about the crash because everything about this crash is a change by history the long history of polish russian and polish soviet relations the captain massacre itself the especially the cover up and so it's hardly surprising that many poles are skeptical about it what did we get before story i think it's interesting that a recent poll in poland showed that there are only eight percent see this as some sort of a conspiracy but there are many people who say it is the russian side providing all the evidence they are they're sharing everything i think in anything that touches polish russian history and especially at this site there are going to be people who are going to there are some people will refuse to be convinced at least a lot of people will be skeptical and asking a lot of questions and the polish prime minister donald tusk is stressed as needed stirring up and the russian sense would do no good to anyone but there are people who are still questioning russia's openness and honesty about all this what will it take to change the mindset. well i think i think first of all it's important to s

polish europe and difficult issues was to persuade again russian society and to say or to find. proper awards to the polish society saying stop we understand it was committed by the previous regime and stop blaming us because we'll really cut off from the premature grave but if russia has already overcome its superiority complex this that means that the poles have overcrowd their inferiority complex let's just let's go sanjay i guess europe's. first off of course i think that we have a completely new outmost for today but of course you ask about the expectation the expectation is very easy to explain this is true only on this fundamental we can to build a future and if you are talking about cutting you we are talking about the officers the officers. in this for a forest and of course it's. russian decision what do we expect i think very easy thing i think very hard believe patient the explanation are that it was not the it was. very thread digital event done in this forest boy and by. the. officers this is the situation was known in poland but of c

from warsaw and here in the studio we have till monday and they exactly have secretary of the russian and polish group on difficult issues the spotlight will be back shortly how to take a break so stay with us don't go. for . international peace soon which will rise in a few bands from feinstein the russians. who threw stones on team don't come. hungry for the full summer we've got it first hand the biggest issues get a human voice face to face with the news makers. download the official ulti out legation choke i phone on i pod touch from the i choose apps to. watch all sheesh life on the go. video on demand policies and live broadcasts and r.s.s. feeds are now in the palm of your. question on the i'll call. welcome back to spotlight on how we live in just a reminder that my guests on the show today are out of my league in he's here in the studio with me he is the executive secretary of the russia polish group and difficult issues and angie holan skee the chairman of the foreign affairs committee of the polish parliament he is joining us live and not being able to cover from us the beautiful pic

polish side explaining and. that either was screened committed by and given their political or stalins order. and then we needed a guest of course. society and some parts of the russian elite that it was through what gorbachev said to the polish authorities in very late eighty's and bendis for example the task of russian but with europe and difficult issues was to persuade begin russian society and say or to find a proper war so the polish society saying stop we understand a little skin needed by the previous regime and stop blaming us because we'll really cut off from the premature very view but if russia has already overcome its superiority complex this is that mean that the poles have overcome their inferiority complex let me ask let us housing i guess your pursuit. first off of course i think that we have a completely new artemus for today but of course you ask about the expectation the expectation is very easy to explain this is true only on this fundamental we can build a future and if you are talking about cutting you we are talking about the. officers who are. in this for a forest and of course it's. russian decision but what do we expect i think very easy th

polish attorneys police. investigate what could be the difference i guess that. from russian side mainly it was their opinion that it was very. very bad preparation from the polish side this is the fact that it was that bad weather such a. plane should not have told takeoff and absolutely should not lend but also many poles and the many polish experts. that it was sort of the. errors also by done by the flight controllers at the airport that somalis. have to leave it there for now professor pinsky vice chairman of the its own affairs committee thank you for joining us here. well we can now see some live pictures from warsaw where we are where thousands of people are expected to gather to commemorate i victims of that plane crash course a year ago massive crowds held candle ceremonies and flowers near the presidential palace and today there will be more scenes there of course in warsaw. meanwhile the in the small dense. and live pictures here a religious service is being held and science people taking a chance to lay flowers there as you see the actual site where a year ago th

previously denied see that event was to be a real milestone in the easing of previously tense russian polish relations but since that tragic plane crash we have seen a very public and very united outpouring of grief from both sides with the leaders from both countries stressing that they want to very much to keep the polish russian relationship on track and today on monday we are expecting the presidents of both russia and poland in the dead of a cold war all seen to come here to smolensk to attend a working lunch before coming to the crash site said to his tender commemoration service the speeches will be held as we understand present we said and flowers lays and then they too will move on to size of the kitty memorial the interstate aviation commission that which was a group set up by president medvedev immediately after the crash happened was headed by the prime minister vladimir putin consisted of aviation experts from russia from poland and from the u.s. and it was set up to investigate the causes of the crash and they released their own report on january the twelfth and they concluded

