the osg case began with a foreign ferral. canada suspected that the ship was dumping, and they were right. but in our investigation, one ship led to another ship to another ship. and 12 osg ships were found to be involved in illegal conduct. to have a company this large, a publicly tradeded company, a company headquartered in the uniteted states o of ame, engaged in this type of criminal cocondt was shocking to o us. oe the investigation began, we interviewed crew members on the ship. and one of those crew members came forward and he had tucked underneath his arm a little black notebook.e was the fitter of the ship, and he was asked to build a bypasss system. he w was so angrgry abot having to make the pipe, he recorded every time that they dumped overboard. "before we left the port of boston, around 4:00 to 5:00 pm, i started pumping out the slop from the tank in which the said action is against marpol." and he received over $400,000 in the case. this was a case that resulted in a $37 million penalty.e certainly hope we are

osg hpilss ve hd intoo. ha csethe m caerani n wh ion yo. ia ryhaennghi too,arcurloremrs cgrs o e ncne abt b ls cmuti tt ghen thoprtitineah re ifre the inoubite,o e pouny r bso b esveinomnieshrgh reareripitrite ct est a ao e evuaonf hecaci wiinhacouny ul see tensetr th lor-st lg-rmsot wi tt md ate al beevth wldelth pres wldddo athai soavlod t hoits d ale w ffulth ianho iisslntgl desi min al, thk erar or 2 faliesig n tt e t u a he n i rierolrbaon gutoe kedo bau itaseeunleo t at acsh tou t cre syem chrm mle o falhi -- treas stentadin e tt tthpridt rerdg t falept at diteth v.s tn f imatg rrt ogm oi rtrtis miagririndheim reriioof0 ds cae eyoot- eyese t .'s stury ssns i owhe rorcaedor taelinioofheilge d meeqrent i uliktoskf u ul adeswhyo wt rtr. kw,icin ayo oi w aerdiict scsi anghe mmsierbeuswead deanngie aun ce weelhae d fd bancbeuswendstd eacth treashe ng oweeng e rrt a stef,n ctchce s o oaut wte d ibeevthe mitis uuesewe csi obmsoretan a oen me t tinnvvef enei ae s se the mitis cseacss su. ft ate reirg f ei o cic imy rerodeanal stngeng e a. p c

osg ts rti llay esrelaonarinedly cole th gesouomincaon roiny ly0 yso mmt. thagcyakmohso d bea ns del ts. y esagci we t lod ive ct te.. its ueranbl th d'wa the wt w ha tte tm. dthbe j y c. wesk f aennc sotis g i th w rpo. oly vi o th gesoun ea onef e chs cs enoc ow. iigti a hltca , he e acisngegatn. u n psn u99 poti. ovti ihilyiky. thbieeoncoenti fo iov aomanwere avy voedn aticet tt. lemeurto iegti - imgrio thchbehalo bn voedn miatn fo. welws ve ugr rd sury, roerantond plme vifatn ocur f elors leliti othabct. prid cta pcerear go tou. e na bl d ayr w aamstbi. coin wh paedemra rk pgrs,haimrtt --smpta f elorso etheee tt eyav wh ty n'fi desc woer b ao te e prsu o t bde, atheobanteo ng exts -- mnenoonr is. th ia atrmhawos toth f bh onic befi othcotranal tougnt bdeseri. owr.ru yteaywe vet-weavonerebte -- oebtee ve 6pa whe peonurosioon miatn fo a w okorrdo rkg th oer lle t wte usanhofuy c g a asab bl tou exri. ado keueio oth ise. erarma pmutis. wi lvet tt. hltare envve thomntg heig par t hltca ror r g sugog iis otti t elor-se syem twhh veeval iotois -- porie gin at