a professor of international development and interestingly a former aides to run us president paul gami david is president karzai doing a good job and with regard to the economy. we're on paper yes. i said growth. or you know as you mentioned those. numbers sound as a starting trends. but it's already when you begin to look at it closely. what is this growth about you find that. much of the growth in the things that are not traded. traded was. most it industry to be used to your mission industries. industry. is not. manufacturing is. nonexistent. so the industry that basically construction. mining and stuff like that. that really do not added value or exploitable david this is not this is just talking about the bits that are actually working do you don't think that that rhonda could be a role model for other african economies no absolutely not it's you cannot be in mordor flow 3 reasons 1st. this is a country. whose budget to the tune of 50 percent comes before any number 2. they cornered me we speak about the biggest act. in they going to actually is there one and put your dick front group o