the kh-22, or well slower than the kh-101, but everything is the same, first of all

nato is a space of security. membership in nato provides internal security.is the largest alliance in the world that guarantees security for all its members. it comes from a mutual declaration, which is consciously accepted, no some narrow group that governs certain countries, peoples of nato countries, with the help of democratic institutions of nato countries. we are also interconnected in large numbers. economic and social interdependencies, and putin knows about it. putin is a rational politician in his own way. he makes mistakes, well, such a mistake was the attack on ukraine. this error was made possible by the wrong data he received. unfortunately, it happens that dictators, and putin is one of them, receive false data from their people and do not have the opportunity to verify this data, because they created themselves. such a system, but he is not crazy and will not risk attacking the territory of nato, the territory of the baltic countries, especially, taking into account the military presence of nato on the eastern flank, it is growing and will str

nato before the ratification of finland's accession to nato, and now finland is a member of nato, andknow simply from the warnings of previous periods that russia, as a rule, does not interfere with any, well, with troops, does not interfere with nato member countries, that is, it is rather such a rhetorical a strategy to frighten the west and... there, well , to divert attention from ukraine, isn't it putin's policy, it is actually aggression against ukraine into a full-scale invasion, isn't that what became the impetus for finland to join nato, because putin traditionally blames the west for growing in this way, but this decision of finland was made, probably not just like that, yes, yes, it was just that... this is the behavior of russia, and both finland and sweden , they decided to change their long-term policy of neutrality and submitted applications to join nato, and, as i said, there was such a gray period, you could say, a period when finland had already announced that it wanted to join in nato, but not yet. member of nato, then you can was to act, and now it is already, if t

you, you have, that's that consensus there, that, that nato machinery can, can build on. even if in practice he notes, there's still a handful of allies, less than fully committed to their new responsibilities, not who are says rushes, actions are a constant reminder of the risk of not doing so. and dw, as terry shall to file. that report told us that nato is actually looking to the past as a re shapes its defenses. for infection me, nato's for we're looking plans, actually look more like the way the alliance positioned itself during the cold war . in the sense that you needed more equipments and more troops, pre positioned along the front line, closer to the russian border. and that's what they're going to do. now. they're really going to put a spotlight on what research sources they have and where and how quickly they could move if needed. if russia actually posed more of a physical threat to nato territory, that means every country is going to have to literally say, how many ships it has, how many tanks it has, how many troops it has, how quickly can they move? and tha

only the equipment is missing nato standards. therefore, it is necessary to work on this - nato secretary general stoltenberg is confident, however, in order to guarantee the security and defense capability of nato countries, as well as to continue providing assistance to ukraine, it is necessary to create a euro-atlantic common space of the defense industry at a sufficient level, the head of the ukrainian ministry of foreign affairs stated this at the meeting. dmytro kuleba. the minister of foreign affairs of germany, anna lena berbak, noted during her speech that attention to ukraine is disappearing from the field of view of communities. and this is fatal, especially considering that russia continues shelling of civilian infrastructure. all those present expressed their understanding that this winter, more than ever, is needed. to strengthen the defense of the ukrainian sky. so, let's see what will be done for this and what else was discussed at the meeting. for the first time since the start of russia's full-scale war, the sit

is not about security for the state, until there was nato in ukraine. while there was no nato in finlandhing, nato appeared, that’s it, yes, now there are some dangers, but i want to tell you a couple of things about ukraine that were, firstly, zelensky appointed at... the conference after putin, he could not help but do this, he is being an ape, from the first days of his presidency, he tried very hard to always be like putin, he has there was a feeling that putin for him was the standard of a leader, that is, he copied speeches, copied habits, he tried to copy something, at the un, even when he was in ukraine , scandals were ridiculed, he never saw putin in wrinkled shirts and unironed trousers , no, well, don’t get confused, this is the president, otherwise he is a breed of the president, zelensky never worked out, and you laughed, if i’m not mistaken. well, even before this and before the normandy meeting with zelensky, that is , there were several weeks when zelensky did not give any interviews at all, he had on the table there was a life-size figure made of plywood carved with puti

