very warm welcome to you this is all sea life from moscow i'm alice said but poland's prime minister said his country will carry out its own investigation into april's plane crash which killed the polish president also but expressing anger over the findings saying russian air traffic controllers should have stopped the plane from landing well earlier russia's foreign minister defended the official report saying the findings were beyond downed cut that out of. the us and joins us live. and a lot riding on the outcome of this final investigation was on the podium with initially quick to criticize but a mulcahey different tone coming from the prime minister was. indeed perhaps one of the most important statements to come from donald tusk news conference is that poland is accepting part of the responsibility for this milan. plane crash which killed the former president his wife and nearly all of poland's political elite and that of course is. a different statement from those that poland has made previously saying an investigation should be conducted into why the russian side has. accepte

poland slums the results of efficient investigation into the plane crash which killed its president says it simply doesn't agree planetaria was to blame. the polish prime minister cut short his visit to italy returns home and is about to deliver an urgent press conference all the details from poland in just a few moments. starts all this reduction treaty in russia's progress with the u.s. nato were highlighted is russian foreign minister sergey lavrov looks back over the kremlin's international actions in twenty ten. patients he found refuge in the united states after last year's earthquake may be pulled out of the country under way from their families. and coal prices are skyrocketing rally continues on the russian markets you see believes rates unchanged all that and more in twenty minutes on business it's. a very warm welcome to you this is live from moscow with me alice have it now russia's foreign minister says the official report into april's a plane crash which killed the polish president is in keeping with international law but only one has been expressing anger over the findings

line from moscow with me alice habit poland's a prime minister is that his country will carry out its own investigation into april's a plane crash which killed the polish president well wolf been expressing anger over the findings saying russia now. traffic controllers should have stopped the plane from landing well earlier russia's foreign minister defended the official report saying the findings were beyond doubt. that in a while many had expected the polish prime minister to slam the findings but that's not at all what we've got is it indeed a my appear as though the polish prime minister has definitely approached took on a more diplomatic stance towards the report published by the interstate aviation committee saying that poland does respect except responsibility for some of the reasons that the crash took place and for the catastrophe of course that followed but there are many nuances in the address itself and in the following news conference that followed that do suggest that poland is not quite satisfied with the report mr said that he believes the report is incomplete and that

because there are so many there were at that time so many jews living in poland this was the largest jewish population and in the was essentially what happened however all over all could buy. in that tell you tell these that the germans have invaded that it applies to western europe and even more so to the eastern europe to poland and to that it's obvious for the east is that the local population was as jews were being the local population got drawn into that process of persecution and they benefited materially from it and. it was of act on to give shelter to jews who were trying to avoid the. network but in some fundamental way of course. it's a story that's driven completely by the nazi scholar for with some collusion on the part of the local population throughout the. you you think they did what they did just the local population because they feared for their lives and they thought if they didn't at some point ps i know a peace is a kind of a dirty word but appease the occupiers that they would be they would see the reaction come against them. i don't think this is a good explanat

tonight poland asks russia to carry out further investigations following the publication of the official report into a presidential plane crash but its authors hit back claiming there's nothing more to say. despite a reluctance to accept the findings of this latest report polish prime minister says this will not spoil good relations with russia all the details from warsaw are just a few months. also in the program the start arms reduction treaty and russia's progress with the e.u. and nato highlighted as russian foreign minister sergei lavrov looks back over the kremlin's international actions in twenty ten. patients who found refuge in the united states after last year's earthquake maybe forced out of the country and away from their families. hello this is r t it's now eight pm thursday night here in moscow my name's kevin zero in and our top story this hour poland's prime minister says his country will carry out its own investigation into april's plane crash which killed the polish president warsaw's been expressing anger over the official findings and says russian air traffic controll

polish prime minister interrupts his vacation and returns to poland urgently and that's the reaction concerning this latest report. the united states prepares to kick hundreds of haitian immigrants back home to a country still struggling to keep its people alive one year after being struck by a massive earthquake. and a ban on selling sex in spanish newspapers that's designed to protect women but is leaving prostitutes seeing right. around the clock around the world of this is. in the russian capital. the russian foreign ministry has reiterated that the final report on the plane crash which killed the country's president was carried out in accordance with international law poland's prime minister has called short his holiday off to warsaw expressed anger over the report's conclusions the interstate aviation committee's findings blamed inexperienced crew members bad weather and the pressure to lend from passengers well let's cross live to get more of a former. russian foreign ministry has addressed the results of the investigation and polish criticism tell us what has been said. and w

