extraordinary sequence of events within a few weeks in time where president bush nominated john roberts to phil o'connor state, and then chief justice rehnquist died in roberts was moved to the chief justice chair and then justice scalia was nominated to fill o'connor seeds and then you have the two bush appointees on the court to. so that was the conclusion of the concluding chapter of the rehnquist court of the beginning of the roberts court to. what i thought i would to before i turn to the panel is to give you a glimpse, some of these will be familiar and some may not be, not so much about how the court has changed in doctrinal terms, not to talk of the cases of doctrine but in many ways what a profoundly different chord it is recorded was in 1969. in terms of who is on the course and how they do their business. the first place has been a complete turnover, there are no warren court justices left. indeed, i think there is known on the present four to behaves like the warren court justice. i think there are no thurgood marshall and william brennan on the present court. secondly is a the justices back