david petraeus, this big come back and what about paula broadwell? at is going to happen to paula? >> isn't that always the way? >> it is always the way. >>> want to look at another lowlight, i would say. perhaps the lowest of the year. in terms of people remembering it. that is what happened on the much awaited day when the supreme court issued its ruling on president obama's health care plan. >> we have breaking news here on the fox news channel. the individual mandate has been ruled unconstitutional. >> so, what appears as if the supreme court justices have struck down the individual mandate, the centerpiece of the health care legislation. >> george, we just got the opinion. i'm taking a quick look at it. it's very long and a very brief look at it. >> it appears the decision has been affirmed in part and reversed in part. >> organized chaos, obviously, the high court upheld obama care. was that, were those moments damaging in the blip? >> of course they were damaging. i was there and i thought upheld, not upheld. if just went through the crowd and

author, columnist. >> 15 minutes of fame. >> paula broadwell. >> i will supplement that with jill kelleyflorida woman who got called up into the love quadrangle, however big it got. >> what are we all feeding at the same trough? >> i saw sandra fluke. how long can you go on about free birth control when the economy is crashing. >> who is she? >> she's the georgetown law student who talked about the need for the government to provide her with free birth control. >> rush limbaugh called her a name. [ overlapping speakers ] >> 15 minutes of name. the guard particles, discovery completes the standard model of physics, and explains the mechanism from which mass comes into existence. does that prove, or disprove god's existence? either way, it's 15 minutes are up. best minute of the year. >> hamas, celebrates after 1500 district hits in 8 days, and the world believes it was a great victory. >> vice president biden, bin laden is dead, and general motors is alive. >> president obama's entire reelection campaign. to me, it was one big eally, al >> pretty much. >> mitt romney's statement that he c

is not fully closed and there is the matter of -- that they're investigating of whether or not paula broadwell had classified information on her computer and access to it that she should not have. >> bill: okay. petraeus could be in trouble. where is miss broadwell? what is she doing? >> less is known about her activities. we did see her visit washington, d.c. after word of the affair broke. she was photographed with a zoo lens through a window at her brother's house in the capitol sipping wine with an unhappy look an her face. but she, too, is believed to have gone to ground while the legal machinations unfold. >> bill: all right. now, you just heard karl rove say that hillary clinton said that she isn't going to run in 2016, cameron. but i don't think many of us take that as etched in stone. what's going on behind the scenes with mrs. clinton who is going to resign her secretary of state position soon? >> sure. she's said over and over again she's not going to run and few people believe her, particularly the folks around her. when she does leave her state department post, she's actual will h

and he got into that scandal with paula broadwell.nd then happens obviously before that. >> right. >> but he feels he has the license to do things that other generals couldn't. >> let's get to the heart of the surgery strategy, which worked in iraq, i'm told. that's the conventional wisdom. applied then to afghanistan. how were the kagans with that whole strategy? >> the kagans pushed the surge strategy in op-eds, in my newspaper and other newspapers. they were vocal proponents for it. and then they were proponents for taking a much tougher line against the various taliban factions. while david petraeus was talking up a good game on using troops to protect civilian populations in afghanistan, what the kagans were lobbying to do is to use more of the troops to conduct strikes against taliban infiltration lines from pakistan. >> your story -- we'll do more on this later. but i want to salute you, rajiv, because your story met the test of ben bradley's. he said i want to pick up the newspaper and say holy -- i >>> let me finish tonight w

which was secretly taped i assume, by paula broadwell hiding under the table. (laughter) listen petraeus respond to ailes offer. >> tell him if i ever ran, but i won't, but if i ever ran i would take him up on his offer. >> okay, all right. >> he would quit fox. >> all right. >> and bankroll it or maybe i'm confused and that was rupert. >> i think one is bankrolling it. >> big boss is bankrolling it. rogg certificate going to run and the rest of russ going to be here in-house. >> stephen: okay so, if petraeus ran for president murdoch would pay for it, ailes would manage it, and fox news would sell it though their audience. now if you think about it, a news network choosing the candidate sounds like a conflict of interest. so don't think about it. because it's not really about conflict of interest. ailes said he did it because the republican field needed to be shaken up. so it was really just worried about casting his reality show. as a tv producer ailes was trying to avoid a repeat of 2008 when republicans nominated this cranky old guy who-- how to make a star

