commissioner yee. >> thank you again vice president carter oberstone. in regards to i guess many of these pretext stops, as i stated probably about a year and a half ago i was told (inaudible) shouldn't consider it, but what we should have done maybe in the past is go to the state legislators making sure when vehicles are getting small annually or biannually, make sure that-or when they get their oil change mandate it in the state legislation that the shops need to check the break lights making sure all the lights are functional. if not, then it doesn't pass and it-making sure we in the police department do not have to police this and can avoid many of these pretext stops that did arise from it. that will be my first thing i want to say. regarding parking and i know commissioner benedicto says it is also in regards to any (inaudible) i think it needs to be in context when they are sleeping (inaudible) sleeping in the car-i'm going on. you say that won't happen. it does happen. they interpret it different way or bring it out and they say they can look at

commissioner yee. >> thank you very much vice president carter oberstone. just want to thank you cheryl davis. great job on doing this coming out of the changes and i know it is a monumental task, something that needed to be done quite a few-quite a long time ago. for today just want to ask regarding the outreach. i know you went out to the api community council, but the api community is geared toward the non profit. for me myself i come out of the chinese community association and at least 25 percent are chinese and their concern is public safety and as you change these policies our concern would be what are the impact that we will face and we the seniors or something like that. i know you guys did due diligence and stuff like that. i'm just looking at if you will consider coming out to meet with us in chinatown community as well as throughout the city. we are not just in chinatown, we are in visitation valley, bayview, richmond, sunset so we need to educate our community before it comes out and we say what happened. why are they not stopping them? cars ma

commissioner yee. >> thank you very much vice president carter oberstone. just want to thank you cheryl davis. great job on doing this coming out of the changes and i know it is a monumental task, something that needed to be done quite a few-quite a long time ago. for today just want to ask regarding the outreach. i know you went out to the api community council, but the api community is geared toward the non profit. for me myself i come out of the chinese community association and at least 25 percent are chinese and their concern is public safety and as you change these policies our concern would be what are the impact that we will face and we the seniors or something like that. i know you guys did due diligence and stuff like that. i'm just looking at if you will consider coming out to meet with us in chinatown community as well as throughout the city. we are not just in chinatown, we are in visitation valley, bayview, richmond, sunset so we need to educate our community before it comes out and we say what happened. why are they not stopping them? cars ma

commissioner yee. >> thank you again vice president carter oberstone. in regards to i guess many of these pretext stops, as i stated probably about a year and a half ago i was told (inaudible) shouldn't consider it, but what we should have done maybe in the past is go to the state legislators making sure when vehicles are getting small annually or biannually, make sure that-or when they get their oil change mandate it in the state legislation that the shops need to check the break lights making sure all the lights are functional. if not, then it doesn't pass and it-making sure we in the police department do not have to police this and can avoid many of these pretext stops that did arise from it. that will be my first thing i want to say. regarding parking and i know commissioner benedicto says it is also in regards to any (inaudible) i think it needs to be in context when they are sleeping (inaudible) sleeping in the car-i'm going on. you say that won't happen. it does happen. they interpret it different way or bring it out and they say they can look at

vice president carter-oberstone. >> thank you president. as commissioner benedicto mentioned, the mayor's office on disability and the department of disability and aging reached out to commission. we met with both and appreciate lending some of their expertise to this process. we scrutinized to make sure that nothing in this policy, we were not banning stops on our roadways but, at the same time, disabled folks and elderly folks can be disproportionately impacted even if they're not significant collisions happening. and i want to say to the public that we're committed to making this policy work. so just wanted to acknowledge the meeting and our intent. i did want to address a couple of d g.o.s that i've been assigned to. and just for background, they put together a presentation showing that there were about 25ish d g.o.s that were suppose to be in the division process directed by the department where the department had received dpe's recommendation for those revisions based on nationally recognized best practices. but those revisions were n

there were two more this week including one wrapping up as we speak where vice president carter oberstone is as well. the sessions have been tremendous sources of valuable feedback. thank the members of the community that attended the sessions. there is a informative article written last week in mission local summarizing sessions last week. overall i think by my count there have been at least 9 or 10 sessions with these additional ones, which are all most durable the most we have done for department general order which 5.01 there were 4 with one commission meeting held so call that 5. the process hasn't been perfect. i guess my friends in wealth and disparities will point out in public comment i like to provide appreciation for wealth and disparities for attention and work on this process but i do think it has been a significant improvement and a lot of transparency and community feedback and so grateful to members of community to members of organizations who participated in this process. also last week i attended the cit awards which was a tremendous privilege (inaudible) tremendous beha

. >> vice president carter oberstone, i like to take roll. [roll call]

many comments earlier tonight were focused on harms and (inaudible) commissioners carter oberstone and benedicto mentioned we dont need to deal in hypothetical (inaudible) passed a similar law in 2020 and the (inaudible) were down or the same the year before it passed. des discussing harms (inaudible) reduce the real harms we heard so many callers discussing tonight and the calls (inaudible) her dad was pulled over is still with me and i (inaudible) are listening to these stories. i know you have responsibility tomorrow but appreciate the time you are giving this and hope you adopt policy (inaudible) already existing harm. thank you. >> caller you have 2 minutes. >> hi. good evening commissioners, my name is (inaudible) i am with the organization san francisco rising and i please urge you to adopt a comprehensive policy that both requires more data and transparency and ends pretext stops in san francisco. june 2021 my partner and i was targeted in a pretext stop. we were stop under the context of tinted windows but what happened after we were stopped made it obvious (inaudible) from th