michelle says one week before the fire, she and paul went to catherine's house to move his things out, and paul unlocked the basement doors. according to michelle, pauln't with her on the night of the murder. that alibi was a lie. instead, she said he was with a fellow paramedic named scott sherwood, who drove paul to narrowsburg. michelle said paul told her he went inside, set off the basement smoke alarm, hid behind the stairs, and when catherine came down to investigate, he tried to knock her out with chloroform. through her tears, michelle spilled out gruesome details of what paul said were catherine's final words. she begged him to think of their children. then, michelle claims paul took a blowtorch from the garage and set the kitchen curtains on fire. michelle's story was a stunning betrayal of her former boyfriend. and if it was true, paul had committed a vicious and calculated crime. michelle said paul told her he did it because catherine was a monster. paul's sister, alanna, didn't believe a word of it. from the moment she heard a witness had come forward, she was convinced her brother was being set up. i said, this is michelle. you got rid

paul young. where's paul at? thank you, paul. god bless you, man. thank you, paul. ul has a tough, tough race but i think not only are donald trump and i are going to win the state of michigan, paul is going to join us in the united states congress. thank you, paul. he's working hard. god bless you, man. i don't know if you saw it but it looks like maybe the cap la harris campaign, they think they have a problem with young men so they decided the solution to this -- i just saw this a couple of days a ago when i was reading the news -- is to have tim walz, v.p. candidate, play football online with a.o.c. and that's how they're going to solve their problems with young men. i saw that i guess governor walz said that a.o.c. runs a mean pick six. those of you who know football, you don't run a pick six. a pick six is something that happens on the football field. you run like a spread offense or west coast offense. it got me thinking they parade tim walz around as some kind of football genius as a former football coach and maybe i know more about football than governor tim

paul, paul, you were also with us on for air that second assassination attempt. and then, of course, the other one back in july, which actually struck the president on the ear. i mean, you just have to wonder whether things are going to change in us politics in the months and years ahead. you know, can can politicians make public appearances? will there come a point where they're only going to be on a video camera? >> i mean, they're going to have to keep making public appearances because democracy rests on the interaction between leaders and their people . and i leaders and their people. and i think british people just find it. so think british people just find it. s(at a think british people just find it. s( at a checkpoint . it does rally at a checkpoint. it does look like donald trump has once again, quite literally dodged a bullet . annunciator you and bullet. annunciator you and i were both on air and pauln attempt on donald trump whilst he was playing golf in mar a lago, which was luckily unfulfilled and unsuccessful. but once unfulfilled and unsuccessful. but orbizarre that guns are it. so bizarre that guns are so ubiquitous in the american culture. you know, this guy being arrested with guns in his car . americans drive around with car. americans drive around with gunsin car. americans drive around with guns in their car all the time. this is, you know, quite a normal thing. and i just think we i don't know about you. i can't remember the last time i saw a gun. you know, it's not part of our everyday culture. and yet, in the states, it really is. and until they sort that bit out and just get them off the streets and out of people's private ownership, then i think this is going to carry on. >> but the genie is out of the lamp on that one, isn't it? there are now more handguns in america than citizens. >> well, indeed. but i think, you know, if you look at the types of gun control that

to carl's point presidential races are like paul -- paul volt, than the target raced and the next bar is can you articulate the vision in ways that don't sound canned, that sound organic and real and can you be revealing of your self so that you don't sound like you are reciting lines, and she will have to make the sale to do that. >> not to say what she's done hasn't worked, take a look at the gap between who do you think is better able to handle the economy, inflation and border was like this with biden and this with her and in fact there's now a couple polls that suggest on the question of the economy people's projection of her being able to handle it is almost the same as their forward-looking projections of how he would handle it. >> think about what it will take for this country to really turn the page on donald trump and the republican party. i think about the 2022 midterm election where in arizona in various states, you would have the donald trump candidate win the primary but they couldn't win the general election. so i remember there was a lot of commentary at that time, peo

. >> even back to the really ugly stuff about paul-paul hello, see, and everything like that. just elevating these conspiracy theories. it's so we've never been, we've never been in a situation like this before, right. where you have such a pivotal person when of the world's richest men, running one of the world's most powerful platforms. and now literally he's decamped. his e is based in pencil ovadia for the next few weeks. during the solvent merrick garland. thank you so much coming up next stunning new video from israeli operation that led to the killing of hamas, the terror leader yahya sinwar, plus how israel may try to use his body as part of negotiations to get a hostage deal done. >> girls all want you to feel better taiwan extra tv time or all about this, introducing the only kid stopped you medicaid cuff relief new mucinex, children's mighty choose or mighty clever they are trying to shut down this legal loophole to get 100 milligram generic viagra or 20 milligram generic. see sialic delivered to your door for just $0.87 in less than two minutes. do this first scan

let's talk about paul for a second and the conversation about paul's imprisonment and paul's prison. so one of the things that i found provocative of about the book is how you reset texts in context for us related to the matter. paul and paul's imprisonment in particular. i'm thinking about how we the carceral setting of paul at four letters of paul are written from prison. so ephesians, philippians, colossians so i lehman and you call this space repeatedly the paul inhabited as his subterranean chamber which i was like i love this subterranean chamber. so here's the question. can you talk to us a bit about, the relationship between this roman carceral space that occupied this sub subterranean chamber, his enterprise of letter writing and his racket collaborations, secretaries or this of enslaved coauthors and collaborators you are referring to? how do we put these pieces together in a different kind of fits configuration that is maybe truer to what archeology is telling us, truer to what we about the text and how writing is happening now. how do you reset our our imaginations about?

terms of the presentation, i'm happy to say that. >> well done paul, are you doing very well in a stiff headwind tonight? it has to be, said paul, thank you very much. we'll be back after the break thanks to my panel. coming up next, i'll be speaking to the pub landlord being called britain's strictest carvery owner after he started charging customers for their leftovers. he's got major beef with his welcome back to farage with me. martin daubney standing in for the big man now. i love this story. a pub landlord has got a major beef with wasteful customers and his weekly sunday carvery. mike mark graham was so incensed with wasteful customers piling on all the trimmings, he even charged them extra if they were throwing their unwanted turkey into the bin. now let's introduce now the landlord of the star, in which newspapers are calling britain's strictest cavalry, mark graham, landlord of the star inn pub. welcome to the show. we've certainly got the show. we've certainly got the nation talking. mark, can we start with the notion of what gave you the idea of charging punters for wasting food ? punters for wasting food? >> well,