poland is accepting part of the responsibility for this plane crash and that of course is. a different statement from those that poland has made previously saying an investigation should be conducted into why the russian side has. just accepted responsibility that part of that part of the statement poland still hasn't changed despite the fact that the polish prime minister said that poland does accept part of their responsibility he says that it takes courage for their counterparts in this case russia of course in the investigation to do the same thing and admit the accept the other part of responsibility in the tragic plane crash so let me just. the goal is not a compromise but a complete disclosure of the truth diplomacy and politics cannot hamper the presentation of the facts on efforts to alter the facts the facts are facts on the rule polish investigators working on adding the parts of the report to the missing changing what is already we assume responsibility for some of the causes of the crash for the courage and commitment to fairness needed this doesn't know the fa

no of course poland especially the opposition forces in poland specifically the brother of the deceased polish president. they attempted to blame russia for the tragedy saying that there were a lot of false in the investigation many in poland actually of the opinion that air traffic controllers should have outright forbidden the polish pilots to land at that airport and instead of forcing them to revert they used a backup airport instead however it has been said by many of the already figures both in russia and poland and within the international aviation committee that no air traffic controller has that authority that at the end of the day it is the pilot's decision and therefore the pilot's responsibility to make a choice about where that landing will take place and specifically of course with the pilot of a presidential plane and it does appear that those pilots made a decision a decision of course that ended in tragedy. to many things that was. well loved. joined by. the coleman from the podium at the. many thousands of being with us on the it seems to give out now prime minister .

a landmark moment for poland. the country's first black m.p.. one of the chilean miners arrested last year from 700 meters underground hasaid there were changed and the world was as well. quex it was a drama that gripped the world and a terrifying ordeal for 33 men. there were trapped 700 meters down in a cramped space at a temperature of 32 degrees celsius. there was almost no food and little prospect of rescue. >> we had the first drill bit coming down but it missed us and our spirits crashed. jose enrique's story of survival turned him into a christian missionary. he adopted the role of pastor and said only through religion to the minors survive. the government prepared to tell thei world there was no hope. >> it was like finding a needle in the haystack. >> then a wider bore and a capsule to extract the miners. 22 of 32 had converted to christianity. fighting christianity underground has changed rough and ready minors. -- miners. >> the wives said my husband is changing. he is talking about god and treating me kindly, not a harshly but befor

tonight poland asks russia to carry out further investigations following publication of the official report into where he pulls presidential plane crash but its authors hit back claiming there is nothing more to say. despite a reluctance to accept the findings of this latest report polish prime minister says this will not spoil good relations with russia all the details from warsaw in just a few moments. start arms reduction treaty and russia's progress with the e.u. and nato are highlighted as the russian foreign minister sergei lavrov looks back over the kremlin's international actions of twenty ten. and haitians who found refuge in the united states face being separated from their families and deported back to the island in spite of its continued turmoil after the devastating earthquake. this is r.t. welcome it's one am here in moscow my name's kelly know in our top story poland's prime minister says his country will carry out its own investigation into april's plane crash which killed the polish president also has been expressing anger over the official findings and says russia's

no more to say russia defends its report into the plane crash that killed poland's president as warsaw continues with its own probe. despite a reluctance to accept the findings of this latest report polish prime minister says this will not spoil good relations with russia all the details from warsaw in just a few moments. from arms reduction to a reset of u.s. relations russia's foreign minister gives his rundown of twenty tense achievements . about turn to the u.s. regimes deportations to haiti despite the humanitarian crisis still unfolding in the caribbean state. you're watching r t six in the morning here in the russian capital welcome to the program poland's prime minister says his country will carry out its own investigation into april's plane crash which killed the polish president now warsaw has been expressing anger over the official findings and claims russian air traffic controllers should have stopped the plane from landing well the authors of the report have defended their work and say no stone was left unturned artie's got that he thought of all reports from warsaw. polan