the justice department has announced former cia director david petraeus' mistress paula broadwell will not be charged with cyber stocking in the scandal. you may recall harassing e-mails from her sent to a socialite launched the investigation which initially uncovered the affair, leading to the cia director stepping down. the investigation is ongoing. >> investigators searching for the suspect behind an early morning home invasion and shooting. this is not a random crime. >> it happened in the 9100 block of loflin road in fort washington. john gonzales has the latest from the scene. >> the initial call came into prince george's county police around 2:30 this morning. reports of shots fired inside this home. when police arrived, they found a homeowner suffering from at least one gunshot wound. armed suspects, two or three of them, and -- stormed into the house demanding cash and jewelry. >> my brother-in-law was shot in the back in a home invasion. >> relatives arrived a short time after the crime. the homeowner was shot at least once. his wife and his 16-year-old daughter were also ins

petraeus' mistress was also his biographer paula broadwell.barrassing exit from the public stage by one of the most respected public servants of his time. >> an impressive list, huh? and that's only half of them. the most intriguing people of 2012 numbers five to one revealed after a quick break. >>> this is a symbol of good luck especially if you touch the buttons on the chimney sweeper's coat. happy new year from germany. >>> it was a move that outraged nfl fans in 2012. the league battling with referees over money tried to use replacements from college and even high school. but after a blown game-deciding call on national tv, the two sides decided it was best to settle and agreed on a new contract within days making the replacement refs one of our top sports moments of the year. the men in stripes did not make our most intriguing list, so who did? we continue our countdown of those you voted as the most intriguing people of 2012. here's five through one. >> number five. o> number five. ch wndg m a e oefa bggg ou hunting her down, shooting h

petraeus' mistress was also his biographer paula broadwell.it from the public stage by one of the most respected public servants of his time. >> an impressive list, huh? and that's only half of them. the most intriguing people of 2012 numbers five to one revealed after a quick break. my geico app...see? y ...i just uh paid my bill. did you really? from the plane? yeah, i can manage my policy, get roadside assistance, pretty much access geico 24/7. sounds a little too good to be true sir. i'll believe that when pigs fly. ok, did she seriously just say that? geico. just click away with our free mobile app. ♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] everyone deserves the gift of all day pain relief. this season, discover aleve. all day pain relief with just two pills. time for citi price rewind. because your daughter really wants that pink castle thing. and you really don't want to pay more than you have to. only citi price rewind automatically searches for the lowest price. and if it finds one, you get refunded the difference. just use your citi card and register y

then traced the e-mails to paula broadwell, who is also married. ecutors announced broadwell's actions did not qualify as cyber stalking and as a result, they were not illegal. >>> the brave men and women of law enforcement put their lives on the line every single day to keep us safe. have you ever wondered how they train to respond to life and death situations? >> important thing in performing a pit maneuver is location. no embankments, no bridges, no congestion. >> shepard: coming up, you'll get a front row seat and a one of a kind training center in georgia. plus, an independent review of factors that led to the attd thr in libya is due out tomorrow. and it could indicate what security changes we may see in the future. details of that in a live report coming right up this family used capital one venture miles to come home for the holidays. that's double miles you can actually use... sadly, their brother's white christmas just got "blacked out." [ brother ] but it's the family party! really jingles your bells, doesn't it? my gift to you! the capit

the justice department decided not to charge paula broadwell with cyberstalking after the e-mail scandal that led petraeus to resign as cia director. >>> the movie "zero dark thirty" opened in theaters in new york and los angeles to positive reviews, but senator john mccain said the film is wrong because the waterboarding of khalid shaikh mohammed did not lead to information to osama bin laden's compound. >>> chris christie is the most favored republican candidate for the 2016 republican nomination in a new poll with 55%. >>> president obama's approval rating reached 57% in a cbs poll focusing on the fiscal cliff talks. >>> former republican senator chuck hagel is a top candidate to become the new defense secretary in the second obama administration, but there's some opposition questioning hagel's support for israel. >>> and ben affleck is reportedly on the list of possible successors if senator john kerry is nominated as secretary of state. affleck will be in washington today testifying before the house armed services committee about the security situation in congo is that's your mornin