the question of multipolarity, the reason is very acute, in the us there was the doctrine of paul wolfowitz, paultz, a republican, he put forward a proposal, it was... after the collapse of the soviet union, that the us should never allow any country in the world to be so influential as to threaten any us interests. this doctrine leaked into the newspapers was criticized even by the new york times, because it was too imperialistic, but this concept has never left us national security policy. that's why many people in the us say that the war in ukraine is a us war against russia using ukrainians. the goal is to defeat the russians. to make sure that there is no power in the world, as wolfowitz said, that could challenge us interests. the russians will never agree to ukraine becoming a member of nato. do not forget that these are people who lost 25-30 million people during world war ii. i believe that this war in ukraine can only be resolved in the context of discussing this multipolar problem. dmitry. speaks the pure truth, because, of course, the wolfets doctrine was criticized in the newspapers,

paul, paul. >> joe biden is one of the greatest presidents according to some recent polling and ronald reagan seems to have hit a ceiling. do you see that changing over the next 50, hundred years? >> historians on us. i saw a poll about a bunch of political scientists who are notoriously left-wing and they had joe biden rated as the ninth greatest president which made me gag. but joe biden is a terrible terrible president. he's going to go down in history but by honest historians is the worst president in american history if not the worst. reagan by that token, not my standards, the standard of a liberal professor, john patrick diggins, the unofficial historian of the american left wrote books about the labor movement, the women's movement, he wrote books about civil rights but his last book, he and i became friends many years ago before he passed away, his last book was called ronald reagan, fate, freedom, the making of history and in this book he says our four greatest presidents, washington, lincoln, fdr and ronald reagan, because they left their country a better place to live than when they came into office and because they saved many people and look what reagan did with the following the berlin wall in the fall of communism, the fall of the soviet state and how he opened up the warsaw pact countries, that was all due to reagan's policies. people thought he was crazy because he said in 1980 during the campaign he said his grand strategy, to restore american morale, create a bony economy, create jobs and defeat the soviet union. they are all interlinked, he knew are happy people are productive people. people in the 70s were miserable. 17 years, john kennedy's assassination, nixon's resignation, high interest rates, high inflation, john travolta, pet rocks, jimmy carter, gerald ford's failed presidency, richard nixon's failed presidency, 17 horrible years, no good news, it was all bad and reagan saw this and said i need to restore american morale because for the first time in history in 1980, ever since it had been pulled, parents about the future would be better for the children than it had been for them until 1980 when that stopped, people did not think that anymore. so the idea that joe biden is a great president is nonsense. it's poppycock. it's ridiculous. name one thing he's done successfully other than spending money and any moron can spend money. >> i also think, reagan watched a few john travolta movies. >> he probably did. john travolta, i said that is a joke, travolta was a guest at the reagan white house several times and danced with princess diana there. >> the audience for a question here. >> i wonder if you could comment on the relationship between george bush and ronald reagan particularly after the 1980 election once they were working together and what role bush had in the policies of a making process. >> a very complicated relationship animated by the fact that mrs. reagan never warmed up to the bushes. she and barbara went to smith college but it didn't mean anything. and 8 years the reagans were president the bushes were never invited to the private residence. reagan was easier to forgive than mrs. reagan. in 1980, the issue of reagan's age came back a lot. he was too old for the presidency and this and that and it was jon stewart's false, the campaign manager, in 80 before he was fired by reagan, took reagan off the road for the year, wouldn't do anything, what happens in the vacuum, reagan making news is interesting, the gossip mongers take over, reagan is too old, things would be better, nasty stuff. a lot of this came from the bush campaign. they are animated, they were establishment whereas reagan was antiestablishment. it was always going to be a clash. i will tell you when example, bush was chairman of the republican national committee asked to buy a reporter, tell me, ambassador, are you a liberal, moderate, or conservative and bush disdainfully says labels are for cans. reagan would have knocked that out of the park. he would go into a long dissertation on libertarianism being the basis of american conservatives, he would refer you to books and events in history. there was always that and he attacked reagan's tax-cut plan, that set off mrs. reagan. she wrote in her diary that that set her off and slurs about reagan's age because ronald reagan was fighting a false rumor about his age, bush was jogging everywhere. he was jogging in texas, he was jogging in iowa, he was jogging in new hampshire, jogging for the benefit of the media and then he went to a gym in concorde and did weight lifts, let me see ronald reagan do that. that really really was number on her. i understand why. so he picked bush because he was out of options at the convention. they tried gerald ford, that worked for about 8 hours and then fell apart. it was nonsense really. jim baker said if elected, would you call ford mr. president, mr. vice president or mister vice president, mr. president. it fell apart and reagan was out of options, jack kemp was too younger. the one option i wish he had thought of was to go back to his 76 tour, dick schweikert, really good man, senator from pennsylvania, changed dramatically when he was reagan's running made in 76, he was a moderate republican the senator although he was great on captive nations, he was pro-life, pro-second amendment, he was weak on labor issues but that's understandable being from pennsylvania. he changed radically, he had become a very good conservative by 1980. with handford, dick allen and all those, and already tested and vetted and the good guy, wonderful family, no downside and helped unify the convention. >> an issue in new hampshire and detroit. to paul's question. bush gave a masterful speech at the reagan funeral, missus bush chose bush, wanted a president to speak at the reagan funeral, the national cathedral. and a clash of culture and bush was houston elitist, goes to school in a limousine. a great man, great hero of world war ii, they had lunch once a week, reagan tried but on the other hand they disagree on so many things. it was a very complicated relationship. mrs. reagan said i sleep with this guy, of course i will give him my advice, and in those opinions for mrs. reagan. >> you take the model of listening to your wife. and one more question, let's take one more question. he's not going anywhere, never upset and let's have chris and q and a in the book signing. >> craig, coming back to the polling made a minute ago, presidents that come from outside the political class versus those that do, reagan and trump come to mind, you also have covered a lot of other history and looked at different presidencies do you see a pattern in

