silva and patrick shaw and anyone else. >> thank you ladies and gentlemen, today is manager's report shows in the first 3 months of 2016 theres been 2 thousand plant wraufld from the coming plan totally $36 million this is year to date of those that were 2 h 200 and thirty full withdrawals for this point plus million dollars there should be a policy to car what is going on if to the equivalent those figures reinforce what any planters have been saying that the management of our deferred coming consultant of our bar monies is lacking they could do better and therefore people are withdrawing their funds and doing better at the cost of the city after reading allowing articles about i'm giving 20 to the director and others to distribute to you the city attorney there are many concerns startling one of the issue of lobbyists to influence the awarding of this plan number two the loss of one million dollars due the financial crisis and the downturn the planter that have withdrawn from this plan i don't know how much clear it can be not working thank you. >> thank you. >> patrick shaw and (c