i'm appellate peter poon's son. appellate brief 1 and twot house had no permit work between 1987 and 2018. could you speak up because of masks. don't take it off that's okay. speak a little louder than you would normally speak the mask does a great job of covering words. >> the exhibit 3 you will see mrs. tseng the owner and permit holds in 2018 obtain a permit to remodel an existing bathroom and add a bathroomom each of the second and third floor for 48 thousand dollars. before this 2018 permit, mrs. tseng performed construction w on the ground floor in the bathroom without the permit. upon 2019 and 2021 there was construction noise. we believe mrs. tseng was w under a permit there was a job card posted the truth between 20 then and 21 mrs. tseng did a store in the rear of the third floor. a deck on the property line on the side of the second floor. and -- lost track and also the lastly remodeled a second and third floor deputy and did other remodeling jobs to the house all without permit. i complained in october o