paul stephen paul and then well simons who didn't seem like he was as much of an extremist as he's turned out to be and that of course is part of the reason why these all these columers have left because they're much more associated with the revision sign sorry with the labor tradition and with killing palestinans in the slower way out of the vision of the of the... world's press, so there's that division which is there, and if you look at the editors of the jewish chronacle over over all of the years, they've tended to be much more sympathetic to - to laborers kind of of position, and that's of course is what's changed in the last 20 or so years with the chronicle, interesting, well nasa, the the jewish chronicles reportage has been subjected to numerous lawsuits and and complaints in recent years, hasn't it? yeah, this is especially during the the jeremy corbin when jeremy corbin was the leader of the labour party, under stephen pollard, the newspaper really focused on defaming and attacking corbin and his supporters and the palestine solidarity movement, and as i explained in my book, weaponizing anti-semitism, it was really the jewish chronicle which spearheaded the campaign against corbin in the british press in a lot of ways, they they provided a real weapon against the the corbin movement, they've they've had. to pay as a result they've had to pay out uh libal damages, they've had this long tack track record of really labeling uh the movement around and pro-palestinian solidarity activists and palestinians in particular indell david, i mean what do you think the departure of high profile pro israel columnists like jonathan friedland and and david bedill for example, but what does that say do you think about the jewish chronicle? it says has become more and more partisan look um friedland is is a car carrying sonist he come all the way through his life he was in as a youth he was having drawer the the racist zianist youth group so was andil was also in a the similar youth group and the and of course ironovic is a former communist party member let's remember this so they come they come from the left of zionism and uh so there's an extent to which the this war that's going on inside the uh the colony itself between netanyahu on the one hand and the the idf, these so-called defense forces uh and the intelligence services, this is a this is wit large in the british jewish community, it's a reflection of that division really is that and so they they they're fully paid up to the genocide of the palestinians, but they just want to do it in a slightly uh nicer seeming way, that that's that's the difference and that's the only difference, but of course these people camouflage themselves with being on the left, they they say that they're on the left, the... to appear to be liberals, but they're not really, do you think there's a likelihood that they might return or do you think it's good night vienna they're never going to? it's good in viena, mean this is the this is the end game for the jewish chronicle, mean unless there's a revolution. jewish chronicle, let's remember the the jewish chronicle was taken over in in recent years by this guy robby gibb, we might come to talk about later, who is an ultra extremist and uh and people associated with him, and and it it was taken over from a the company which had owned it, the foundation which had own it for many many, many years, and that was the final death now for the possibility of those kinds of people uh in running the paper, right? yeah, well, briefly, before we go to our next report, ace, the jewish chronicle is the only british newspaper long. zionist crimes is this, mean you've got the jewish news, the guardian, john friedland obviously associated with and others, they're also complicit, aren't they? yeah, absolutely, the jewish news is another newspaper which like the jewish chronicle um portrays itself as the the voice of the jewish community in britain that it is a jewish community newspaper, but both the jewish chronicle and the jewish news are, they're really their main focus is not so much jewish life in... although they do report on that too, but is really israel is really propping up israel and really propping up support for israel uh in the west, the jewish news as well was also very involved in the campaign against corbin, if you remember the labor party conference, i believe in 2019 they had a front page uh story in which they were really trying to um say that the pro-palestinian motion at conference that year was anti mitic and they were, they were, they were calling it disturbing that there was palestinian flags, flying at labour party conference, so they they were equally as involved in the campaign as the the jewish chronicle, absolutely, well, our next report, surveys the jewish chronicles downward spiral into the gutter under its previous and current editors, the jewish chronicle is known for acting as mouth piece for the israel lobby. while it has supported the zinist regime for many years, it began to acquire its current infamy around 2008. that was when stephen polard, previously a columnist with the daily express tabloid, became the jewish chronicles editor. pollards pro israel and anti-muslim biases were clear from the beginning. only two years before becoming the jewish chronicles editor, polard had written the made of veil manifesto where he spoke about the... need to preserve western civilization from so-called islamist. as editor of the jewish chronicle, he published racist screeds against muslims. the anti-palestinian islamophobic journalist douglas murray has been repeatedly featured in the paper. so to has melanie phillips, a pro israel writer who has stoked islamophobia throughout her career. on paul's, one of the most weld'. mented zionist atrocities during the nakba of 1948 as quote an alleged killing. pauld also published numerous articles smaring pro- palestine activists and organizations which resulted in various lawsuits against the paper. in 2019, british charity interpal, which provides humanitarian, medical, and educational support to palestinians, sued the paper for claiming that it had links to terrorist activity. the paper was forced to pay out £50,000 pounds in damages and to issue apology. the jewish chronicle has also been forced to issue apologies and pay damages to several pro- palestine political activists like audrey white and marksworth, highlighting the papers pattern of using unverified and exaggerated claims, but the problems didn't stop when polard was succeeded by the papers current editor jake wallis simons. wallace simons has exhibited the same islamophobia and anti-palestinian tendencies as his predecessor. in a 2010 interview he said that were britain an

paul adams. . ~ . , adams. paul adams did touch u on adams. paul adams did touch upon this _ adams. eli government, - the things driving the current israeli government, it- the things driving the current israeli government, it is- the things driving the current israeli government, it is this| israeli government, it is this deed, — israeli government, it is this deed, unshakeable - israeli government, it is thisi deed, unshakeable conviction that this _ deed, unshakeable conviction that this is _ deed, unshakeable conviction that this is all _ deed, unshakeable conviction that this is all ours, _ deed, unshakeable conviction that this is all ours, the - deed, unshakeable conviction that this is all ours, the landi that this is all ours, the land given— that this is all ours, the land given to _ that this is all ours, the land given to us _ that this is all ours, the land given to us try— that this is all ours, the land given to us by god. - that this is all ours, the land given to us by god. and - that this is all ours, the land given to us by god. and on. that this is all ours, the l

paul>it. oh. oh, yeah okay. >vern>all >>right. i am grateful it takes place somewhere else in the country. >paul>for now.ow >>giant spiders that normally live in parts >>> the last story, on a personal note, gentlemen, is something i see in my nightmares. i absolutely hate everything about it. >> oh yeah, okay. >> i am grateful it takes place somewhere else in the country, for now. giant spiders that normally live in parts of asia have popped up in boston, massachusetts. not going there anytime soon. i know i have family there. >> it's a wicked big spider. >> nice knowing you. this is what they look like. they are called joro spiders. they are venomous but apparently not dangerous to people. still, they are big. they can get around 8 inches. even though they are from eastern asia, they started to pop up in the u.s. in 2014. they were accidentally displaced, according to some scientists. someone or something brought them to the u.s. on accident, they say. down in georgia is where they were first spotted but they have since gone north. experts say they are slow-moving and gentle, for now. there is always a

paul richards. paul labour adviser, paul richards. ly getting a bit of a kicking? >> i'm afraid my sound has just gone off. >> oh, i think the sound we're having issues with the sound. paul having issues with the sound. paul. we'll come back to you, which is a shame. it is quite funny, this narrative emerging that you know, all of these evil right wing journalists. >> oh, boo . who do you know what >> oh, boo. who do you know what you play those games. you. you topple governments because of cake in downing street. and whatever else and wallpaper in downing street. you set the standards. that's the rules. you set, you set. you were responsible for that. so people would argue if you want to play the game by such strict and tough rules, then i guess, to be quite frank, suck it up. this is it. you're in government now, andifs it. you're in government now, and it's a lot easier to cheer from the sidelines and points and wail from the sidelines as it is actually running the country and away from the freebie gate and things like that, which s