warsaw poland. well david lemar from flight global magazine says poland may be eager to distance itself from the blame but he can't find fault with the official report i think that the polish government is i think desperate to put at least some of the blame in somebody else's direction but incidentally i completely go along with the russian verdict on the on the air traffic controllers hours incidentally the air traffic controller did not clear this aircraft to land he had with withheld clearance for the aircraft to land and he wouldn't have had permission to stop an international flight like this one anyway if it had been a russian air force aircraft the controller could have told it to divert an international flight especially of this status the controller would simply go along and do everything that he could to help the captain achieve a safe approach but it's a very very emotive happening for for the polish people however i can tell you this if they try to carry out their own report in order to

gauging reaction for us in the polish capital warsaw now you are on the ground in poland what exactly has been the reaction there to the results of the investigation. sean you can imagine this is the biggest news story in poland today of course every single news channeling devoting a lot of coverage to the story to the reaction of course reaction to the report released by the committee is of course mixed some are saying that it is a truthful report and a necessary all be painful steps in relations between moscow and warsaw that it is a necessary step that will allow the two sides to close this tragic and painful chapter of their shared past and hopefully move on others of course including the former polish president lech kaczynski his brother are saying that the report is nothing but a joke that it is presenting the polish side with falsified data. even taking it to such extremes as saying that the bodies of those who died in tragic day in april were falsified and the bodies that were identified in russia were not the same bodies that arrived back in poland so this of course is causin

in poland is hard for many reasons. and first of all we are approaching the parliamentary elections i am afraid that. all these could be the one of the most important battles of. contention between the major political forces well some of owning our political leverage in their sights others say the cause of the disaster is clear cut vision is a very complicated matter the simple people. interested in so sometimes it's easy for. conclusions poured in my opinion. both poland and russia have insisted on keeping this debate from influencing the recent fall in ties but with a story far from over it looks like some in poland are keen to keep things for. polish newspapers and fill their front pages with strong action minded words war against the report tossed curses the aviation committee we will find out the truth and so on but these headlines that are how catchy are just words what actions the polish government will choose to undertake and how they will affect relations between russia poland remains to be written. catherine a

warsaw poland. security expert chris yates told us here at odds are you that the official report presents a complete picture of what happened. there is nothing more to be said quite frankly i think they. the committee that did this investigation has done next job and they've they've they found what they found which is that the primary blame should be one of the truth. you know there is one important line in the transcript of the conversations between pilot and ground during the. final approach of the aircraft into the airport and that is that there is no condition for landing at this airport and quite frankly with that sort of information being given to the pilot the pilot should then have made the judgment to follow traffic instruction and transferred to another airport nearby where better visibility better conditions for the landing might well have persisted. b.p. has dubbed as historic it's a multi-billion dollar venture with russia is all from last year after the companies will now join forces t

the president of poland and the prime minister of poland i believe but to do what they can in order to not to let it harm the by letter of relations between poland and russia and we do appreciate it but on the other hand they have a position in poland including the. the brother of the late president of poland a mystical ski and they make their a tickle statements without i believe without reading the texts i could see the first requirement of mr kaczynski probably twenty minutes after the report was published here in russia it's not possible to make any conclusions when you have not seen that this and this is purely political i do respect the feelings of these people who are personally involved in this tragedy and they do accept it but i don't accept when certain politicians simply in poland drive to make big ball of ticks on this tragedy in case we will continue to disagree on certain positions and this may happen in case experts will continue to do disagree on that there is only one way to proceed and this is to address a certain international multinational widely which would would c

april last year just outside the russian city of smiley and a lot of outrage was initially heard from poland but today's address by the polish prime minister actually comes as the voice of reason the polish prime minister was mentioning to his colleagues that it is unwise to try and politicize this tragedy but the quest for truth shouldn't be mourned with political mind games in sight and that opposition members should keep that in mind when they sensationalize the investigation on the first he made it clear that politicizing this tragedy is not in the headlines benefit. the truth to be complete and we realize that it will be inconvenient for many there is a complex number of causes for the crash so it's convenient to blame the pilots that are in depression and others it will be convenient again the russians but it be the whole truth the organization that seeks the truth must not be influenced by forces in poland that wanted to be cozying up to them there are more and more people specifically within poland's political elite that do believe that politicizing this tragedy should be put aside a

