turkey is actually a member of nato, a member of the north atlantic alliance. whose. which actually has the second largest armed forces in the north atlantic alliance after the united states of america, announces its plans to join an international forum in which such great friends of america as russia, china, iran, and there are others also participate countries, so to speak, which attitude towards america may be somewhat more neutral, but the fact that they have already entered brix is ​​actually a clear, so to speak, indication that these countries are not allies of the united states of america, that they will pursue their own, independent and an independent policy, so i think that i don’t know how these negotiations with turkey will end, it is quite possible that this is some kind of psychological operation on the part of the turkish government in order to put pressure on its nato american partners and so on. but in in any case, so to speak, this is a very serious blow to the authority and prestige of the alliance; on the contrary, this is a very, so to speak

defense of ukraine rustem umyerov during a joint briefing with the secretary general of the north atlantic alliance jens stoltenberg. he also thanked the head of the alliance for supporting ukraine. stoltenberg, in turn, said that the current struggle of ukrainians is more important not only for ukraine, but also for europe, because it is a struggle for common values. we and our allies have already announced. new aid packages, which are crucially important, and so we all continue to look for opportunities to provide ukraine with more aid and to do it as quickly as possible, and of course, we want to once again recognize your bravery, both as a political and military leadership, as well as of all men and women who wear the uniform and are now on the battlefield in ukraine. it was your bravery that impressed the whole world. in ivano-frankivsk from june 17 to 23 , the ukrainian shakespeare festival will be held for the first time. during the week at the ivan franko drama theater. performances of ukrainian and foreign theaters will be shown, as well as lectures and discussions with writers and art cri

in fact, in the situation between russia and the countries of the north atlantic alliance, everythingensus, conduct dialogue, offer options for resolving the conflict, but like peas against a wall, they can agree, lead us, but the decision will be made unilaterally, because there is no agreement with...

. and the nato countries understand that sooner or later putin will go to war against the north atlantic alliancee countries of the north atlantic alliance, in the large forum that took place in st. petersburg, the so-called economic forum, the russian dictator at a meeting with foreign journalists in which threatened western countries with nuclear weapons, let's listen to what he said and how he said it. it's such a tough subject: the united states, the only country that used nuclear weapons during world war ii world war hiroshima, nagasaki, 20 kilotons. our tactical nuclear weapons are 70-75 kilotons. this is such a tactical nuclear weapon. let's not argue not only about use, but also about the threat of use. for some reason, the west believes that russia will never use it. we already have a nuclear doctrine. look at what it says. if someone's actions threaten our sovereignty and territorial integrity, we will consider it possible to use all the means available to us. you can't treat it lightly, superficially, you have to treat it professionally. i i know that you don't really like to comment,

well, here's a quote from the head of the north atlantic alliance. keep the world nuclear-free , but as long as it exists, we will remain nuclear alliance. because a world where russia, china and north korea have nuclear weapons and nato does not is a dangerous world. in the end, i would not only talk about nuclear weapons, i would say that the world in which putin is the head of russia is already a dangerous world. and, by the way, russia has already reacted to this statement by the head of the north atlantic alliance. dmitry piskov is the one who is putin's spokesman. uh, that's how he commented on this statement about the transfer of nuclear forces to a state of combat readiness, piskov's quote, this is nothing more than further escalation tension, you thought he would say something else, i honestly didn't, i was even waiting for him to say it. well, in conclusion, another scandalous statement by donald trump, and again it concerns ukraine, unfortunately. i will deal with billions in payouts. which ukraine receives from the united states of america

shooting down a missile in the air the vastness of a country that is not a member of the north atlantic alliance the same time , it will be done by a country that is a member of the north atlantic alliance. well, for example, the same poland. how to implement it, legally, how exactly to integrate it into the fifth article. of collective security, which is already quite overbureaucratized and archaic, it is like the north atlantic alliance itself, a bureaucratic such an archaic mechanism , in fact, that has long been begging for reform, global reform, this is the first point, and the second point, why i don't i see some prospects for solving this issue in the near future, this is technically already an aspect, let's imagine such a moment that in the direction of... lviv , a russian hast-1-555 is flying, it sends a buck m1 air defense missile to intercept it, it can intercept it , but at the same time, this enemy missile is seen by the polish air defense system, for example, the same patriot air defense system, so the coherence of actions, the compatibility of systems, the synchronization of syste