. >>> the justice department won't press cyberstalking charges against paula broadwell. federal prosecutors were investigating broadwell after she sent anonymous harassing e-mails to jill kelly, a socialite who knew petraeus. the investigation eventually exposed petraeus's affair. broadwell was also under investigation for handling classified material. while she has been cleared of cyberstalking, justice officials will not say whether broadwell will face other charges. >>> overseas, developing news on the situation in syria where the civil war there has killed an estimated 40,000 people since march of last year. the "new york times" is reporting that russian warships are heading to the mediterranean for what could be the early stages of an evacuation of russian citizens there. while moscow has been a supporter of bashar al assad, there are some signs that russia's confidence in the regime is slipping. news that richard engel was safely freed from syrian kidnappers is attracting a ton of attention online and relief in the nbc family. richard described his ordeal yesterday

the justice department says it is dropping its investigation into whether paula broadwell stalked a woman she perceived to be romantic rival. an fbi investigation uncovered broadwell's affair with petraeus. forced to resign as cia director last month amid the scandal. >> drivers can push the gas pedal harden some areas of the district. speed limits along new york avenue, parts, north capital street, and canal road, all went up today by five miles an hour. the changes were made based on speed camera data. the increased limit will have no negative impact on safety. >>> up next on news 4 -- a daring prison break. two inmates were am in to use something inside their cell to rappel down the side of a high rise and make their get away. >> change of heart for a popular photo sharing service. tonight, tell you what instagram users need to know about the privacy policy. >> 26 acts of kindness goes worldwide. how people are finding hope amid the sadness in connecticut. ♪ ♪ and the flowers and the trees all laugh when you walk by ♪ ♪ and the neighbors' kids... what does being true to yourself have t

. >> what do you think of paula broadwell being flirtacious and salacious vamp and same with jill kelly . sexy, and seductive, what do you think about them getting. >> there are two of her. twov her she has a twin. if they were short, fat unattractive people not in the position of power, we would have lost interest in all of my feeling about the petraeus scandal. i feel something when i look at. q. in the end of it, what did it mean? i have yet to see a smoking gun here to be -- just the affair. >> you have the men, two powerful generals, john allen and david petraeus helpless victims to these sirens. >> first of all no one brought up. jill kelly is a narcisist and and publicity hound. insped of going to the f.b.i.. why didn't she call petraeus and say by the way, i am getting strange e-mails from an anonymous source. as your buddy, what do you think of this? she went straight to the f.b.i.. what an idiot. she was wanting publicity . the girl is broke! >> you don't feel bad for them like the tight clothes reviewed. >> don't feel bad for them. she is a vixen and a siren and loved the pub

feel dirty just looking at this it's all good here we have general david petraeus he's the lady paula broadwell who was writing his or her bio his biography the book by the way called all in reading about as you will this lady here was also speaking with betray us he was also sending rude e-mails to her telling her to back off this guy was sending e-mails to her as well she was liking him and around and around and around we go i'm ready for some i've actually seen it work today because you came through in troops and drabs in a series of a week. but you know you are things that a general would know better than to let his prize and playoff spot i don't know i honestly well i mean it's just astonishing and i suppose maybe it shows you know what what are these guys really doing you know that all of this i mean they fly around in a force one you have their own private jets and mile high club god knows what they're popping the bottles having far too much fun and god bless america the taxpayers. as well but you know listen i'll tell you what we did have a bit of a bit of a scandal of course let's talk

station actually aired a graphic with a doctored title of the prop paula broadwell book. about david petraeus the title of course of that book was all and and as you can see here they put something different. not all in so it's baffling to me i've worked both here and in a lot of local news stations usually i'm sure it was somebody in the graphics department just messing around and yes something funny about how that aired is just crazy it is i mean and that's a breakdown in the in the whole production of the tour you know flow right there but i mean again that's really how can i put this is not really bad for the news outlet because it's generating more eyeballs on the show on the show and then there is a company or a website got more clicks that day exactly and people you know the twitter sphere explodes you see it repeated on facebook the picture just goes on instagram and everything you know doubles up on itself you know and it wasn't that serious i mean you didn't have somebody you know of the hoaxes or somebody was so they were dead and they weren't or miss reporting