events like crash or for polish presidential airplane are now doomed to be surrounded by by all possible rule morris' conspiracy theories everywhere about this specially in russian polish he saw i am afraid even if russia will do even more work doing this to get there you will always find people and call on who will see that it's not enough and it's not fair and the government which is in basically a very positive and constructive russian position but the the needs to be need to be reelected soon so they need to. through public public mood so unfortunately it's a politically very very risky situation do you think that your countries will ever see eye to eye on the causes of the tragedy. the most optimistic to me was not not even the political reconciliation political gesture by both prime ministers and presidents but. how people russia react we have a lot of negative feelings easily pulls fortunately. but what many people came to polish last year and now to pay tribute to do it president who was not that big from the russia but the tragedies unifying all right well thank you very much for joining us from the russian global affairs magazine thank you. we are clos

to remember the seventieth anniversary of that massacre but this new plaque is now in both polish and russian and makes no reference to katsina the removal of that initial white house cool something over for. who are included both among the general public and also among a political community that we have now heard from the russian foreign ministry who say that they did warn the pota side that they would be changing the clock and they were surprised by the reaction coming from poland and they also say they changed it because they wanted a bilingual plan it would allow both russian and polish mourners to feel welcome here let's look back now a little more detail i want happens on the tenth of april twenty ten. the final moments within seconds all ninety six on board flight one i one with the dead. the time with ten forty one am april tenth i was out for the plane was flying low with one of its wings going down to heaven so fast that question to the trees and burst into full for it was obvious that no one was going to survive the flames were as high as a five story house crowd control saw for th

the executive secretary of the russian polish group on difficult issues and angie holan skee the chairman of

actual suddenly solve the crash who's to throughout the day more lives here in smolensk both russian and polish have been coming here to pay their respects in the russian capital moscow the russian first lady spoke non-image that of the late her own flowers and paid her room respects outside the polish embassy and this of course follows on from yesterday's events when the wife of the put the president down on a comet also came here with the families of the victims to attend a memorial service here at the smith's care field before moving on to the county memorial site a very similar timetable for that would be followed by president's move it is unclear what all see on monday but to help these very united and public help poor use of grief from both the russian and polish sides we do understand that some in poland touch states press their concern at the news that the memorial plaque at the crash site behind me was replaced on friday nights we have no heard from the russian foreign ministry on this and we understand that locals med school authorities changed up because they say permission was grant

the actual subway solve the crash through throughout the day mourners here in smolinski both russian and polish have been coming here to pay their respects in the russian capital moscow the russian first lady said nan in the dead of the late her own flowers and paid respects sell side the polish embassy and this of course follows on from yesterday's events when the wife of the british president at an uncommon all sky came here with the families of the victims to attend a memorial service here at the smith's care field before moving on to the scene memorial site a very similar timetable to that would be followed by a president who did it and called off he on monday big to help these very united the public help poor use of grief from great the russian and polish sides we do understand that some in poland had to state suppress their concern at the news that the memorial plaque at the crash site behind me was replaced on friday nights we have not heard from the russian foreign ministry on this and we understand that locals med school authorities changed up because they say commission was door grant

left two nations devastated a year ago a plane carrying the late polish president lech kaczynski and ninety five others crashed into the russian city of some of that area right. now share skin warsaw and others have it in the southern screeching. yesterday the wife of the polish president and a comatose together with the families of many of the victims came here chinky estimates of the crash by these millions care feel to attend a memorial and remembrance service they then moved on you can see the memorial very similar timetable we follow the presidents with vandeven come out of the on a monday and of course it's so walls and we'll be able to see for there you see two pools and reflects and really more when the ninety six own pool about one five full flight for wolf is in the lens and he died all night with a tent and the trees just behind me on board that flight was a cools the polish president lech kaczynski the commander in chief of the polish air force and its army chief the huge iranian all this of course is that polish delegation was on its way to western russia to commemorate the seventieth anniversary of the canteen ma

