we also look at 11th and natoma. i think a discussion maybe was more focused on where we were on the status of the purchase of 11th and natoma but i think doing our analysis we have to look at the shadow cast on the property exist today but really what makes this the future since we just don't know what the future will be. >> but you are willing to approve it for recommendation i mean just with the fact [cross-talking / off mic] >> yes we do not wait into the >> 11th and that, >> we did about late 11th and natoma but what is it today and just buildings which we won't be able to really do anything with until 2024. we do not take into account any public benefits by the-i'm so looking for the 1989 memo but the public benefits opposed by the project were the shadow caster so we do not take into consideration. >> it's interesting >> we did recommend this to move forward. >> before, sarah you weigh in on this, i think as i understand it, both the general manager and the commission way in and recommending to the planning co

we also look at 11th and natoma. i think a discussion maybe was more focused on where we were on the status of the purchase of 11th and natoma but i think doing our analysis we have to look at the shadow cast on the property exist today but really what makes this the future since we just don't know what the future will be. >> but you are willing to approve it for recommendation i mean just with the fact [cross-talking / off mic] >> yes we do not wait into the >> 11th and that, >> we did about late 11th and natoma but what is it today and just buildings which we won't be able to really do anything with until 2024. we do not take into account any public benefits by the-i'm so looking for the 1989 memo but the public benefits opposed by the project were the shadow caster so we do not take into consideration. >> it's interesting >> we did recommend this to move forward. >> before, sarah you weigh in on this, i think as i understand it, both the general manager and the commission way in and recommending to the planning co

natoma's family is here today because natoma can't be, and her sister connie is here, connie, stand up. [applause] i'm signing this bill for all the leaders who took up this cause through the generations. from teddy roosevelt to franklin roosevelt. from harry truman to lyndon johnson. from bill and hillary clinton to one of the deans who has been fighting this so long, john dingell. [applause] to senator ted kennedy. [applause] ted's widow vicki is here. [applause] it's fitting that teddy's widow vicki is here and his niece caroline. his son patrick, whose vote helped make this reform a reality. i remember seeing ted walk through that door in a summit in this room a year ago, one of his last public appearances. i it was hard for him to make it. but he was confident that we would do the right thing. our presence here today is remarkable and improbable. all the punditry, all the lobbying, all the game-playing that passes for governing in washington, it's been easy at times to doubt our ability to do such a big thing. such a complicated thing. to wonder if there are limits to what we as a

for those of you who don't know the chevron gas station the bottom picture the office building on natoma and the wide streets of howard and 9th street what was interesting about the project as doug mentions that crossed through zoning district the r e connector and is mixed use and the commercial district also a 45 height limit on part of it and 55 on the rest of the site and has looks flat but almost a story worth of gray change between the corner southeast corner and the northwest corner across the site you'll see this section gets complicate but essentially it is four stories ever wood over a concrete podium the other thing that was structural since in sort of existing rear yard open space we moved the pedestrian alleyway in bound to have residential on both sides that have residential entries on both sides we have 47 percent two bedrooms and some are larger than the two bedrooms we've been designing recently. >> the lowest levels it the parking garage level i show you this has a maximum of parking space allowed without a conditional use that is 8 car share and a storage area for you

we also look at 11th and natoma. i think a discussion maybe was more focused on where we were on the status of the purchase of 11th and natoma but i think doing our analysis we have to look at the shadow cast on the property exist today but really what makes this the future since we just don't know what the future will be. >> but you are willing to approve it for recommendation i mean just with the fact [cross-talking / off mic] >> yes we do not wait into the >> 11th and that, >> we did about late 11th and natoma but what is it today and just buildings which we won't be able to really do anything with until 2024. we do not take into account any public benefits by the-i'm so looking for the 1989 memo but the public benefits opposed by the project were the shadow caster so we do not take into consideration. >> it's interesting >> we did recommend this to move forward. >> before, sarah you weigh in on this, i think as i understand it, both the general manager and the commission way in and recommending to the planning co

think through is a lot of concern in the neighborhood especially from ken and kidnap we clean up natoma balls a lot illicit behavior as homeless are moved around the city and it has a good pedestrian zone to work with them in light future i'll make a commitment to do that. >> have a lot of street credibility i'll be open to i'll see what my fellow commissioners have to say but i think if there was more design the filipinos are put on the project will be welcome. >> i'll see what my fellow commissioners have to say. >> commissioner koppel. >> i'd like to echo the comments of commissioner vice president richards that is an opportunity site with the gas station being there on the corner there could be more things on the corner not so user friendly - i was looking at the drawings and looked at the roof plan on that it t and wondering if there sustainability we're trying to do all the san francisco entertainment commission directly in the muse especially a lot of setback we're not parking on the site so i think if you're familiar with title 24 is almost like recertification right now so i ca