former nypd detective pat brosnan.any of you eliminate either one of these parents right off the bat? arthur, hit it. >> all kidding aside after watching the last 40 minutes of the show, especially your interviews with the mother. i have done these investigations as a prosecutor and as a criminal defense attorney. to me she rings very true. the father there is a lot of things that -- >> judge jeanine: she rings true. a lot of people agree with you. does she ring true with you, pat? yes, no? >> no. >> because the luckiest burglar in missouri landed at that home tonight. he went in the front of the home. went inside. didn't wake the boys or the baby. the dog didn't bark. picked up two cell phones and magically transported the 10 month old out the door. >> kathleen? >> been there done that. an identical situation. perpetrator in the house. brother sleeping right next to her. father doesn't hear anything. out the front door. >> judge jeanine: that's possible. >> i spoke to kathleen about that but the only single night that

. ♪ megyn: and rejoining me now, judge jeanine peer row and pat brosnan. ask you about the screen differences. no one could have gotten through that screen, but it was only a little bit. it wasn't off the rail. >> it was the frame that was bent in, and i asked them three times, could someone have gotten in through the window, through the screen as it was that night? i was very pointed in the question. they say no. and to you they say -- megyn: well, watch it for yourselves. check it out. do you think they came many through that window? >> absolutely. megyn: do you think so? >> absolutely. >> i think so. megyn: how? because the screen was pushed out only a small amount. >> it was off the track. >> it's popped out of the track, and there's a spider web on it, so it looks like it was pushed in and then up because the spider web was rolled up. >> could somebody have fit through the frame where it was popped? >> no. >> you said it was popped, debbie. >> nothing makes sense. >> could someone have fit through this? >> would you remove it and is then push it halfw

pat brosnan is a retired new york detective, we brought him in. a whole lot of weight in this guy or the witnesses. >> it's very ambiguous and vague. let's put that in one case. the other box is a eyewitness account by mike thompson e. states he saw a naked baby in the hands of an individual at 4:00 in the morning in 40-degree temperature in kansas city. jenna: this was the guy driving home from work tonight, similar to the father driving home from work. >> similar to another eyewitness driving home on his motorcycle at 4:00 in the morning. it's not peculiar enough for thompson to say maybe that baby is connected in some way to the case that has dominated the airways. it takes all that time for thompson to tie it together, call the police and say, i can identify the guy and the baby. i don't buy it. jenna: what would you go on here, just based on the evidence, or maybe lack thereof. what would you be doing if you were working on this case now three weeks old? >> i would stay exactly where it appears the kcpd is involved right now. i'd keep it focu

where baby lisa lived, not far from the home at leecht joining me now, former police detective pat brosnan. it is tough to look at this video, because no matter what happened to this child, we know something bad, i mean, someone stole her or something happened to her and she's been missing for almost two weeks. i want to talk to you about, first, the news that the fbi is on the scene, going up and down the street reportedly with metal detectors. what do you make of that? >> that's unusual. and first of all, i think the federal response is unusual. it just speaks to the gravity of the case, let's face it, the baby didn't levitate out of the crib 11 days ago on her own accord, either involvement or complicit on the part of the biological parents, living there with the baby, or some circle of acquaintances of the friends of the parents. megyn: they've got to look into that, too, because you don't know the connection of the parents. i want to play a couple of clips we put together from judge jeanine's interviews with the parents, because there may be critical clues about the night in question.