so then we'll call the next item which the item no. 7. 92 item 7: appeal no. 13-033 paula datesh, appellanttss vs. arts commission, respondent appealing the denial / non-renewal on march 21, 2013 of street artists certificate. certificate no. 8663. for hearing today.item no. 7. 92 sf 71234 we will start with you and you have seven minutes. >> good evening, i remember you commissioner fung. >> wow, not really much has changed except i left. i was in new york for seven years and i came back and well, okay. so, i just want to talk about the san francisco arts commission code in section 2408 b regarding the procedure to assist then revoked whatever street artist permit. this section violates city article 6en titled executive branch and commission which states that unless otherwise provided by the charter, the affirmative vote of the majority of the members shall be at the denial of the permits. if the street level -- there is a four commissioner and there is a vote t city charter mandates that it go before the full commission, 12 commission for a vote. in this case, my case, it did not. it didn't