blackmail and and nato countries understand that sooner or later putin will go to war on the north atlantic alliance of the north atlantic alliance, at a large forum that took place in st. petersburg, the so-called economic forum, the russian dictator, at a meeting with foreign journalists, once again threatened western countries with nuclear weapons for... this is such a very tough topic: the united the united states is the only country that used nuclear weapons during world war ii. hiroshima, nagasaki - 20 km. our tactical nuclear weapons are 70-75 kton. this is such a tactical nuclear weapon. let 's not only prove to use, but... as for the threat of use, for some reason the west believes that russia will never use it, but we have a nuclear doctrine, look at what it says: if someone's actions threaten our sovereignty and territorial integrity, we will consider it possible to use all available we have the means, you can't treat it lightly, superficially, you have to treat it professionally, i know. mr. valery, you don’t really like to comment on putin and, in general, what he says, but i will still

architecture, the european architecture is changing, the leadership in the eu and partly in the north atlantic alliancel be changed. mark rutte, the new premier, the new secretary general of nato, it is already known that he will be the new general secretary of the north atlantic alliance. in october, he will gain powers in nato. how will it affect the movement of ukraine to nato, and how will it affect the results of the july summit. in washington of the north atlantic alliance. we will talk about all this with valery chaly during the hour from 8 to 9 p.m. at 9:15 p.m., we have a traditional journalism club, just like every friday. bohdan butkevich and olga len, my colleagues. together with me, we will sum up the results of the week and talk about, of course, the debates of biden or trump, because this is a top topic, a top global topic. and of course, this is an important topic for... for ukraine, especially in the context of trump's promises to end russia's war against ukraine rather quickly and the fact that the world is literally on the brink of the third world war. among the topics discussed this

stated that he did this, which he did repeatedly, that official ankara does not want the north atlantic alliancehich it is a member, that is, turkey, to become a direct a participant in this war. at the same time, he added that more and more nato countries are beginning to support ankara's point of view that... the war in ukraine needs and needs only a diplomatic solution. well, as much as i talked about the negotiations that, for example, turkey wants to promote, i will talk about them, in particular, i will mention the peace summit in switzerland. so the draft of the final document got to bloomberg journalists. they saw the document and there they released several statements from this document. in particular, there is such a sentence: a project in which it is about the fact that the path to peace must comply with the charter of the united nations organization, it provides for the holding of the second summit, that is, there must be another summit, where it will be , when it will be and what in general, who will be there and what will be discussed, well no it is generally known, in the end, jus

parameters of the timing of ukraine’s entry into the alliance, can these statements by the north atlantic alliance escalation, probably yes, also the north atlantic alliance just said that it is not comes from the fact that that ukraine will become a member of nato in the near future and does not assume that... nato soldiers with boots will appear in ukraine in the near future. on the one hand, one can rejoice at such statements. on the other hand, we treat them as skeptically as possible, bearing in mind that we have already seen killed regular nato soldiers or so-called vacationers in ukraine, so it is pointless to speculate on whether they will appear or not, they have already appeared. work in ukraine as instructors , including, well, the president of our country only that he said that we indeed reserve the right to begin supplying long-range, precision weapons to the enemies of the united states, but also to those countries, he put it delicately, that are under pressure from the united states, but these deliveries from our side have not yet begun. let's listen. the rate is associated with a w