paul stephen paul and then we was simons who didn't seem like he was a uh much of an extremist as he's turned out to be, and that of course is part of the reason why these all these columns have left, because they're much more associated with the division sign, sorry with the labor science tradition and with killing the palestinians in slower way out of the vision of the of the world's press, so there's that division which is there, and if you look at the editors of the jewish chronicle over over all of the years, they've tended to be much more sympathetic to to labor signist kind of position, and that's of course is what's changed in the last 20. so years with the chronicle, interesting, well nasa, the the jewish chronicles reportage has been subjected to numerous lawsuits and and complaints in recent years, hasn't it? yeah, this is especially during the the jeremy corbin years when jeremy corbin was the leader of the labour party under stephen polard, the newspaper really focused on defaming and attacking corbin and his supporters and the palestine solidarity movement and as i explained in my book weaponizing anti-semitism, "it was really the jewish chronicle which uh spearheaded the campaign against corbin in the british press in a lot of ways, they they provided a real weapon against the..." the corbin movement, they've they've had to pay as a result they've had to pay out uh liabal damages, they've had this long track track record of really libeling uh the movement around and pro- palestinian solidarity activists and palestinians in particular, mean what do you think the departure of high profile pro israel columnists like jonathan friedland and and david bedill for example, but what does that say do you think? about the jewish chronicle, it says it's become more and more partisan, look friedland is is a car carrying sonist, he come all the way through his life, he he was in as a youth he was in hapnem drawer, the the racist zianist youth group, so wasil was also in a the similar youth group, and the and of course ironovic is a former communist party member, let's remember this so they come they come from the left of zionism and uh so there's an extent to which this war that's going on inside the uh the the settler colony itself between netanjahu on the one hand and the the idf, the so-called defense forces uh and the intelligence services, this is a this is written large in the british jewish community and it's a reflection of that division really is that and so that they they they're fully paid up to the genocide of the palestinians, but they just want to do it in a slightly uh nicer seeming way, that that's that's the difference and that's the only difference, but of course these people camouflage themselves with being on the left the... they say that they're on the left, they want to to appear to be liberals, but they're not really, do you think there's a likelihood that they might return or do you think it's uh good night vienna they're never going to oh is good night vienna i mean this is the this is the end game for the jewish chronicle i mean unless there's a revolution in the jewish chronicle let's remember the the jewish chronicle was taken over in in recent years by this guy robby gibb who we might come to talk about later who is an ultra extremist and uh uh and the people associated with him and and it it was taken over from a the company which had owned it the foundation which down it for many many, many years, and that was the final death now for the possibility of those kinds of people uh in running the paper, right? yeah, well briefly before we go to our next report, asar, the jewish chronicle isn't the only british newspaper laundering zionist crimes, is this? i mean, you've got the jewish news, the guardian, john friedland obviously associated with and others, they're also complicit, aren't they? yeah, absolutely, the jewish news is another newspaper, which like the jewish chronicle, um, portrays itself, as the the voice of the jewish community in britain that it is a jewish community newspaper, but both the jewish chronicles and jewish news are, they're really their main focus is not so much jewish life in britain, although they do report on that too, but is really israel is really propping up, israel is really propping up support for israel uh in the west, the jewish news as well was also very involved in the campaign against corbin, if you remember at the labor party conference. believe in 2019 they had a front page, yes uh story in which they were really trying to um say that the pro-palestinian motion at conference that year was anti-semitic and they were they were they were calling it disturbing that there was palestinian flags uh flying at labour party conference so the they were equally as involved in the campaign as the the jewish chronicle absolutely well our next report surveys the jewish chronicles downward spiral into the gutter under its previous and current editors. the jewish chronicle is known for acting as mouth piece for the israel lobby. while it has supported design regime for many years. it began to acquire its current infamy around 2008. that was when stephen pollard previously a columnist with the daily express tabloid, became the jewish chronicles editor. god's pro israel and anti-muslim biases were clear from the beginning. only two years before becoming the jewish chronicles editor, paul had written the made of veil manifesto where he spoke about the need to preserve western civilization from so-called islamists. as editor of the jewish chronicle, he published racist screeds against muslims. the anti-palestinian islamophobic journalist douglas murray has been repeatedly featured in. the paper, so to has melanie phillips, a pro israel writer who has stoked islamophobia throughout her career. on polard's watch, the paper described the dear yassin massacre, one of the most well-documented zionist atrocities during the nakba of 1948, as quote, an alleged killing. polod also published numerous articles smaaring pro-palestine activists and organizations which resulted in various lawsuits against. the paper. in 2019, british charity interpal, which provides humanitarian, medical, and educational support to palestinians, sued the paper for claiming that it had link. to terrorist activity. the paper was forced to pay out £50,000 pounds in damages and to issue apology. the jewi

paul is saint paul and thecla was one of the most. favorite saints the time she was a woman disciple of paul and she was leader of the community. she preached. she performed miracles. she baptized and she was hailed as an example that women can be leaders in the church and women can preach and women can baptize and perform miracles so and so this was one popular text with one view of women. then there was another a letter allegedly from paul to timothy, which most scholars today think is a much later was not written by saint paul in the first century, probably forged his name sometime in the second century, and in this letter, a completely view of women and the role in the church it that women should be obedient, should be silent, should never be leaders they should fulfill themselves by doing whatever men tell them to do and by having children and raising children. this is their role in life. and the committee in carthage decided exclude the acts of paul and thecla from the top 27. but include this letter timothy which is still part of the new testaments around the world. first timothy and this is shaped the views billions of c

permanent resident anyone a pulitzer prize is a contributor and paul paul n and also the radio for yournalist. that deal involvement in countries. it was a hard deal to put together, the person that was released from germany had been convicted of a heinous crime. i'm not one to say to any deal that comes your way but i do know that someone who is been the subject of one of the hostage takings and ultimately a deal for my release there is a moral imperative to bring innocent people home as quickly and safely as possible. at the same time yet to come up with the measures to make this activity less attractive and more costly to the perpetrators. i've had the opportunity to meet evan several times and i won't get into a lot of details but i feel like he's well on his way to recovery and i'm excited for him to see what you will do next. he has a hell of a story to tell and i'm eager to watch him tell it. but it's a story that never should have to be told. >> i think it is time to sum up, this is an important conversation to begin the first amendment summit, bring together for our audience wh