on 2023 has been a year of major change for nato. we take a look at how the alliance is repositioning itself. a delegation responsibility right along the blocks porter with russia. the i'm out of here. moment welcome to the show is really forces have intensified their attacks on the gaza strip, killing thousands of civilians, israel's military campaign against him, us, which is considered a terrorist group by the us on the you is gradually shifting to the side of the strip where hundreds of thousands of displaced, pulse to needs have fled. a warning this report contains some graphic images, a forensics search full survive of the aftermath of an issue. strike on an apartment in process in kansas. sell an engine baby to is among those clues from the ric inch to risk you is race to hospital. the width of the injured children are rising. the we escape from northern gather and a standing at my sister's house. we came here to rosa and then they hit the neighbor's house which collapsed on to us. we came from the north because they said we'd

also on the sho 2023 has been a year of major change for nato. we take a look at how the alliance is repositioning itself and delegating responsibility right along the blocks board with russia. the i'm clear, richardson, thank you so much for joining us. because i'm also run health ministry says at least 15 people have been killed and is really airstrikes this thursday in various locations across the territory. one of the latest took place in their own fall in central garza, emergency crews extinguished fires in several houses. is real carried out suspected airstrikes a day earlier on the southern city of con eunice closet. officials say at least 20 people were killed. osmond byrom is with the norwegian refugee council and has colleagues working in southern gaza. he told us earlier of what they've been experiencing, the people are mostly crowns, like the rest of the population to these small pockets in rough. uh, i just texted to my colleague and got my message. didn't go through last time i checked and it was last night and he told me that the s

was going east, that ukraine was part of the western world, that it would be in nato, and that there would be missiles and crimea there will be them, the american fleet will be stationed in sevastopol, but they were provoked, and today jeffrey sachs says that what is needed is not negotiations, no, but what is needed is a call from biden , the us president, to our president, vladimir putin, that the us was wrong, and nato it won't go any further, that's what it sounds like, of course fantastic, but on the other hand, jeffrey sachs says that this will help break the impasse in which the current situation in the world has reached. i think this war goes back to the time of nato expansion, which the us started in the mid-nineties, when the soviet union was already ending its existence, the us promised president gorbachev that nato would not expand more than an inch to the east, and the idea was that to ensure peace and that there will be normal relations between the us and the soviet union, or between the us and russia after december 1991, but as soon as the soviet union collapsed, ameri

, it will not be discussed , and the course will continue to include ukraine in nato, but there is noal yet, the west is only ready for such a gradual evolutionary model, and this is not enough now, and as for weapons, yes, now, i think, we need to decide what weapons we need , which is qualitatively new technical level, the support of ukraine is needed, i think that work on this is already underway and the visits to ukraine by the ministers of defense of the usa and germany, i think that some other visits are also a confirmation of the fact that, in principle, they are already working on this, the main thing is not, let's say that it happens faster, so that it is not too slow a process. ugh, you are talking about nato, they are moving so slowly, feeling the ground under their feet there, this is again not to frighten someone there to the point of the red button, to such a fright, i think what is here... actually there is a red line, there are fears and yes, yes, yes, and well, we understand, this is the usa first of all, the biden administration, and to some extent germany, the old s

instead of just how it would keep russia from, from attacking nato allies. and i think that with examples every day and ukraine about how moscow wages a war. now, they have, of course, much more practical examples. now they're able to tailor their war fighting capabilities to exactly what, what capabilities they know that russia has, as the war and ukraine grinds on. there are also concerns about so called ukraine fatigue in europe and in the united states. how does that enter into the equation? here it is, of course, a huge concern of nato, doesn't itself assist ukraine. it doesn't have military resources, it all comes from allied governments, and those governments have to make their own decisions. but that's what you claim is very worried about now with the united states, in particular, saying that it has just yesterday sent it's less front of 8 and less. congress approves a new 61000000000 dollar package, which doesn't look very unlikely at the moment. this has everyone very concerned, europe is going to have to dig deeper, because of course is going to b