and then the quote from the head of the north atlantic alliance: "i am absolutely sure that both europeanthe united states will continue to support ukraine, as this support corresponds to our interests in the field of security." we are not going to launch missiles at russia through a fairly minor incident, but nato member states are trying to develop an algorithm for how they should respond to serious incidents related to russia's subversive activities in europe. latvian president edgar serinkevich said this in an interview with the financial times newspaper. allies should be able to discuss all kinds of responses, he said. appropriate tools, but at the same time he added that unfortunately not all of these tools will be able to be used. besides, mr. president stated that one of options for countering russian sabotage would be to increase the number of nato maritime patrols. and he also said that another option is to completely close the baltic sea to russian ships, but at the same time he added that this is exactly the option he said is unlikely to be implemented now. because it would me

be made on transferring the coordination of this assistance from the united states to the north atlantic allianceitary aid to ukraine annually, and this support on our part should be maintained for as long as is required for stable, reliable funding every year. in parallel, at a two-day conference on assistance to ukraine, which opened in berlin, the european union and germany jointly announced an increase in contributions to the german society for international cooperation in kyiv, its fund will be increased. up to 75 million euros per year, the president of the european commission, present in berlin, recalled that from july 1, the european union intends to transfer to ukraine the first tranche in the amount of one and a half billion euros, proceeds from the frozen funds of the russian federation, an agreement was reached on this at previous summits here in brussels, the media are counting on the fact that at the next g7 summit this weekend there will be... well, we continue at the presidential fund for cultural initiatives, today we summed up the results large-scale work on selecting applicatio

for a moment, turkey is actually a member of nato, a member north atlantic alliance. hich such great friends of america as russia, china, iran. so to speak, a factor that contributes to strengthening the authority and international position of brix, by the way, they are going to join brix, you know, these are several dozen states, they have such giants as indonesia and nigeria, well, that is, so to speak, brix has every chance to greatly strengthen its global world position vis-a-vis, so to speak, the united west, here, of course , any... i think that this will be a very serious factor, shaking this very euro-atlantic unity and undermining the unity of the north atlantic alliance, you know, there is such a bearded joke, i apologize to those who have heard it many times, it means a russian tank in the village fields opposite the arc de triomphe. two of our tankers are sitting on the armor, but one to speak to another, we lost the information war, that was an anecdote before we started work, well, yes, now we have won the information war, of course, so you see, losing a

confident that vladimir putin’s visit to phinyang threatens the global security of the entire north atlantic alliancenference with anthony blinken. russia's war against the ukrainians are supported by china, north korea and iran, they want the united states to lose, they want nato to lose, if they succeed in ukraine they will make us vulnerable and the world more dangerous. putin's visit to north korea demonstrates and confirms russia's ties to authoritarian countries such as north korea, china and iran. this shows that our security is not regional, but global. in the west they first set fire, when sparks and smoke begin to fly in their direction, they begin to shout means to the whole world about threat and safety. nikit, but it’s unlikely that they are so afraid, but why do they shout so loudly, but they are afraid, oles, with all due respect, but i think that they are really afraid, because stoltenberg, this is just a meeting, no, of course, this is not everything just a meeting, everyone understands perfectly well that even though there will be an agreement on paper. many things will be discussed

the largest naval exercises of the north atlantic alliance are in the active phase. are being sold under as the new york times reports, already this summer kiev has exhibited

union and the north atlantic alliance.l, all those promises about assistance, further assistance to ukraine in the military sphere, in the humanitarian, economic, financial sphere, which were included in this agreement, about these joint security obligations between the european union and ukraine, they say that all this will continue provided. if ukraine continues to demonstrate its progress towards its european future to membership in the european union, through commitment to the rule of law, democracy, basic values ​​and freedoms, and this again emphasizes that all this assistance that is provided today and that is promised to be provided to us in various fields tomorrow and the day after tomorrow, it will be directly linked to whether ukraine will remain, in its struggle or in its transformation, a country that meets the critical copenhagen political criteria, which relate to the basic principles, the balance of power, democracy and freedoms, i would like to believe that our leadership... the current government of ukrai