we had an incredible senator from minnesota we lost in a plane accident named paul wellstone. and paul wellstone taught us a lot of things but i simplified the economy with a saying he had. he said it's simple, folks, we all do better when we all do better. some folks have a tough go and things get difficult. vice president put out and released agenda, an opportunity for black men. no denying there are historyal barriers that stop people and no reason that home ownership should be different because there is generational wealth. we know that. [cheers and applause] we need to make sure the housing and all that and specifically targeting access to capital for black entrepreneurs to start their own business is absolute. making sure we are targeting job training so folks can get the skill and capital they need to be their own bosses or work them in the industry that makes you the middle class. so that's an agenda that is out there. and look, there is a disproportionate impact on laws around cannabis have set back folks in those communities. when we in minnesota talk about this and kamala ta

paul solman, gave that a closer look. >> an invasion of criminal migrants. paul: for former president donald trump, immigration has long been an obsession. >> we are a dumping ground. we are a garbage can for the world. paul president harris too promises to crack down on illegal crossings. >> we will pursue more severe terminal charges against repeat violators. paul: 55% of americans say they favor reduced immigration amidst a record number of illegal crossings late last night -- late last year, straining resources in several cities. though crossings have since plunged. these are immigrants in the south bronx, learning construction safety basis. almost all have asked for asylum and are in legal limbo until their cases are resolved. how many of you think you will be working in two months? what kind of work? well, he came here years ago from the dominican republic. he says he has done every job he can find. >> electrician, carpenter, plumber. paul: wilbur has been here just one month. >> i go to home depot. a lot of migrants know to look for construction jobs there. paul: alfonso endured the nightmare trek from venezuela through the jungle to get to america with his young sons and wife. >> we were robbed ju

paul young. where is paul? hi, paul. [applause] they like that. good luck, paul. and michigan g.o.p.hairman pete hoekstra who has been a friend of mine for a long time. i went to pete, you know, he's very successful politician, congressman. and then he retired and did other things. did a great job. then became ambassador, he was a great ambassador. i said you've got to take over the party. i want you. he's done a hell of a job. are we going to win? [cheers and applause] we're going to win. thanks, pete. good job. lying kamala is the worst vice president, according to many in the history of our country. she wants to open borders, totally open borders, keep them open. if she gets in, you'll have 200 million people in here along with you. not 21 million that they let in already. she'll deliver even more catastrophic inflation. she was an original creator of defund the police. defund the police. anybody that wants to defund the police is not qualified to be the president of the united states. because it shows you're a radical left lunatic. i mean when you want to defund the police it sho

paul hagerman: did you talk to sherra? oh, yeah. paul hagerman: did she tell you that he was missing? no. paulerman: and was your understanding that sherra wright never called him? no. she never did. no. paul hagerman: you had to. i had to. andrea canning: but the star witness for the prosecution was sherra's cousin jimmie martin, who told the jury what he had said to the police years earlier, that sherra wanted lorenzen dead, and she had turned to him and billy turner for help. when sherra's talking about this business that she shouldn't be in, killing lorenzen, is billy turner there? yes, sir. paul hagerman: obviously, you're there. and you described it as what, brainstorming? like brainstorming. they were coming up with ways of how to best, you know, perform the act. paul hagerman: ok. and what act are we talking about? the murder of lorenzen. paul hagerman: all right. and you say they were coming up with ways. jimmie martin: we were. you were too, weren't you? yeah. andrea canning: though he took part in the planning, even helped find the location, jimmie said he wasn't there when the murd

policy ins instincts are to be as protective of them as possible. >> paul, thank you so much for joining us. appreciate your time today. paullant. >>> coming up, consumer confidence just saw its biggest jump in nearly four years. and stock market optimism, hold your breath for this, it's at its highest level since reagan was in office. but there are signs of weakness in a few battleground states. all the details and what it means for the market, next. and the busiest week of earnings season rolls on with a third of the s&p and dow on deck to report. we have the action and trade for amd, visa and alphabet coming up. stay with us. >> this is "the exchange" on cnbc. it's our son, he is always up in our business. it's the verizon 5g home internet i got us. oh... he used to be a competitive gamer but with the higher lag, he can't keep up with his squad. so now we're his “squad”. what are kevin's plans for the fall? he's going to college. out of state, yeah. -yeah in the fall. change of plans, i've decided to stay local. oh excellent! oh that's great! why would i ever leave this? -aw! we will do anything to get him gaming again.

paul want us to be focusing on the £63 billion investment.— billion investment. paul scally, former business _ billion investment. pauless minister, - billion investment. paul scally, former business minister, you | billion investment. paul scally, - former business minister, you must welcome the amount of investments? £63 billion coming into the uk economy— £63 billion coming into the uk economy is a really good thing for us as_ economy is a really good thing for us as a _ economy is a really good thing for us as a country. i am back into business — us as a country. i am back into business now and i will be welcoming that as _ business now and i will be welcoming that as well. i think only about 10% of it is— that as well. i think only about 10% of it is new. — that as well. i think only about 10% of it is new, announced today. a lot of it is new, announced today. a lot of that _ of it is new, announced today. a lot of that was — of it is new, announced today. a lot of that was from auctions before the data centres that were announced and those _ data centres that were announced and those things that will come in, bu

paul, for your incredible courage and thank you. i think you can represent team usa one day. paul with tori, thank you for representing at paris. this is not my house, this is your house. that's the god's truth. team usa's house. i get temporary residence, only a couple months left. [laughter] so thank you to all your family and friends support, for these incredible athletes. tori's dad said it best, only in america. only in america. do we believe anything is possible. i spent close to 100 hours alone with xi jinping in china. when i was vice president he said can you define america for me. it's the god's truth i said yes in one word, he looked at me and i said possibilities. we are only nation who thinks anything is possible when we set our mind to do it. that's what all of you embodied. we have the entire nation saying thank you for representing the very best of america. [applause] and because i'm president, they wouldn't let me go to the olympics. [laughter] but i watched it all, jill my wife went to the olympics. guess what, i was supposed to be introducing at the inauguration

and again at 6 pm. >> all right, let's have a look at all the sport for you with paul weir sailing away. paul ? paul what we. after. after what we did yesterday, we went through all the sailing terms, didn't we? yeah. and the amount of it and a huge amount of sailing terms that are used in everyday language. and i swear this is true. i was out with a dog yesterday and a gentleman came up to an ahoy there. and so, so either he thought i was a sailor or i'd been watching the show. i think it's probably it's probably the latter. i think it probably is. anyway, the america's cup. oh, it's very long and complicated. britain and team ineos, team britannia going against team luna rossa from italy. they're six four up at the moment. you know what? i'm just going to stop trying to explain it and have someone that does know what he's talking about. it's our friend and he's a sailing broadcaster. alec wilkinson joins us now from barcelona. morning, alec. >> morning, paul. listen, it's long, but it's not really complicated. >> i know it isn't, but the thing is , i managed to make the thing is, i managed to make

