state. of the budget, we will talk about it with the coordinator of the economic expert platform, oleg hetmanre on the phone, i congratulate you, mr. oleg, good day, well, what are the reasons for the fact that during the full-scale invasion during this period, it is growing rapidly the market of illegal tobacco and illegal tobacco products, i remember that even before the great war there really were such points, they were closed to the eyes of the law enforcement officers. well, women openly sold branded duty-free cigarettes in such spontaneous markets, but now the numbers are on the contrary increasing, why explain that? well, look, we as analytical centers , as experts, we observed this situation in dynamics exactly by quarters, and if we take the year 2023 in terms of quarters, and even tantar confirms this, then starting from the first to the second and... the third quarter the shadow is the opposite decreased, there was an increase in white sales, there was a quarter-on-quarter increase in taxes and , accordingly, sales, and... and production as well , well, for example, white sales gre