. >> so, alisyn what do you think of paula broadwell, flirtatious, salacious, a vamp, jill kelley, sexyuctive, what do you think about them and-- >> she's as well and two of her, she has a twin. and here is what i think, i think if these were short, fat, unattractive people who weren't in positions of power we would have lost interest in this. my feeling of the petraeus scandal it's like a music video and art house film and i feel something i look at it and the end of it what does it mean. i've yet to release the smoking gun, i mean, to the-- >> and here you have the men, these two powerful generals, john allen and david petraeus kind of the helpless victims to these sirens. >> y know, first of all, no one ever brought up, jill kelley, who i think in my personal opinion is a complete narcissist and a publicity hound. she actually, instead of going to the fbi, why didn't she call petraeus since they're buddies, by the way, i'm getting strange e-mails from an anonymous source about you and i hooking up and other various things. hey, as your buddy, what do you think of this. she went strai

. >> paula broadwell, she's a very capable, durable human being.l emerge from this with a huge book deal and maybe her own talk show. but mrs. petraeus i just feel terrible for. >> other bad breaks, "newsweek" magazine folds, at least the print edition, going away after 80 years. it's all digital now. hostess beaten down by financial troubles and pink slips to 18,000 workers and walking papers to its signature products including twinkies. the nobel committee explains this year's peace prize should go to the entire european union. that's more than a half billion people. >> the nobel peace prize has been devalued in the last few years. of course the eu got one. you're going to get one next. i got one, i got three. it's all right. >> and lance armstrong, supercyclist, cancer fighter, and all-american hero was sent rolling out of the record books for doping. say it ain't so, lance. >> i couldn't believe that, i really couldn't. it amazed me how often he won, and it just is heart breaking. say it ain't so. >> actually, he has a lot of times. it's just t

last spring petraeus' biographer paula broadwell, wrote anonymous e-mails to tampa socialite jill kellyning her to stay away from high-ranking military officers. kelly complained to a friend in the fbi, which led to an investigation with unexpected consequences. the fbi also discovered e-mail exchanges between broadwell and petraeus, showing that in addition to being the general's biographer, she was also his mistress. the general resigned from the cia just days after the election. who knows what's in store for 2013. joe johns, cnn washington. >> local comedian dean obe obeidallah joins us. top of the list this year, scandal in washington. are you surprised petraeus topped the list? >> no, i'm not. the guy is the head of the cia, the top spy in america, and he can't keep an affair secret. i think there's some human quality in there, and some humor at the same time. it's remarkable to me. it's men in power, thinking they can get away with it, bill clinton, john edwards, newt gingrich. one after the other. men in power think they live by different rules, that's why he deserves to be top o

petraeus's mistress was also his biographer, paula broadwell. >> and don't touch that remote.here's more. we're going to show you who you picked as the top five most intriguing people of 2012. that's coming up next right after the break. when you have diabetes... your doctor will say get smart about your weight. i tried weight loss plans... but their shakes aren't always made for people with diabetes. that's why there's glucerna hunger smart shakes. they have carb steady, with carbs that digest slowly to help minimize blood sugar spikes. and they have six grams of sugars. with fifteen grams of protein to help manage hunger... look who's getting smart about her weight. [ male announcer ] glucerna hunger smart. a smart way to help manage hunger and diabetes. >>> just before the break, we showed you five of the ten people who you the viewer picked as this year's most intriguing. stories filled with bright moments and of course, tragedy. here's brook baldwin with the top five people who made their mark, for better or for worse. >> number 5, super jumper felix baumgartn baumgartner

they traced the e-mails back to this writer, paula broadwell, and then they went through her e-mails and found evidence of the affair, and this thing, better than "homeland" even. the investigation is still going on. but already the tv specials about it are starting to hit the air. >> the cia rocked by scandal. its leader accused of sexual misconduct. threatening e-mails from the lover to another woman. a faithful wife scorned. is america's security at risk? find out tuesday on the next "jerry springer." [ bleep ]. >> jerry! jerry! >> jerry springer cia smackdown, 11:00 a.m. on pix, new york. ♪ >> jimmy: i will be watching. i don't know about you. [ applause ] by the way, i want to alert you that national unfriend day or nud for short is right around the corner. i started it just shy of three years ago. this is the day on which we encourage those who use facebook to unfriend anyone who is not actually your friend. most people have hundreds or thousands of friends, but the fact is most of those people aren't your friends, and national unfriend day is this saturday, november 17th. if y