paul. stay safe, always a pleasure to check in with you. mr. paul lorudi there from the free palestine movement joining us from berkeley, california, and bewers. these we've been in the middle of rolling coverage all all night. iran has uh fired dozens of ballistic uh missiles uh, last night, tuesday evening in west asia at key military and security targets in israel, namely against the tel aviv in response. deadly attacks on gaza and lebanon as well as the marturdom of a senior hezbulah, hamas and irgc uh leaders. israel says large number of those missiles were intercepted, a claim refuted by images you could search anywhere online and media outlets to attain and see how many of those missiles you see hitting targets in tel aviv. israely officials avawed a response but time and again uh multiple iranian officials said that the regime will face a crushing response. if it attacks iran and um we're following developments very closely here on press tv we're going to show you leave you for a short bit and be back to continue our rolling coverage in abou

paul richards. paul special adviser paul richards. paul, you heard what i had to say. ent is still the same. where do you stand with all that? with all of that? >> well, i was thinking, come on now , get off. get off the fence. now, get off. get off the fence. why don't you tell us what you really think ? you know, i mean, really think? you know, i mean, that was quite the broadside. but if we if we unpack it a little bit, the carbon capture announcement is over 25 years, and it will create some really good quality jobs for people in merseyside. and teesside. give some young people apprenticeships and move us towards a greener economy. i don't mourn the loss of the last coal mine. i don't think we should be digging up coal anymore. it is a redundant technology and you can't complain about ending the coal mines. and then also complain about solar and onshore wind because we are going to have to move to those renewables. >> well, i'm complaining about it because and also safeguard the planet. well, i'm complaining about it because of course, in to order make certain thing

paul mauro. paul, it's great to see you again. what do you make of this? because governor abbott, you know, governor abbott called in the national guard. he's been building the border barriers that bidenharris undercut. he's been trying to reverse and stop bad policies like getting rid of trump's remain in mexico and title 4 4 the 2 -- 4 the 2 and the executive actions. hooest saying -- he's saying stop taking credit for the work we have done. >> the idea is beyond laughable. i mean, let's review here. he was the border czar for almost the entire period of her tenure, and i know she's going to the claim root cause czar, whatever. whatever you term it, she should have taken some action regard aing the border. and consider the fact that as the second highest executive in the country, especially as being deemed the border czar with the president's -- she was in a position to have a meeting with alejandro mayorkas,s with head of the fbi, chris wray, with the head of doj and just say, okay, guys, let's come up with a plan to not only harden the border but to interdistrict the groups like tren de aragua. she did none of that and, in fact, she's played games with these parole programs where we're now flying in something like 30,000 a month from cuba, haiti, nicaragua and venezuela. they don't even go through the southern border, so no wonder the encounters are down. she's done nothing, and it's a little too late to visit the border and say she's tiepghtenning it up. elizabeth: she said trump's border wall was a, quote, stupid waste of money, that's what she tweeted out a few years ago. border officials saying kamala harris falsely claiming they need a bill, they could shut the border down now. the supreme court already backed a bill. border officials opposed the senate bill kamala keeps touting the. it would cement in place 1.8-22 million -- 2 million illegals crossings a year. let me get to the new fight over the shocking new i.c.e. data that spans the last 40 years. more than 425 illegal aliens with criminal records in the u.s., worthy of pending charges against them. show the data. including 15,000 illegal aliens convicted or to or charged with homicide, tens of thousands of other concerns -- criminals. what do you make of these numbers? not all of this happened on kamala harris' and biden's watch. it happened over the last 40 years, but i don't think people knew hundreds of thousands of illegal aliens with crime charges against them are inside the u.s.. >> so let's tie this to her primary rejoinder regarding donald trump's provisions along the border which was that he said let's not go through with the bipartisan bill. no provisions in the bipartisan bill to get anybody out. a fatal flaw and was one of the problems that shows she's not really being honest with us. elizabeth: paulan out of time. we'll have you back, we hope, very soon. it's good to see you begun. >> and you -- again. >> i believe the president of these united states can be indicted -- >> we're going to be a real pain in the ass. i think they know my name personally. elizabeth: whoa, another democrat attempt at lawfare against former president trump could fail. new york appeals court judges now poking holes, major holes, in new york attorney general letitia james' case against trump. we've got the former clerk to supreme court justice neil gorsuch, he's mike davis. he's going to take it on on the. also this -- the. >> ever since iran has been exporting terror all over the world, it's been just unraveling. the whole middle east has been unraveling. but, of course, the whole world has been unraveling since we left office. russia would have never attacked ukraine. this would have never if happened in the middle east. there wouldn't have been is an october 7th. you wouldn't have had inflation. none

paul finkelman until about 9:00 this morning, but certainly have been very, very familiar and, heavily influenced by his very, very sound insightful and really at times revolutionary. so dr. paul finkelman is currently visiting professor marquette university school of law and he has had, needless to say, a very distinguished and continues to have a distinguished scholarly career. he is the author editor of more 50 books, has published more than 200 of you articles scholarly articles and book chapters. dr. finkelman is widely recognized as a leading expert in a variety of areas, including the american civil war. american legal history, constitutional law, slavery and law and religion the united states supreme court is quoted and cited. dr. work or mentioned him in six decisions. has lectured on human trafficking, on human rights issues. at the united nations and more than a dozen countries in. 2017 he held the fulbright chair in human rights and social justice at the university of ottawa. so please join me in giving a warm welcome to dr. paul finkelman paul finkelman. thank you. it's a delight to be here. in case you're wondering, the thai has the people who ended slavery in the united states on it. ulysses, general sherman, general sheridan and various other united states army generals. during the civil war. i'm not going to talk a lot about slavery today. but slave obviously looms over everything we do. and it is important to understand when we think of the the war in 1861, 1865, by the way. do you know what the official for the war is, right? it is the war of the rebellion. it is not the civil war. it is not the war of southern independence. it is or the war of southern treason, depending on which side you're looking at. it is the war of the rebellion. but the. the. can you hear me now? i'm not. which mic i'm supposed to be. how about. do i need to repeat all that, or did you get enough of it? okay, so. so one of the things to understand is that secession caused by slavery, everybody knows that in 1861, everybody knows