from both the polish and russian side i've been very keen to stress throughout this investigation to exist this politics must stay out of the investigation and the improvement that we see the russian polish relations must continue to abort and today certainly does come just a few days before this coming weekend commemorative events which will mark one year on since the plane crash in the events to be attended by both presidents come off the meds that. are supporting a series of terrorist attacks have been prevented and russia's north caucasus republic of congo. according to the national antiterrorism committee three members of a terrorist organization were captured in the operation to homemade bombs with the equivalent of three kilograms of tuna and so we were struck to by special forces one of those seems to is suspected of attacking policemen in the region as well as being responsible for a fatal attack on security forces in december last year. now to ivory coast where incumbent president goes compound is being stormed by supporters of his rival president elect. but go is holed up

well it would allow both russian and polish moon as it's feel welcome here what's live up to now a little who these health i what happens on this have a full transit had. the final moments within seconds all ninety six on board flight one hundred one day . it's time with ten forty one am for the tenth i'm going to come from i was outside when i heard the plane it was flying really low with one of its wings pointing down it crashed into the trees and burst into a ball of fire it was obvious that no one was going to survive it flames were as high as a five story house. ground control star who there were no conditions to land mass requests was still made to attempt a trial approach transcripts from the plane's black box flight recorder reveal the crew were acutely aware of the rapidly decreasing visibility and also of a pressure to land as soon as possible to go crazy yeah we don't know who he is what we do know is that a senior minister periodic we enter the cockpit throughout the flight and that the chief of the air force himself was present at the time of the crash under these conditions

tragedy that people people change their views but the default mode in in russian polish relations for many centuries now has been hostility. they are slowly overcoming that it's not going to happen quickly so but i think i think things in that way but just the sense of like that you said the human spirit the feeling you know that neighbors should but that is maybe slightly better now with that said that kind of human feeling being better the polish side has regularly criticized russia for not handling or handing over information about the crash investigation and the investigation as a whole how fair do you think the investigation was well i'm not an aviation expert and i can't speak authoritatively for that but i in my own work have rounded up the fuse of aviation experts and they seem to be of the general opinion that it was a pretty thorough and fair minded transparent investigation. but you do hear this suspicion this doubts coming from the polish side and you know they're coming from that you know atavistic historical place more than from any set of facts and figures. what do you

the actual size hole of the crash through throughout the day mourners here in smolensk both russian and polish should be coming here to pay their respects in the russian capital moscow the russian first lady said non-image vetiver laid her own flowers and paid her own respects outside the polish embassy and this of course follows on from yesterday's events when the wife of the british president at an a common all sky came here with the families of the victims to attend a memorial service here at the smiths care field before moving on to the top the memorial site a very similar timetable to that would be followed by presidents with their lives and come out off key on monday but to help these poor united them public help organs of grief from both the russian and who decides we do understand that some in poland have states press their concern at the news that the memorial plaque at the crash site behind me was replaced on friday nights we have heard from the russian foreign ministry on this and we understand that locals are. changed up because they say permission was not granted for the original

balance the sma let's just call from walsall that day was to log on you know since stage in the russian polish relations all balled up plane which. to attend a commemorative event to mock. the kept see that massacre of nineteen forty with thousands of polish prisoners of war we killed but i still viewed as soldiers and he politicians from both the pollution russian sides presidents prime ministers for ministers have been very keen to stress throughout this investigation it's a process that's called a six month stay out of the investigation and the improvement that we see to russian polish relations must continue to a bone and so today certainly does come just a few days before this coming weekend commemorative events which will mark one year on since the plane crash in the event is to be attended by both presidents. tell us thanks very much indeed for bringing us the latest there. and a series of planned terrorist attacks have been prevented in russia's north caucasus republic of coverage you know bill caria according to the national anti-terrorism committee three members of a terrorist organi

russian on the street and. the very positive reaction of both president medvedev and prime minister putin we have seen progress but also later on some polish total forces they call in with of the conspiracy in organizing in quotation marks that crashed by russian authorities and. by polish authorities. well the latest twist of course follows the previous controversy that we've seen surrounding the release of the interstate aviation commission's report into the cool says of this plane crash they released their conclusions on the twelfth of january and they found the pilot error was mostly to blame of course compounded by my poor weather and the lack of visibility and the psychological pressure being exerted from passengers on board the plane all the crew salon's as soon as possible but still they conclusion was that pilot error was mostly to blame and nearly in poland's refute those conclusions saying that more needs to be done to investigate conditions of the smolensk airfields here and also into the role played by grounds could pay had prevent the plane from coming into lands in those cold weather conditions but the underlying stress in t