oleksandr, i would like to talk to you about the north atlantic alliance, in particular about the summitd in july this year, in particular, information has appeared from the british correspondent of rfe/rl oles kovich, he reported that that great britain is trying to convince the united states of america and the federal republic of germany that it is necessary to give the country an invitation to the north atlantic alliance after all, or at least in some way to accelerate our integration into nato, our entry into nato, right before the summit we are talking about. how realistic is it that great britain will persuade, or at least somehow influence the united states of america, germany's position on, well, in particular, relations between nato. in particular, regarding the accession to nato within the framework of the july summit of this year. well, you know, our partners tell us that, unlike the european union, where we became candidates for membership of the european union and started the integration process, it is actually a political decision accepted, there are still technical points,

order to make concessions or give a signal to the world that ukraine will be a member of the north atlantic alliancear as i understand, we cannot count on inviting ukraine to the alliance at the washington summit today, but this does not mean that the partners are not currently thinking about how not to offer ukraine a clear path to membership in nato, and this does not mean that their intentions about our future membership have somehow changed, it is difficult for them, but they do not have... unity regarding this issue, and obviously, in an organization in which everything is decided by consensus, today there is no such consensus on this issue, for various reasons, and this is probably, well, a big and meaningful discussion, regarding whether there will somehow be an influence, well these statements now by scholz and the future new leader, the secretary general of nato, rutte, his role in the alliance on how the events at the washington summit will develop, i do not expect any serious additional changes, we roughly understand what is being prepared, but the fact that the west understands more and

oleksandr, i would like to talk with you about the north atlantic alliance, in particular about the summitt will be held in july this year, in particular, appeared. information from the british correspondent of rfe/rl oles kovich, he reported that great britain is trying to convince the united states of america and the federal republic of germany that it is necessary to give ukraine an invitation to the north atlantic alliance, or at least somehow speed up our integration into nato , our entry into nato, actually before the summit that we are talking about... how realistic is it that great britain will convince, or at least somehow in a way will affect the united states of america, the position of germany, regarding, well, in particular, the relations between nato, in particular, regarding the accession to nato within the framework of the summit of july this year. well, you know, our partners tell us that unlike the european union, where we became candidates. became members of the european union and started the process of integration, then in fact the political decision has been made, ther

once again, the destabilization of the european union and the paralysis of the north atlantic alliance. and some of us are aware of this, but again not all of us. in connection with that, your rhetoric must ensure that the awareness of the four goals that putin has set for himself, once again, the destruction of the ukrainian state, the destabilization of nato and the destabilization of the eu, the paralysis of nato and the destruction of the ukrainian people, which are all goals that threaten not only the residents of kharkiv, kyiv or lviv, but also threaten residents of madrid, lisbon, london or rome. this is our common threat. well , accordingly, what should we do, how should we build correctly. a tough response to the russian aggressor, why i say tough, because it should be a joint decision on the one hand nato member countries, well at least on the european continent, because in a few months the situation in the united states may change, and we do not know what the situation in the united states will be when donald trump becomes president, but president macron is already preparing

the only guarantee, the indisputable guarantee of our future security is membership in the north atlantic alliancesaid in his interview as if he had never russia should not seize ukraine, on the other hand, he says that he does not see ukraine in nato. how did you personally perceive this statement by biden, is it really for us quite alarming, should we not exaggerate these words now, and there is no reason to despair that nato will be closed to us forever. well , you know, i am an old euro-atlanticist, both professionally and as a member of the ukraine nato public league. we have been fighting for nato entry for 30 years, and this swing, it continues for the first year. and every time the swing swings in the opposite direction and they say that everything is lost, everything will be fine, but you can't fold your hands, in fact the movement is not constant, two steps to the left, two steps to the right, as they say, but he continues, what can i say, we have to do our part, we have to defend our land, no nato will protect ukraine now from the russian invasion, we have task number one. existential,