paul steinhauser to talk about the latest developments in the presidential and senate house campaigns of the last week. >> we are joined by desmond right with notice. joining us via zoom is paul steinhauser. i want to start with your latest piece on the politics of disaster response. the fox news headline back to back hurricanes rock the harris-trump presidential campaigns. explain how these disasters are playing out on the campaign trail? >> good morning from pittsburgh and it is no surprise hurricanes have been impacting political presidential campaigns for a long time. think back to 1992 and president herbert walker bush, his response, fema's response to hurricane andrew which slammed into florida did him no favors. we have seen presidents as well, think 2012, superstorm sandy smacked into the eastern seaboard. arguably helped president obama win reelection. we have back to back hurricanes. helene which tore through the southeast doing some immense damage in states like georgia and north carolina. two crucial battleground states. and now milton which yesterday we saw go through florida and there is still a huge mess down there. a couple million still without power and the death toll as well. obviously former president trump, his campaign, you heard the clip you just played from senator vance a few minutes ago. very critical of what president biden and vice president harris, it is the same administration, they see this as a political opportunity to criticize the competence of kamala harris. >> what are the campaign saying about efforts to ensure voting access in hurricane impacted areas? modify early voting days and changing polling locations if needed. >> both republicans and democrats at the local level are open to try to make sure they are retaining access to people's right to vote in these hard-hitting areas. in 2020 republicans were not for modifications to early voting days when it came to issues like disasters and now they are asking for it in states like north carolina and georgia that were hard hit and that are going to be consequential to president trump's base. i think it is getting to paul'soint. the former president has used these disasters to criticize vice president harris but vice president harris is using disasters to criticize former president trump because him spreading that this information saying fema was giving disaster relief to migrants which has been debunked several times falls into her campaign's playbook which allows them to say look, there are two choices in temperament. there is president trump and vice president harris. allowing her to call him on serious and her to -- her to say he is unsympathetic. we have seen her try to show the most sympathy to the american people. it is also working on the vice president's. >> you mentioned you are in pittsburgh. that is where barack obama was appearing with kamala harris with the campaign should this is barack obama about a minute and a half from yesterday. >> when donald trump lies or cheats or shows utter disregard for our constitution, when he calls pows losers or fellow citizens vermin, people make excuses fo

paul for a second conversation about paul and prison letters. so one of the things that i found provocative about the book is how you reset tax in context for us related to the matter of paulimprisonment and in particular i'm thinking about how we imagine the settings but paul at least four letters of paul written from prison so ephesians in philippians colossians and you call this space repeatedly the place the paulan inhabited subterranean chamber and love this greatest subterranean chamber is the question.ca can you talk to us a bit about thesh relationship between understanding the roman space the paul occupied the subterranean chamber to enterprise the letter writing and is recognize collaboration secretaries or the category of the enslaved co-author and collaborators and people these pieces together in a different kind of configuration that is may be to what is archaeology is telling us that more true to what we know about the text and how the writing is happening now and how do you reset our imagination about paul writing letters. >> yes so you for asking about this great deal about this and am happy to talk about this. so concerned with the archaeology. and already

heritage capital president paul schatz. paul's interesting because sam stovall was sort of saying the same thing, right? we've got a chart here, path to the s&p 500 on any given year normally goes up. and in an election year we're in this space right now, right? we get that little bit of anxiety into the election, but after a the election, back up. this is where we are right now. >> that's right. and really except for year 2000 and 2008, i think that probably follows suit this year as well. look, you were talking about the vix earlier and why is the vix going up. almost every election year -- remove '008 because that was an exogenous event -- but the vix normally goes up 50-100% from some september low the some period before the election. we're in that spike. i think the vix is up now about 40% from the september low -- august low. so we're kind of trading in this normal pre-election pattern. charles: so then the bottom line, this area of this weakness for you and throw in, like, the recent hurricanes and anything else, this is

let's bring in bespoke investment group and market intel co-founder paul hickey. paul? the market ain't one of the problems. little sarcasm but you do point out this rally, listen, the rally does very very well once it goes past the two year point but the third year can be choppy. >> just like you say anyone with kids when the toddlers turn two, you tend to get growth spurts and problems, so pullbacks what we seen is below average returns over the next year, and less consistency of positive returns about half the time. charles: you've had some negative, a lot more red on here than a lot of the charts. >> than you would normally see , so i think in this respect there's so much good news out there we're looking at that that could be one of the biggest risks for the market here, that what is not to like. you talk to a lot of people out and there's not much they don't like at this point, and so when people do become a little come complacent the market keeps you honest. charles: a couple of weeks ago the narrative said the fed is coming to the rescue, market goes up. now the

paul begala. >> paul, very nice to see you as you well know today marks an important milestone in this selection exactly one month and one day before election day. look, you've been in the room at this moment before. what's the one thing that each campaign needs to do in this remaining month and day well, it's actually two things. >> you need to fire up your base. you can't win without two pace then you also have to reach out to those voters. >> you don't yet have. now, the way to do that is with president clinton, you say they have wedge issues. we need web issues that stitch together our base and those swing voters. louisville, kamala harris is doing. >> she's she has electrified her base. i mean, they were very depressed when biden was a candidate very excited now that kamala is and she's reaching out, even getting liz cheney for going to say she's holding together coalition from aoc to liz cheney meanwhile, mr. trump well, he fires up the base, but the things he does that fire up his base, alienates those voters. he does not yet have i mean, i haven't met a single swing voter who said, you know, i'm really concerned about those people in ohio eating each other's cats you know i mean he just so off putting in so he's i think not doing what he needs to do candidly, he's fired up his base. we always talk about that. but nothing moves trump's vote down because that base is so solid, nothing, nothing, nothing he is convicted of 34 felonies. >> anyone at one point? >> okay. >> i mean, it nothing moves it up very much. thank god, he survived an assassination attempt. he moved up 1.2%. so he trades in such a narrow band. this is a race for trump where everything has happened and nothing has changed his vote so interesting, you brought up bill clinton because of course, on the 1992 clinton campaign, you famously worked with james carville to help get bill clinton elected. and they're just happens to be a new cnn documentary coming out this weekend called carnival winning is everything kamala stupid. you feature prominently in this documentary and wonderfully, by the way, i want to play a short clip of it they both passionate little love their country. >> they both passionate love politics they're both really expert in their students of the game. >> but on different sides. they have such a famous know it's like a cliche, such a famous mixed marriage. she's a devout republican. he's a reptile. >> and yet they've made it work over the years i'm really a conservative he's really illiberal history. things are changing in change wife, i'm not changed sexual orientation and not changing the political party we're going to go to the how foot, what we got here, okay they have a deep love and a deep perspective. >> there's no question and the secret i believe i know, but secret i believe to their marriages. they don't talk about politics what is it like living with you two friday night? if we, were with you, we've probably be having a good stiff drink, which we'll get to go do right now i'll let you go do that. >> married. thing to james carville. thank every bad join him about the marriage between james carville and republican mary matalin. but you went to james immune, obviously your great friends of them, you said you talked to him every day, at least once for the last what, 30 plus years. what makes him 40? >> 40? >> 41 years that's that's incredible. >> that really is incredible. what makes him unique as a strategist of heart and head he's got a great gut and it's because of how he grew up and where he grew up. right? he was white kid in a town of 75% black. he was a carnival in carville louisiana, but they didn't have any money he really has this granular ground level gut level sense of how people bill clinton called walking around folk, how walking around folks are going to be thinking and feeling. but then he studies all the time and he works and this is something i think a lot of people miss because he he's he's a little eccentric. let's be honest. >> he added my partner for 40 years and i loved him and he is family. i was honored to be the best man at their wedding james wedding at 31 years ago in november and what people miss is that he's a real student of the game. he is really, really serious. he'll call not just buddies like me. he'll call professors. he'll call the campaign manager for someone in a key district in michigan. i mean, he really, really studies the game. and so you have that combination of that kind of gut and that kind of brilliance he is the very best he's ever done this for a living paul, it's always a pleasure to speak with you and even more fun to talk to you about james. >> thank you so much for being with us. >> again. do not meant and i know there's watch it we just got about james was watching a dog to know what the next thing you said would be. again, do not miss the cnn film carville winning is everything stupid starring paul begala. it airs tomorrow night at 7:00 eastern time. sir. >> all right. the head the war of words between israel and iran heating up as both consider retaliating against one another again, here, what a iran supreme leader is saying, his country is prepared to do, plus a tennessee company accused of forcing its employees to work during a dance at least storm and 11 workers were then swept away in the floods. the company responding to these accusations this morning and deal reached the port strike ending as workers agree to a deal on wages, details, just ahead on that >> everyone mission is to provide complete balanced nutrition for strengt