was a mid list book that got a second wind, all in the education of general david petraeus by paula broadwell. sarah, comments on those books? >> guest: funny you eluded to broadwell's book that got a second wind. in light of petraeus' resignation and ms. broadwell's role in that, that's why her book got that second wind, why the paperback publication was pushed up. i think what it's done a little bit, though, is take away from the larger aspect of these books. when scandal rears its head, one focuses too much on that rather than the substance of the books, but one thing, i think, that's worth pointing out, especially in relation to the mark owen, and mark owen, a pseudonym for one of the navy seals involved in the mission to kill osama bin laden is that the book's publisher, i believe was penguin press, they announced that with only weeks to spare, and i felt at least that they did a very brilliant job of marketing that book. of course, it doesn't help or perhaps it didn't hurt, depending on who you ask, that mark owen's real name was dutifully revealed by the media which then caused a fire

the justice department said it is dropping an investigation into whether paula broadwell stalked another woman online. >> she was the official biographer of david petraeus. weeks ago found herself at the center of a national scandal. it was broadwell who allegely sent harassing e-mails to tampa socialite jill kelley. the fbi started a cyber stalking probe that traced the e-mails back to broad well and led to the admission of an affair with former cia director david petraeus. still to be determined why broadwell had classified information on her computer. law enforcement officials say it is unlikely she will face criminal charges over that issue either. petraeus stepped down as cia director early last month. he has denied giving broadwell any classified documents. live in the newsroom, keith russell, news4. >>> when we come back on "news4 at 4:00," a man in a wheelchair plummets off the side after subway platform. what had ans next is an amazing story. >> is celebrity inspiration for holiday parties. we will tell you how to look like a hollywood fashionista without breaking the bank. ♪ th

myth list book that got a second wind and this was in the education of general david petraeus by paula broadwell. any comments on those books? >> it is funny refer to that book as a poorly amid this title about a second wind because after general david petraeus administration, that is exactly why her book got the second wind and why the paperback publication was pushed up. what it has done a little bit though is take away from the larger aspect of these books. when scandal rears its head, one focus is too much on that instead of the substance of the book. one thing worth pointing out especially in relation to the mark cohen and mark cohen was a pseudonym for one of the navy seals who was involved in the mission to kill osama bin laden, the book's publisher which is penguin press, they announced with only weeks to spare, i felt they did a very brilliant job of marketing that book. it didn't help or perhaps didn't hurt depending on who you ask that mark owens's real name was dutifully revealed by the media which than cost its own fire storm and the like but the upshot is many of these books with c

he admitted to an affair with paula broadwell.umbled on the relationship after tracking anonymous e-mails broadwell sent to tampa socialite, jill kelly. >>> today a man from wood bridge gets an early christmas present. he gets a $1 million check. how about that? he won the money in the power ball drewing on december 8th. store that sold the ticket gets a $10,000 bonus. friday a woman in arlington claimed the prize and she won the power ball drawing on november 8th. where's our prize? i'd like that. >>> here's stories we're following for this afternoon. pat lawson joins us with a preview of things to come. >>> hey, barbara. coming up tonight, paying at the pump. the hi-tech way thieves can steal your credit card information as quickly as your fill up you're tank. >>> also, finding the right look to dazzle any holiday party. we'll tell you how you can get the look of hollywood celebrities without breaking the bank. >>> and coming up tonight on news4 at 5:00, kals crime supplements. good for your bones but may not be good for your he

we begin with paula broadwell, the woman who had an affair with the former cia director, david petraeusace federal charges for cyberstalking. broadwell was under investigation for sending allegedly harassing e-mails to a tampa socialite who knew petraeus and his wife. her lawyer says they're glad the matter was resolved promptly and sources tell cnn that the fbi and the military are still investigating broadwell's possession, though, of classified material. >>> we are learning more about jacob tyler roberts. that's the man police say killed two people and then himself at an oregon mall last week. according to court documents, roberts' roommate was worried about his behavior. his behavior was so odd that the roommate actually called the police tip line hours after the shooting and told an investigator he thought roberts might be responsible. he told the detective that roberts was acting quote, unquote, weird and had started to sell his belongings. >>> an update on an "outfront" story we have been following. on the mother who according to her husband, died after being refused an abortion

