most places can't even get pappy van winkle, it's so hard to find.y the theft of 200 bottles made headlines. it was valued at $26,000. if you were to go into a bar that carried it, there are 23-year-old vintages getting $100 per pour. not per bottle. it was considered a very premium bourbon and thus, might be the target for theft. jason: news of this alleged theft rocked the world of bourbon drinkers everywhere across the united states from bars in brooklyn to front porches down south. bret: that's exactly what happens. what's amazing, this happened in 2013, a year and a half goes by. no news, no movement. in 2015, local authorities in frankfort, kentucky, they get an anonymous tip. local authorities look into this and they trace it to a guy named toby hunsinger, who starts poking around at his premises and see huge barrels of bourbon in his backyard. immediately you think, i think we found the guy. and they looked on his phone and he has got pictures of bottles of pappy van winkle on his truck seat. it is more complicated than this. essentially what