paul rakoff. paul. good to see you that that was the moment he basically said and then doubled down subsequently in another interview at trump said that he believed that the enemy was within. he named names united states congress people democrats who he wanted to put the military on them. how does that land for you and does it explain why john kelly would then decide to put all of his hesitancy aside and come forward right now yes. >> because general john kelly is a patriot, i don't think anybody at this table would argue with that. he's a man who served his country honorably under tremendous circumstances. he lost his son on the altar of freedom to a landmine and afghanistan, this is a man who cares very deeply about his country and many of us been waiting to hear from him because we've heard all he's quotes and anonymous sources and you wanted to hear the man's voice and that's what you heard now, and i think he's sounding this alarm a couple of weeks out because he's concerned about the future of the country. and i think that i'm already there. i don't need it to be moved. right. but i do think it's a culminating storm of people who were sounding the alarm just a couple of weeks out because because they see how high the stakes are and it's a chorus now, it's general mark milley, who is his chairman, the joint chiefs. it's his former vice president. it's the former secretary of defense, dick cheney. it's his former secretary of defense, mark esper. it's basically the entire military and defense community that served under him that is now opposing him and it's because it's ultimately in my view about the commander in test, and that's what's going to move, especially independent voters in this next couple of weeks, they're going to go into the booth. it's only going to be them and that switch and they're going to have to decide if they're comfortable with this person being the commander in chief and leading our men and women in uniform, which might include their sons and daughters, which is why the integrity piece in the atlantic piece. on other stuff is important too, because you're voting for the man's carroll character and integrity or their lack of, i think you can't ignore the fact that so many of these people and to paul'snt, are in the national security space. those are the people who are the most concerned about this. and some of these stories we've heard before. but here it is john kelly talking more about this episode or these episodes. he says there were multiple of them in which trump disparaged two people who were wounded in action, who were captured in their service. here's what he said he basically for america on the battlefield who are losers and suckers, and he said it more than once yes. >> getting him off at times again, indicate they never wrapped his arms around. why people would serve as a country in uniform. what was initially them? that was a general theme what was in it for them it's his voice. i mean, he wants there to be no doubt that he believes that he saw this happening, heard this happen there has been a lot of speculation that maybe he didn't say that maybe doesn't really believe it. now he's going on the record. you're hearing his voice. he wants every everybody in the world t

paul pelosi in court. christine pelosi, speaker nancy pelosi and paul pelosi's daughter read a statement on paul's behalf, saying he's still suffering through long term effects of his injuries. he asked the judge to impose the strictest sentence possible in san francisco. sergio quintana, nbc, bay area news. and we have covered this case and trial from the beginning until this latest sentencing. if you want to rewatch or catch up on something you may have missed over the past couple of years, you can find our previous stories on nbc bay area, dot com. in oakland the battle. ballot. the ballot battle rather over whether to recall both mayor sheng thao and da pamela price is turning into more than just a political debate. today, recall supporters rallied and called for businesses to strike in support of their effort. but as nbc bay area's velena jones explains, that rally turned into a screaming match that even attracted police after recall opponents showed up as well. recall now, recall now, resign or recall. that was the message. as a group of oakland business owners shut down their business to gather for

withheld in a way that does not reflect the will of the voters will that -- this comes from paul in maryland, paul asked is that kind of state-level funny business -- we got it last time, is that a threat and have we adapted the law to deal with it or is congress susceptible to having the will of the people hijacked by elector manipulation again? i will start at the end, do you want to talk about that in light of the e cra? >> in practice it is a mutable threat, an attempt to not certify has never succeeded. people are under criminal indictment for refusing in soda. and there is a reason for that. that starts the recount in every state to bring up evidence. the act because neither party could gain has firmer procedures for correcting that sort of situation so overall we are not subject to that. >> raised the threshold for objection, in 2020 it took one person. on the house side to throw this into chaos and the number is now 20% and majority must agree so that protection will help with the funny business. >> there is accelerated litigation. do you want to talk about e cra? >> it was very important.

paul hundreds? what's that? name, that's the person's name, paul, hundreds came here, maybe that's the name, surname, paul hundreds but it was to buy sunflower oil, sunflower, sunflower oil, fifty more, and then he came back to the office at 30, 83 came home, understood everything, yes, i wrote everything down, yes, yes, i, i wrote everything down, don't worry, i'll send it now, i moved in 2015, and after 2 weeks i immediately started learning russian at the university, although my husband is from belarus, well, he's from belarus, we met in venezuela, but i said that i needed to learn russian first, after i learned russian, i got married and a year later i started looking for... in belarus, i started looking for a job, only during this year i tried different directions, that is, i didn't work, i just searched, and i don't know how it happened, but i found a job that works with the sphere of youtube, the world of youtube is huge, and i had to learn a lot of things, and i worked there for 3 years, after that i realized that i was bored. i need to put my creativity somewhere, and i started to fail in spanish, i tried