occupiers, another summit will be held in a month , this is the anniversary summit of the north atlantic allianceur on the eve of this summit , a message appeared in the mass media in the west that the leaders of nato member countries they are telling zelensky not to raise the issue of ukraine's accession to nato at this summit. biden reflected on the fact that nato is not yet ready for ukraine, and he... said that he was always against the natoization of ukraine, and in the context of this, is it already clear that together with the european union, ukraine will be a member and the north atlantic alliance, can it be considered that the statements made a year ago in vilnius are a confirmation that sooner or later this will happen, if not at your anniversary summit. in tone, then on ukraine will receive an invitation to join the alliance at the next summit. mr. serhiy, i am convinced that ukraine will be a member of nato, and i am convinced that the decisions that will be made in washington will be much stronger and bigger than what is being discussed now, because what is described, the discussions

ramstan format, deans stoltenberg said that the coordination of aid to ukraine through the north atlantic alliance will increase the amount of military aid to ukraine, he is convinced of this, and says that in the issue of the transfer of weapons there was a certain accountability and... transparency is very important, let's listen to what jens stoltenberg said. we're talking about a minimum of $50 billion in usage. of gross domestic product, i.e. countries pay according to their gdp, we know, yes, that, if we are talking about the gdp of the usa, then it is about the share of 50% of the entire part of nato, so we understand, yes, how proportional the amounts of contributions can be. i hope and expect that the nato allies will agree to this, because it is very important that ukraine... this stability, predictability, and we have to act preemptively in order to avoid those delays in supplies that we observed in the previous months. so, mrs. ivano, jen stoltenberg said an important thing about the predictability of ukraine as well, and for this accountability to be there, does anyone have doubts abo

well, against this background, of course, we are all waiting for the july summit of the north atlantic alliance nato secretary general jens stoltenberg said that at the upcoming summit in washington , we should not expect concrete statements regarding ukraine's membership in the alliance, but there will be a clear message about the prospects of our country's membership. let's listen to the secretary general of nato. we've seen new announcements, and i expect there will be announcements. on providing greater military support to ukraine. i am sure that we will also have wording that ukraine will become a member of the alliance. the precise wording of exactly what we will agree on is currently being discussed among nato members, but i am sure that by summit we will have a good agreement on the solution. mr. valentin, taking into account the fact that last week was such a large ukrainian one. such a week in europe and in the world, because there were many summits, meetings, the big seven, rammstein, and of course, what jens stunterberg says, hinting that there will be some positive news for ukraine

is it already clear that together with the european union, ukraine will be a member of the north atlantic alliance it be considered that the statements made a year ago in vilnius are a confirmation. that sooner or later it will happen, if not at the anniversary summit in washington, then at the next summit ukraine will receive an invitation to the alliance. mr. sergey, i am convinced that that ukraine will be a member of nato, and i am convinced that the decisions that will be made in washington will be much stronger and bigger than what is being discussed now, because what is being described is those discussions. statements of secretary general stoltenberg that are currently being made, they say that nato, first of all, is preparing a separate road for ukraine's accession to nato, which will be individual, which is outside the framework of those procedures that were usually used by nato and applied in relation to other partners, and i am asking you, please give let's all pay attention, even a year ago or a year and a half ago... ursula fonden never spoke like that, what ukraine has done. today, t

justify shooting down a missile in the airspace of a country that is not a member of the north atlantic alliance, while it will be done by a country that is a member... of the atlantic alliance, well, for example, the same poland, how to implement it legally, how exactly to integrate it into the fifth article of collective security, which is already quite bureaucratized and archaic, it is like the north atlantic alliance itself, such an archaic bureaucratic mechanism in fact , which has long been calling for reformation, global reformation, this is the first moment, and the second moment, why i do not see any in the near future... prospects for solving this issue, this is already a technical aspect, let's imagine such a moment that in the direction the russian hast-1555 is sent flying to lviv, it sends a buck m1 air defense missile to intercept it, it can intercept it, but at the same time this missile is seen by the polish air defense system, for example, the same patriot air defense system, so it is bad. ness of actions, compatibility of systems, synchronization of system actions, it is imposs

