year,an pai, earlier this congress provided funding to ntia. thealked a little bit about mapping issue. we've provided that funding to broadband national map in coordination with the f.c.c. coordination effort going and do you believe that a process that uses state and data in addition to the material the commission collects from the form 477 render a useful map? chairman pai: i appreciate the question and your leadership on issue. i've spoken to the administrator ntia about this issue and our staffs have been in touch to make surertise to we're on the same page in terms of the need for mapping. in terms of the second part of your question which now i've forgotten. sorry. johnson: do you believe the process that uses state and material on the 477 process, will render a more accurate and useful map. chairman pai: our hope is that it will and in the meantime what we've done under my leadership start a comprehensive review of the form 477 process to make sure the information we as granular as is feasible and as useable as possible for all. who nee

we provided that funding to ntia to update the national broadband mapping coordination with the fcc. how is that coordination effort going and do you believe that a process that use state and commercial data in addition to the material the commission collects from the form 477 process will render a moring a security useful map. >> your leadership on this issue. i have personally spoken to the administeroff of ntia about the issue and and our staffs have been in touch to share expertise to make sure they are not re-inventing any wheels and we're on the same page in terms of mapping. in term of the second part of you query, which if have forgotten, sorry. >> it was do you believe the process that uses state and commercial data in addition to the material from the 477 process will rein dear moring a security useful map. >> our hope is itself would do and anyone meantime in the leadership, we have a con view of the process to make sure the information we get is as granular as feesible and usable as possible for the folks who need it, include ntia, congress, the fcc ands. >> i know you kn

about two years ago, there was an enormous effort undertaken by the ntia called the short from more than 100 of the best privacy experts in the world set in a room once a month and we went over and over and over how to communicate with users information in a short form that would appear on your smart phone. work, went by, tons of brilliant minds in the room, and then we built the software and to get out into the field and user tested it. unfortunately, the expectation of the room of brilliant privacy experts and the expectation of the private consumer were wildly different. what we found is, the language that people use, the way that they absorb information, and what they want to know, is very different. part of the problem that everyone is having right now, it happens to facebook if you watched their testimony, their basic position was we told you we were doing this, didn't you listen? parent of you as a two children, sometimes you have to change your communication style to figure out how to meet your audience where they are rather than merely from the compliance perspective, saying it

about two years ago there was an enormous effort undertaken by the ntia which was called a short form privacy notice working group, and literally 100 of the best wasn't 100 of the best privacy industry experts of the work and we went over and over and over how to to mitigate with users information and a short form that would appear on your smartphone. a year went by, tons of work,, brilliant minds in the room, and then we built the software and took it out in the field and user tested it. unfortunately, the expectations of the room a brilliant privacy experts and expectations of the common consumer were widely different. what we found is the language that people use, the way that they absorb information and what they want to know is very different. so part of the problem and what is having and happen to facebook if you watch the testimony is, the basic position was, we told you we were doing this. didn't you listen? i guess that tells you as a parent of two children sometimes you to change your communication style to figure how to meet your where they are rather than merely from a com