. >> paul rosenfelt is the founder of the group and he was senior secretary for policy security. >> thank you, members of the board, i appreciate the opportunity to speak with you today. it's really entirely appropriate appropriate in this technological age, and the reason for that is one that puts me in some disagreement with my fellow panel liis panelists. i think as acceptable as they were were somehow outdated and they don't survive the technological challenges we face. the 1973 thunder bird was a marvelous car, but we wouldn't think of holding it out today as the motor, we need a test for privacy today. what would that look like? there are many ways to answer that question, and i think to answer it, you have to begin by thinking about what sort of value privacy is. and here again, i think i find myself in some disagreement with other members on the panel, and perhaps with members of the board. i do not think that privacy is an entological value. it's not an inherent human right. rather, in my judgment, privacy is an inherently instrumental value, one that acts in the service of other