well, against this background, of course, we are all waiting for the july summit of the north atlantic alliance. nato secretary general jens stoltenberg said that no specifics should be expected at the upcoming summit in washington information about ukraine's membership in the alliance, but there will be a clear message about the prospects of our country's membership. let's listen to the general secretary. we have seen new announcements, and i expect they will be announcements of more military support for ukraine. i am sure that we... will also have wording that ukraine will become a member of the alliance. the precise wording of exactly what we will agree on is currently being discussed among nato members, but i am confident that by the time of the summit we will have a well- agreed solution. mr. valentine, given that last week was like this ukrainian week is quite big in europe and in the world, because there were many summits, meetings. alluding to the fact that there will be some positive news for ukraine is encouraging, because after joe biden's statements that he is against the natization

moreover, the secretary general of the north atlantic alliance also expressed concern over the fact thatorth korea will be able to help russia more actively by supplying weapons and ammunition, which necessary for putin to wage war in ukraine. therefore, - says mr. stoltenberg, taking into account this, it has become even more important that all nato members are more than ever with. as countries that believe in freedom and democracy, well, this is really so, by the way, about the modernization of nato nuclear weapons, which jen stoltenberg said a few days ago and after which they howled in the russian swamps, so here he is today, while staying, it was at night because of the time difference, while in canada he said that this upgrade had been planned for a long time and it is in no way connected with what started in russia. actively jointly with belarus in the training of nuclear forces. well, let's move on. yes, yes. romanian president klaus iohannis rejected and withdrew his candidacy for the post of nato secretary general in favor of dutch prime minister mark rutte this afternoon. klau

major exercises of the north atlantic alliance countries, iron wolf, begin in lithuania. 3,700 militarynnel are involved. the armies of seven countries are participating: the usa, belgium, norway, the netherlands, the czech republic, luxembourg and lithuania itself. they use about 500 pieces of equipment, including tanks, infantry fighting vehicles, self-propelled artillery , and armored personnel carriers. the training will last 2 weeks. how easy is it to become a hostage to a situation thanks to your own husband? tonight we will show an interview with daria losik. her name is still used as a symbol of devotion to the revolutionary ideas on which igor losik made his money. these are not the most famous names in the narrow circle of the opposition, but a very loud story about how the life of a family is broken. why? why she no longer a moose, we’ll tell you, daria herself will tell you. after all, the decision to divorce, which was the last straw, so you decided everything, the last straws were in the nuts, i say, i feel like a mother, a schoolboy did something wrong, and his mother sho

negotiations to join the european union for these countries will be an invitation to the north atlantic alliance is one of the stepping stones to nato. many questions. first of all, thank you for mentioning that the process of european integration did not begin with the submission of an application, that is, a formal application for receiving a candidate. and then we heard from all the official tribunes that in two years we have passed everything here, well done, submitted an application and became candidates, and we have already opened negotiations. this process i have been going for many years, i will tell you that... i am involved, only maybe in some interesting moments, i remember we prepared, i think, in 1990, probably the sixth year, such a report, in general, what are the copenhagen criteria, the specifics of the achievement these goals were passed on to the then president, that is , it was still then, well, a lot of people did not know about this one at all. way, although we have already decided on the essence of the european future, well, in essence, our first european deputies even and

important that a new person has become at the helm of nato, the secretary general of the north atlantic allianceformer prime minister is not. well, here's what mike carpenter, director of the white house's national security council for europe, has to say about this in a voice of america commentary, and some people don't like it, but i personally like the metaphor of a bridge to nato, because that's exactly what we're trying to achieve , the so-called bridge to nato is needed for that ukraine could reach, join the alliance on the same day, when there is political will for it, that is very, very important, to understand, well, mark rutte actually can go down in history, being that general. secretary, under whose rule or leadership, nato will be expanded and ukraine will actually be a part of the north atlantic alliance, how do you assess, how do you assess the prospects, the prospects of mark rutte's work, first of all, i absolutely agree with your statement, mr. vasyl , secondly, it is very positive for us the news that one of ukraine's allies, the prime minister of the netherlands, mark rutte, w