talking about it almost nonstop there have been varied comments in poland itself about the findings of the aviation committee report some like the late polish president's brother have attempted to use this report to say that russia is attempting to all laugh at poland that the report is nothing but a farce others do say that despite the fact this is of course a very painful report it needs to be accepted and it is basically correct in its findings. that we are glad that these reports exists this is just brought us closer to the next stage find to know the circumstances that led to the tragedy. i must admit that the russians are right again i don't want to agree with the russians but this is the truth of course we can look for guilt and blame someone else of course the aviation committee that has published its report has now made its way to poland where they are allegedly scheduled to meet with the polish prime minister but we do know what their findings focused most upon what everybody has of course been most interested in is the cause of the tragic plane crash and that according to th

warsaw poland. security expert chris kate says the investigation will soar and carried out so high standard. there is nothing more to be said quite frankly i think the. committee that. this investigation. job. they found. that the primary blame should be. truth. you know there is more important line in the transcript of the conversations between pilots. during the. final approach of the aircraft into the airport. there is new condition for this airport quite frankly with that sort of information being given to the pilots the pilot should then made the judgment to follow traffic instruction transferred to another airport nearby where better visibility better conditions might well have persisted and coming up here in our nine years of pain and torture with no end in sight find out why the infamous tamzin center in guantanamo bay is still open and what it's doing on cuban soil in the first place. because we've got the latest founder julian assange is fighting extradition from the u.k. to sweden fearing

warsaw poland every asian security expert chris yates told r.t. he doubts any new investigation will lead the polish side to a different conclusion. there is nothing more to be said quite frankly i think they . the committee that did this investigation. job. they found what they found which is that the primary blame should be. true. but you know there is more important in the transcript of the conversations between pilots. during the. final approach of the aircraft into the airport. that is that there is no condition for this airport and quite frankly with that sort of information being given to the pilots the pilot should then made the judgment to follow traffic instruction transferred to another airport nearby where better visibility better conditions for the landing might well have persisted. but coming up in the program the bay worth human rights half song find out why the infamous u.s. attention center now as good now is still open and water is doing on cuban soil in the first place. plus we've got the latest on wiki leaks founder julian assa

warsaw poland. at the asian security expert chris yates as investigation was there and carried out a high standard there is nothing more to be said quite frankly i think they. the committee that did this investigation a stubborn exemplary job and they they they found what they found which is that the primary blame should be for the truth. you know there is more important lie in the transcript of the conversations between pilots and ground during the. final approach of the aircraft into the airport and that is that there is new condition for landing at this airport and quite frankly with that sort of information being given to the pilots the pilot should then have made the judgment to follow traffic instruction and transfer to another airport nearby where better visibility better conditions for the landing might well have persisted. and coming up here in our nine years of pain and torture with no end in sight find out why this u.s. detention center in guantanamo bay is still open and what it's doing

baltic states, ukraine and most of poland. so what this means is of all the killing that took place, organized by both hitler and stalin from the atlantic to the pacific the tremendous majority of this mass murder was concentrated in this relatively small territory. this is the event that caught my attention to the district's me that once we know these numbers and we can't localize these numbers in time when we can look at them in a place, what we see is an even which has few comparisons in the history of the world. the question then would be why is there no history of this event? why has someone to become the one seen it as an event? why wasn't it written before? i would like to start by saying a few words why i think it is. in the last 20 years, we have had a new opportunity to write such a history. the reason we had this opportunity is that the soviet union collapsed in 1991. eastern europe began to open in 1989. this is very important. obviously this is important in terms of understanding the history of the soviet union an

very warm welcome see this is our scene live from moscow and poland's apartment will go wrong wednesday to discuss the final report on last april cross in western russia which killed president kaczynski would be official and it was the last day based interstate aviation committee that the truth. is that different after one of the main reasons for the tragedy russia has now released the full transcript of the air traffic controllers conversation with the crew on the roof will criticize the report is incomplete and it is now it is clear to the cross of that. we do know that the parliament will be reviewing this report by the interstate aviation committee in detail of course it found that inexperience polish crew bad weather as well as pressure from high ranking officials on board the flight all ultimately led to the tragedy. so far we've had mixed reaction from poland we understand they're going to try to get on the same page and find consensus from the prime minister donald a relatively diplomatic reaction from the current president borderline anti russian rhetoric and from the late pres