on 2023 has been a year of major change for nato. we take a look at how the alliance has repositioning itself and delegating responsibility right along the blocks border with russia. the him a welcome to the program. these really military is again intensifying its air and ground defensive in desktop strikes on thursday, killed at least 50 palestinians as israel prizes it's prizes ahead. story with its military campaign against him off, which is considered a tower group by many countries over 21000 people have been killed in gaza. according to the most one house ministry, and most of the population has been displaced. the aftermath of another strikes on the, the refugee camp and central gaza. much of the site is in ruins. some residents still buried under rubble. others have flood, trying to escape the bonding. they told us to go to russell, but we don't want to. why should we go and live in the street? said the entire neighborhood here was evacuated. as more people leave their homes in search of shelter, many end up in make shift cam

major change for nato. we take a look at how the alliances repositioning itself and democratic responsibilities, right along the blocks photo with russia, the i've been for solar and welcome kansas. how much fun, health ministry. it says at least 50 people have been killed in his way the strikes this thursday in various locations across the territory. one of the latest took place in dallas on the in central gaza emergency crews extinguished fires in several houses. is well kindly down suspect today as strikes the earlier on the southern city of han eunice. conser. officials say at least 20 people were killed. osmond firearm is with a norwegian refugee council and his colleagues working in southern gaza. i asked him what they've been experiencing, or people are mostly crowns, like the rest of the population to these small pockets in rafa. i just texted to my colleague and got my message, didn't go through last time i checked and it was last night and he told me that the situation is getting worse and worse n

therefore, i call for the admission of ukraine into nato, while the war continues, does nato, mr.ker and the countries of the west now have a common vision of what ukraine's victory over russia is, and what russia's defeat in the war with ukraine is? first of all, russia's victory over ukraine, i don't think it will happen. i think that russia does not have a well-trained army equipment, it can cause a lot of pain, but i don't think it will defeat ukraine, regarding ukraine, victory, i think there is a lot of fear in the west, about what is needed. or to defeat russia, i think that putin has already done enough, mr. volker, do you think there is a time lag that allows the countries of the west to restrain an aggressive russia from further destroying the world, how much more time is there to give at the hands of putin and say that putin does not, should not go further or further destroy the world? well, time very important, we should not doubt and wait for anything, we should send such a message to putin already, we will continue to fight. he will continue to try to restore the rus

that is why nato promises our country a long-term support program.has shown itself to be powerful. strength and power on the battlefield, only equipment according to nato standards is not enough, so it is necessary to work on it confident nato secretary general, jens stoltenberg, however: in order to guarantee the security and defense capability of nato countries, as well as to continue to provide assistance to ukraine at a sufficient level, it is necessary to create a euro-atlantic joint defense industry space, the head of the ukrainian foreign ministry, dmytro kuleba, said at the meeting. during her speech, the minister of foreign affairs of germany, anna lena berbak, noted that attention to ukraine is disappearing from the public's view, and this is fatal, tim. more understanding that russia continues shelling civil infrastructure. all those present expressed their understanding that this winter, more than ever, it is necessary to strengthen the protection of the ukrainian sky. so, what will be done for this, and what else was discussed at the mee

of course, in my opinion, ukrainians are already in nato. we know that if ukraine were already in nato, we would not even be conducting such a dialogue now, i am not so optimistic now . as for ukraine being invited to nato this summer, i think there are a lot of countries, including the united states, that are choosing to wait, and that's a very big mistake, in my opinion, god forbid i'm wrong, i want to say no have such hopes for this year. are you a supporter, general? that ukraine can legally become a member of the north atlantic alliance even before the end of the war in ukraine with russia? i would say yes, but unfortunately, the probability is very small, i hear conversations, because if there is a clear settlement, that is, conditionally speaking, if there is any agreement. that certain territories occupied by russia remain with russia, and the part that remains with ukraine will be taken to nato. i have heard such conversations. on the sidelines and, but if someone thinks that this is possible, then, unfortunately, i want to say that

