pilpel mentioned that would be helpful. thank you. thank you. before we turn to the vote i will call on director short one more time. just and i hope will final time if you could just before we vote on these 10 contracts explain the general rule of the project control construction management service consultant. why they are needed and how they work with dpw staff. >> so generally, thank you, chair post. chara short. generally we use these consultants when either we have special item that we don't have expertise in within our staffing. or if we have -- they provide flexibility. if we have a number of staff out on leave for let's say family medical leave they may be out for an extended period of time of we would never hire someone to back fill them quickly enough it allows you to tap in to consultants to address those needs. all of chapter 6 departments use these and most have a similar contracting mechanism to supplement in house staff we will have talented staff in house as you are often hearing. but sometime there is is a special we may not hav

daved pilpel again. commissioner segal. ka over the air to make a comment since her concern that she expressed the addresses include perhaps on the agenda to enabling clear for the members of commission and the public. i don't disagree in general but there may be specifics where revealing the location is not warranted or it does not apply and i am a bit correspond about the length of the short title and long title or staff recommendation for items i wanted to be careful about bulking up the agenda with long description this is have to be read and understand. and how that comports with the brown act and sunshine ordinance. as to brief meaningful descriptions of items i think it is appropriate in the staff report and also.ed to reenforce my previous point about including maps and photos of projects not just in the presentation but staff report to where the projects are and to develop more specific templets how items are packaged and prosecute voided to the decision. this is an evolving matter and we will continue to --ity rit

daved pilpel. the special meeting contemplayed for january 30 the monday upon i don't know the time give me a time i will block that out. on the city budget over all, we are going to hear thursday afternoon about the mayor's budget instructions i participate the general fund deficit to be huge somewhere north of 100 million. i heard terror between 103 million. i suggest may be soft thenning of general fund source this is fiscal year i don't know that will require mid year changes but i believe there will be pressure from general fund departments publish prudent. realistic and right sized. prudent in maintenance and to the, realistic in how quick low people can be hire exclude projects deliver exclude right size in the terms of of staff, resource and programs. and this is slightly off topic i was not around i want to rescue noise magsz of mike hardman former member of the commission and suggest you adjourn today in his memory of thank you. thank you. peter, tuolumne river trust. i point made this yo

daved pilpel in support of the initiating the landmark for the park side branch library. thank you. >> thank you so much and this completes the queue. >> thank you. madam clerk, public comment is closed. >> i would like to make a motion we sends this out with positive recommendation as a committee report. >> and on that motion supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye >> you have 3 aye's >> that motion pass. this is our last committee meeting of the year and my last day as chair i want to say thank you it has been a pleasure. and i will miss you supervisor mar and thank you deputy city attorney and madam clerk for the wonderful work. >> wait! wait! why is it your left day as chair y. we have a new board next year, newark signments. >> but you could get the same assignment. >> do we have other matters before us today? >> that completes the queue. >> that completes the agenda. >> thank you. lovely holiday break to all my colleagues and staff. thank you. >> adjourned. television. >> in 1948 swensen's ice cream used to make ice cre

it it is david pilpel.iunderstand correct low the file is to be duplicated and one online 10 would be to the 2 year term ending january 31 of 23 and strike the language there and the duplicated file would be for the 2 year term beginning january 31 of 23 ending in 2025. that's how i oobldz that and suggest on line 13 it is not there is no executive director of the bridge district it is the general manager but probably best directed at this time secretary of the district. on the actual appointment of supervisor safai i support his appointment. this would leave one more vacancy on the bridge board. great to have all 4 of supervisors there which would complete that board and have it be the full compliment of 19 member its had vacancies for in time as chair peskin indicated. and it is only unless the supervisor getings on the thursday committee it is only 12 fridays a year from 9 or 10 on noonish. not the biggest commitment. but it is very important. thank you for listening. >> any other comments on the item y.

can i have a 30 second warning >> david pilpel. the board adopted the dehefted payment legislation and now in major lop hole to it. i don't support this ordinance today i know 2 past puc staff member when is should be prosecuted for this kind of activity. this kinds of pay to play contracting sleeze this makes us look bad is had you are empraying. furthermorer low community benefits it is still bad this is when got some people at puc and other city department in trouble. i don't see how rate payers benefit here. the other contracting department port and rec p don't have in my opinion don't need this . legitimate contract criteria are appropriate but in the set asides for pet projects and selected grouped. if this makes sense i would make it a requirement for all city construction contracts and perhaps have oewd lead the efforts with regard to workforce development and other investmentless. more than my ceqa occurrence. >> you have 30 seconds. >> thank you. more then and there my ceqa occurrence if i had time i would file a lawsuit

>> great david pilpel my only comment for today, the mta board acted on this matter yesterday i'm questioning whether they had the ability to submit it to the board of supervisors and i would consider adding a new whereas, clause on page- one moment- on page one or two somewhere in the resolution noting the mta board recommended yesterday recommended approval on resolution on page three whereas, clause should be part of board of supervisors contract approval resolutions where in requests it is fully executed agreement is in the board of supervisors and that is a very good practice and finally have no issue with the undermining agreement for the cross training methodology and appreciate the network and williams for all her work and for many years i don't think the issue is the costs of the agencies but the allocated portion of trips and we can spend a lot of money to better fine-tune it bottom line is close to 7.9 percent (bell ringing) and the methodology could- has been used for many years to allocate the cost of the um, paratransit trips to the city this evening and public comment is closed

david pilpel good evening first i recognize my let the record show lowered and former commission on his passing and support what i understand an in memoriam for him today and something in support of items 45 and 48 and 49 and 50 how have on item 49 i question two lines on page three lines 5 and 6. >> i building that the board of supervisors does not have the authority to declare the bart board results in the california section one 54 into zero zero under public utilities 874 point plus the bart board declares the results i don't see the deputy city attorney in chambers we hope she's listening or put a question to here her to dissolve i have nothing against janice lee but about powers and duties under state law. >> thank you pubically to gordon for representing me own this board i appreciate his service very much thanks. >> thank you for your comments thvpt next speaker, please. >> good evening supervisors paul an advocate from san francisco and wanted to discuss the welgs wellness and there are significant legal issues we need full transparent this time we need real trablt metrics and d

david pilpel good evening first i recognize my let the record show lowered and former commission on his passing and support what i understand an in memoriam for him today and something in support of items 45 and 48 and 49 and 50 how have on item 49 i question two lines on page three lines 5 and 6. >> i building that the board of supervisors does not have the authority to declare the bart board results in the california section one 54 into zero zero under public utilities 874 point plus the bart board declares the results i don't see the deputy city attorney in chambers we hope she's listening or put a question to here her to dissolve i have nothing against janice lee but about powers and duties under state law. >> thank you pubically to gordon for representing me own this board i appreciate his service very much thanks. >> thank you for your comments thvpt next speaker, please. >> good evening supervisors paul an advocate from san francisco and wanted to discuss the welgs wellness and there are significant legal issues we need full transparent this time we need real trablt metrics and d