and whereas paul a. renne has served with a member of distinction to the san francisco ethics commission since he was first appointed in 2012. and whereas he was reappointed in 2013 to fulfill a six-year term of office as an ethics commission during which he was elected to serve as commission president in 2015 and 2016. and whereas commissioner renne completed his full term of office on february 1, 2019. therefore be it resolved on this 15th day of february 2019 that the ethics commission acknowledges paul a. renne appreciation for his distinguished service and leadership and gratitude for his enduring commitment to accountability and integrity in san francisco city government. >> vice chair kopp: i would move approval. >> commissioner smith: second. >> chair chiu: i have a hearty second. okay. i would love to take public comment -- and also, commissioners, as well, i'm so sorry. don't mean to overlook my fe y fellow commissioners. commissioner lee? >> commissioner lee: thank you. i had the privilege of servin