nato, i.e., the reform program described for us, for our full operational interoperability with nato, is being finalized, being prepared, and it seems that right now we are even talking about the absence of any political demands for us, although when we are talking about the north atlantic alliance, it is important do not forget that this is a political and military alliance, precisely in this version, it is a union, and of course. all representatives of our partner countries agreed to continue helping our country as much as possible, there were several important ones a statement about quite significant and ample financial aid to us, in particular from germany, from the netherlands, and this is only what i remember now from memory, they promise not to let everyone get tired of ukraine and not to get tired themselves, i don't know how successful it will be to our colleagues, but mr. vitaly, the commission, let's talk about this with pavlo klimkin, minister of foreign affairs of ukraine in 2014-2019, yes, he is already in touch with us, mr. pavlo, congratulations, but not yet, well, in

will not be able to achieve its goals in ukraine, and after two years of war, ukraine is closer to nato the eu than ever before. the year 2023 was quite difficult for ukraine, because we sought to receive an invitation to join the north atlantic alliance. in july , the summit of the north atlantic alliance was held in vilnius, we were told that the future sees us. in nato, but we did not receive an invitation, in december we received approval from the leaders of the european union, that we can start negotiations with the member countries of the european union, how do you assess the foreign policy successes of the year 2023, could we get much more than we have? i am mr. serhiy, i will start with this quote that is on your screen right now, and it is true, russia will no longer achieve the goals it dreamed of, it will never defeat ukraine, and this is an obvious fact, the only thing i would like significantly it is more that mr. stoltenberg or other european and american politicians formulate this opinion a little differently. that ukraine must achieve the goals that it has set for itself

most of our conversation has been around nato and what nato might do in the region. a number of the flaxseed countries in different stages of that of course. but how important is it do you think the eu to think about how to include some of the states as they are looking at the eu eu enlargement and why is that important for not just countries in the black sea region but for other countries that are looking toward the west and the transatlantic alliance? >> sometimes we do talk about this with alphabet stew of organizations i think this is pretty simple. the european union is based on four freedoms of people to move, move the goods, send capitol, sell their services. and to do it, not just in their neighborhood but across the entire union. in a state says we want to join and that they are saying we want to be open just in the way a u.s. state says we are open for interstate commerce. that allows an incredible growth of prosperity. you see it in places like romania which i think the average income is close to doubled over recent years up 70% i have that right? sorry, i

in nato, when it does everything possible to be heard, it can call such a meeting, but nato members have no obligations to ukraine, and that's what we need to think about when we hold such meetings, of course, we must say that we they do not really want them, remember that before the attack of ukraine, not russia on ukraine, the majority of our citizens were generally opposed to ukrainian accession to nato, and , by the way, many of them, like genr, believed that this would lead to an attack by russia, well, ukraine did not join nato and waited for the attack, yes so to speak, two things in one, but i remember the year 1997, when ukraine signed this act, ukraine nato, mr. pavle, do you remember 1997, pavlo klimkin is already with us, we congratulate you, signing, hello , friends, congratulations , ms. khrystyna, ms. vitaliy, of course, of course i remember, i was not in madras, but, well, your mention is almost historical, but i saw the signing of this fundamental act, ukraine nato , we can say that we have advanced a lot over the years, or we can still say that we have advanced, but we

whole of nato.ssian missile was to actually [and in poland, by the letter of that article, that could be considered, poland could apply to nato to say, we've come under attack from a non—nato country and we would like you to defend us against attack. in practice, that's not likely to happen, because it's probably regarded in this case and in two previous cases that these are stray missiles are not a deliberate attack against poland, a nato member. �* . ., . live now to iuliia osmolovska — former ukrainian diplomat and director of the kyiv office of globsec, a global security and sustainability think tank. good to have you with us. i'm sure it was a terrifying night for many people across ukraine with so many cities hit. whilst it has been, many people are saying, since the full—scale invasion of ukraine began. despite the worst it has been. what are people saying about the missiles that were fired overnight and how has it left him feeling? overnight and how has it left him feelin: ? ~ , ., feeling?