this is on general david petraeus at paula broadwell. any comments on this books? >> guest: it is funny will do to the book is a formerly lidless title without a second second wind because of course because of resignation and the role and that is exactly why the paperback publication was pushed to appear but it's done a little bit is take away from the lurcher aspect of these books one-off and focuses a little too much i'm not instead of subject on the book. one thing worth pointing out was a pseudonym for one of the navy seals who is involved in the mission to kill osama bin laden and the book's publisher, penguin press announced that with only weeks to spare. i felt that the state did a brilliant job of marketing a book. of course it didn't help were perhaps it didn't hurt depending on who you ask that markers real name was dutifully revealed that the media, which then caused its own firestorm. but the upshot is many of these books, even can insert needy attention doesn't translate into sales. where they did phenomenally low. the other thing that is worth pointin

her name is paula broadwell.ay the justice department announced it is dropping its investigation into whether she stalked a woman she perceived to be her romantic rival. an fbi investigation into the matter uncovered broadwell's appear with petraeus. he was forced to resign as cia director last month. law enforce many officials say it is also unlikely broadwell will face criminal charges for having classified information on her computer. >> comments made on a social media website set off a school riot in sweden today. the police say somebody went on instagram and asked people to post pictures of sexually active girls in the city. people responded with about 200 pictures and names. some of the girls were as young as 13. teenagers upset by the posting organized a proceed 'tis on facebook. the police say the teenagers then went to a high school to attack the girl who put up the posting originally. about 27 teenagers were taken into custody. >>> three people are in custody tonight in connection with a massive theft o

>> personally, not for the year, bought paula broadwell and the outfit she wore on jon stewart, very, the bare shoulders. the pants. she even did push-ups in this outfit. so if hollywood's looking for a bond villain or a bond vixen, she'd be perfect. >> jonathan capehart for "the washington post," thank you my friend. >> that wraps up this hour. thomas roberts is up next. thomas, a lot of fashion to talk about there. any favorites for you? >> i will tell you on the commercial. i don't want to go on the record, richard. >>> we call it the fiscal cliff, but if you look deeper, it really are should be called the trench of mistrust. the negotiations continue. neither side trusting each other enough. congressman james clyburn and steny hoyer will join me. >>> huge outrage after defending her hair on facebook. we'll join melissa harris. >>> and marriage quality, why now? and bringing healing in high-heel. why one college is going to run across the brooklyn bridge in freezing temps and he's doing it wearing five-inch stilettos. and find just... the right...thing. how do they do that? more sa

justice department announced it was dropping its investigation of paula broadwell today.roadwell allegedly except harassing e-mails to tampa socialite to jill kelley. the e-mails were reported to the fbi and that uncovered the affair between petraeus and broadwell and that led to his resignation. >>> with the fiscal cliff fast approaching, republicans are going for what they call plan b. house speaker john boehner's offering to extend the bush era tax cuts for all income below $1 million. the white house rejected that idea and saying it would not pass the senate. >> you may be -- may be just days from christmas but the cherry blossoms look more like march. warmer than usual weathers that flowers blooming. you can see these in neighborhoods today. it is a bit windy there. so no telling how long the blooms are going to last. right, doug kammerer? >> don't get trick. >> do not get tricked. a lot of the cherry blossom trees actually do come out in december. they are actually winter-type cherry blossoms. not the same kind that we see blossom during the months of march and apri

. >>> the justice department will not charge paula broadwell with cyber stalking.ustice officials formally notified her attorneys today. broadwell is the woman at the center of the scandal that forced general david petraeus out at the cia. she wrote a biography on petraeus, but last month he stepped down after revealing he had an extramarital affair with her. we'll be right back. >>> we're back. the first presidential debate will go down in history books for president obama's disastrous performance. this week new details are emerging about the strategy and the decision making that led up to it and followed his poor performance in denver. that and other behind-the-scenes details are revealed in politico's new ebook called "the end of the line." the co-authors are here with the inside scoop on the final weeks of the 2012 campaign. we, gentlemen. first of all, all i care about learning tonight, and i'm fascinated with it, is how could the president be so darn good in the second and third debates, and even biden was very good, very good, and the president was so terrib