according to him, the united states of america believes that the north atlantic alliance is the futureraine, and therefore they will do their best to help it join it. well, for this , joe biden's administration, together with its allies, will calculate every step of ukraine on the way to this goal. at the same time, mr. admiral kirby also... added that ukraine itself will need to do a lot on its own in order to become a full member of the alliance, and in particular, to fight corruption. he did not call it the most important problem of ukraine, but said that it is also considered in the complex, then a short quote from john kirby. corruption is a cause for concern, but of course any country wishing to join the lavyans must take other steps. the optimal guarantee of security for ukraine is, once again, membership in nato. the secretary general of the north atlantic alliance, jens stoltenberg, said this during a meeting with the president of the united states of america, joe biden. according to him, the very membership of ukraine in this military-political bloc will mean that the war is

important that a new person has become at the helm of nato, the secretary general of the north atlantic alliancerutt, the former prime minister of the netherlands, and here is what he says about it , director of the council of europe, white house national security mike carpenter in the voice of america commentary. and some people don't like it, but i personally like the metaphor of the bridge to nato, because that's exactly what we're trying to achieve, the so-called bridge to nato is necessary for that ukraine could join the alliance on the same day, when there is political will for it, that is very, very important to understand, and mark rutte, in fact, can go down in history as the secretary general who, under whose rule, or whose leadership and nato will be... widespread and actually ukraine will be part of the north atlantic alliance, how do you assess, how do you assess the prospects, the prospects of mark rutte's work, i absolutely agree, first of all, with your conclusion, mr. vasyl, secondly the second is very positive for us the news that one of ukraine's allies, the prime minister of

once again, the destabilization of the european union and the paralysis of the north atlantic alliance. some of us are aware of this, but again, not all. in this regard, your rhetoric should ensure that the consciousness of the four goals that putin has set for himself, once again, the destruction of the ukrainian state, the destabilization of nato and the destabilization of the eu, the paralysis of nato and the destruction of the ukrainian people, which are all goals, which threaten not only the residents of kharkiv, kyiv or lviv, but also threaten the residents of madrid, lisbon . side, a joint decision of the nato member countries, well at least on the european continent, because in a few months the situation in the united states may change, and we do not know what the situation in the united states will be when donald trump becomes president, but president macron is already preparing for certain scenarios. in lithuania, in latvia, estonia are also preparing for certain additional scenarios, as far as i understand, in poland they are preparing for what may happen, we understand that

it is possible to guarantee the security of our country even without participation in the north atlantic alliance, many experts, including respected ones, say that, well, how is it, how is it legally possible, yes, why such a statement by biden , this is his personal opinion, whether it is inspired by some certain positions or something. certain, perhaps, as i have already said, perhaps a certain pass of russia, a demonstration of some political position, now, what was it? first, at the president's the united states does not have personal opinions, so if biden says that he does not see ukraine in nato as a condition for ending the war, it means that this is the position of the united states of america. second, president biden spoke to president zelensky during the ukrainian leader's last visit to washington. that the condition for ukraine's accession to nato should be ukrainian victory, but what is ukrainian victory is an abstract concept, as we know, in which everyone invests everything he wants, we know what ukrainian victory is victory, from the point of view of the majority of the ukrainian p

the secretary general of the north atlantic alliance, jen stoltenberg , said that ukraine will immediatelyr of nato, after the war with russia is completely finished, and not frozen. let's listen to what stoltenberg said. ukraine will become a member of the alliance. when we will have a consensus, when all the allies will agree, because as you know, decisions on enlargement are being made by consensus, it is not enough that a majority of nato allies are in favor of an invitation, we need all allies to agree, and let me add one more thing about membership: no one knows when or how the hostilities in ukraine will end, but when they will , we must be sure... that this is peace and not just a pause before another russian attack. mrs. galina, the secretary general of nato said that no one knows when the hostilities in ukraine will end and how they will end, or does this mean that the alliance allows that this war will not end in favor of ukraine? i'm a colleague, i'll allow myself a bit of criticism. of the previous speaker, let's call him that. in fact, it seems to me that it is more like a st