, where we see that not all nato members support ukraine's membership in nato, well, there are two membersin question, so this struggle, it is happening everywhere, and i think that it should not be unexpected for us, because the war against ukraine is not just an attack against us, this is an attack on that world, on that world order, which was formed after the second world war and categorically denies the possibility and not'. one country , another country, that's why it's a war, and it 's happening everywhere now, but i'm still inclined to believe that after this great historical cycle, wars will be won... good, because so far it's on the side of democracy, most of the technology , most of the money, and the society there has more developed institutions and, most importantly, has more and better education, so strategically global the west will win, but of course we will have a lot of these battles along the way, and it has already happened that ukraine is at the forefront of this great battle. thank you, mr. serhiy, it was serhiy taran, a political scientist, and we continue. our broadc

ukraine is closer to nato than ever before.ecretary general of the alliance, jen stoltenberg , confirmed the bloc's intention and desire cooperate with ukraine on equal terms. to reach this goal faster, minister. of border affairs, with the participation of the head of our ministry of foreign affairs, dmytro kuleba, approved the structure of the recently created ukraine nato council, approved its work plan, as well as the national program for 2024, which prepares our country for joining nato. among the reform priorities, the fight against corruption, strengthening the rule of law, support for the protection of human rights and national minorities. the secretary general of the alliance said that ukraine has already made significant progress in modernization. i... in fact, i am impressed by the dedication with which ukraine approaches the implementation of reforms, the modernization of society during a full-scale war. we see that the ukrainians have introduced legislative changes, taken specific steps not only in the fight agains

, i'm not saying the whole nato, this nato sometimes sounds like a collective event, but that's it no less, the essence of the event, had more than great doubts about how and where to move forward with us, and only with us, yes, please tell me, mr. pavle, but after all , the creation of the ukraine-nato council, and the meeting at the level of foreign ministers, i am sure. that you analyzed this important event that happened on november 29, can we say that we have any practical gains as a result of these steps? well, council is a good story, it does not mean that we now have the same status, the fact that we are at the same table, we can speak differently, that is gives us opportunities, after all, all decisions in nato are key, they are political, and if they are political, then this is a decision at the level of heads of state and government, and this is exactly the kind of council meeting that has already taken place, when foreign ministers meet, they deal with - well, i would use this word to refine those political decisions that are made by the leadership of states and government

ukrainians are already in nato. we know that if ukraine were already in nato, we would not be conducting such a dialogue even now. now i'm not so optimistic determined that ukraine will be invited to nato this summer. i think there's a lot of countries, including the united states, that i decide to... wait, and that's a very big mistake, i think, oh god, i'm wrong, i mean, don't have those hopes for this year, or mr. general, you are a supporter of the fact that ukraine can legally become a member of the north atlantic alliance even before the end of the war in ukraine with russia. i would say yes, but unfortunately the probability is very low. i hear the talk, because if there is a clear settlement, what conditionally speaking, if there is an agreement that certain territories occupied by russia will remain with russia, and the part that will remain with ukraine, that part will be taken to nato. i heard such conversations on the sidelines. and, but if someone thinks that this is possible, then unfortunately, i want

um, you know, we've and we've seen nato do the same thing. nato says, oh, we're really tough. we can, we do all were so powerful and then the, and then the very next sentence. but rush just going to evade, and they're going all the way to parents or whatever it is they say. so these stories are, are aimed at domestic populations for the most part, because ultimately it is the europeans and the american taxpayer who's a has to pay for this, or go bankrupt, trying to. so the messaging, there's actually probably 2 or is going on, at least by the, in washington one is against their own people and the propaganda war against the world. and then of course, the exercise of our military, uh, uh, in industry. you know, how do we, i mean, they sell the aid to ukraine is sold to americans not is helping ukraine when a 100 percent of course. but mainly because it creates a jobs in america. i mean by that just recently started talking about, oh, don't worry people, it's all about your job. so, you know, but i will say it's a brzezinski doctrine has been something that american politicians f

take, for example, the topic of nato, what the president said about how nato is trying to expand itsity to the asia-pacific region, and that this causes not only dissatisfaction, but rejection from our side and from the chinese side. you know, in my fresh, relatively fresh memory there are several more. years ago, when during inter-ministry of foreign affairs consultations, and we have them, it’s so somewhat academic, it was far from us, this is your problem, somewhere in europe, we don’t have this problem here, now, if listen to the statements of chinese diplomats, and even chinese leaders on this topic, their assessments do not differ in any way from ours, they just felt in china... felt that this was a threat, the coincidence of the assessments of our and chinese partners, this, in my opinion, is a process a completely natural, deeply positive trend-setting, at least for the foreseeable future. the political year in our relations has not yet ended; we still have very serious plans for contacts for the remaining couple of weeks there until the end of december. in next. i’ll tell yo

if putin attacks a nato ally and keeps going and attacks another nato ally, we've committed as a nato member we defend every inch of nato territory, then we'll have something we don't seek and don't have today, american troops fighting russian troops, american troops fighting russian troops if he moves into other parts of nato. make no mistake, today's vote is going to be long remembered and history is going to judge harshly those who turn their back on freedom's cause. we can't let putin win. say it again, we can't let putin win. it's in our overwhelming national interests and national interests of all our friends. our ability to supply ukraine strengthens putin's position. we've run out of money because of authorization. the extreme republicans are playing chicken with our national security, holding ukraine's funding hostage with extreme border policies. let me be clear, we need real solutions. i support real solutions at the border. i put forward a comprehensive plan the first day i came into office. i made it clear we need congress to make changes to fix what is a broken immigrati

nato is a space of security. membership in nato provides internal security.nato is the largest alliance in the world that guarantees security for all its members. this comes from a mutual declaration that was consciously accepted, not by some narrow group that governs certain countries, the peoples of countries. with the help of democratic institutions. and nato. we are also interconnected by a large number of economic, social, and putin knows about it. putin is a rational politician in his own way. he makes mistakes, well, such a mistake was the attack on ukraine. this error was made possible by the wrong data he received. unfortunately, it happens that dictators, and putin is one of them, receive false information from their people. baltics, especially, taking into account nato's military presence on the eastern flank, it is growing and will continue to strengthen. it does not intensify in such a provocative way. this is not about putin having arguments and theses, or one of his courtiers having arguments and theses that nato wants to attack, no, but it is

let's imagine what will happen if a part of ukraine is in nato.e are high risks for us, because i am sure that if part of ukraine will be in nato, then you have also heard signals about finland, well, it means that it will enter and war with us will begin. and here there will be a question whether nato countries will join to fight for a part of ukrainian territory, which has one or another status in nato, not completely, but some status. zelensky also spoke about his relationship with commander-in-chief valery zaluzhny. the western press has repeatedly written about the misunderstanding between zelensky and zaluzhny. the ukrainian president's office denied the conflict, calling it work-related issues. zelensky himself has now publicly stated. he has such a working relationship with zaluzhny, and zaluzhny as the commander-in-chief together with the general staff must be responsible for the results on the battlefield, then i suggest listening to zelenskyi’s answer to clarifying to journalists whether he plans to fire the commander-in-chief, i plan t