together to remember a common tragedy on sunday it will be exactly a year since a polish plane crashed near the russian city of slovyansk killing the polish president and ninety five others. in the struggle and recommend aeration ceremonies taking place so you can't really the tragedy clearly united people but it's still hard for some of polish politicians it seems to overcome this suspicions of russia what's the general mood. from poland to russia on the state over one hundred people have a right there now caring of the size of this catastrophe took place almost a year ago now the science worthy to pull you want fifty four plane crash burning burn burst into flames killing polish president lech kaczynski his wife and ninety four of the country's other senior political and military elite now it's very important to remember what was behind that trip to russia it carried a very important emotional. emotional feelings with it members of. these delegation of polish delegation were about to visit his side of the cut the memorial where twenty two polish officers were slaughtered by stalin's secret police bac

coming together to remember a common tragedy on sunday it will be exactly a year since a polish plane crashed in the russian city of slovyansk ninety six people were on board including the polish president his wife and a large part of the country's political elite greif united the two nations but ponies rejection of investigation has threatened to divide the books he's a. screeching commemoration ceremonies are due to make it. there is only a tree stumps left at the side where the polish to pull one fifty four plane crashed causing a fire a year ago the plane carrying the polish president his wife and ninety four other of the country's political and military elite very soon relatives of those killed him because you will be gathering here at these guys and the current polish president's wife on the come out of school will lead a delegation from poland will be a following ceremony a religious service and after that they'll be visiting because the memorial which is some twenty kilometers from here you should remember what was behind the fatal flight of this region of russia a year ago to commemorate something

soviets so that was being held as a very symbolic milestone in the easing of previously tense russian polish relations so the tragic crash in one day denied poland its president its first lady the chief of its air force its military chief so a very somber day here in smolensk being commemorated by both presidents together they are laying their read saying prayers and lighting candles here at the site of the plane crash as you can see them be moving on to the sides think team that memorial puts new speeches about how it's they were expecting that simply of the sound of a trumpet being plays and just a very somber quiet needs here at the moment to hear and smell and see this is peter alona studio but there is a controversy though about plaques was there i guess they didn't resolve that at the last second or do you can you go into any detail about that. certainly the stone that you can see just behind me marking the exact spot where lech kaczynski plane crashed a year ago doesn't have a plot and now adopt plot was actually put some time on friday night we don't know exactly when because the pre

for the crash has certainly had a strong impact on russian and polish relations political commentator and time best part of the voice of russia radio joins us now to talk more about this good to have you with us so before we get into the implications of what this accident has on the country's cooperation just talk about poland for a second how much of the country changed since this all the since this tragedy took place well it was an extraordinary event you don't have your president member sophia release from political really dying in an air crash so it was unique in the history for it for any european country and to poland it was especially painful because it's a place where it's militarily to. sixty years before so. at the beginning when you spent a few. reached problems there was a sense of unity among known political arena patience but later it was supplanted by you even stronger rivalry between the two main right wing parties the ruling platform the injustice and now the struggle of the rescuers ever do you think there are many in warsaw who are having. trouble accepting the resu

costing lives in the heart of the russian capital you're watching r.t. but a year since the polish president was killed in a plane crash in western russia both countries leaders will meet today to mourn the victims of the disaster dozens of poland's political elite also perished in the accident ceremonies have been held to commemorate what's been described as poland's worst tragedy since the second world war. the actual size of last year's show. the crash plunged both countries into shock but in some ways brought them closer together. well sunday april the tenth the one year anniversary since the plane crash that killed the polish president lech kaczynski and ninety five others including the head of the polish and force its army chief the polish first lady and several leading m.p.'s and historians and of course that it's a two pronged one five four crashed in the trees just behind me a mere two hundred nieces should be smolensk efi open it was a before and not flight so called the rule so were a boundless moleskine ironically because the delegation led by the president was due to a

the results of the investigation by the russian committee the interstate emission committee are recognized to be true consistent with the facts though the polish side says not all of the facts have been included into these reports and i think that the the assassination version is not likely to emerge in future russian polish relations at the functional level there which will remain a significant factor for the war and justice party that is trying to challenge. president komorowski hands and even more prime minister tusk so i think there is a chance that the two sides will agree on this there which is going to be held way . now the cuts in months occur of the one nine hundred forty s. has always been a stumbling block you talked a little bit about how conflicts go back decades. are there any signs now that the two countries can move on and close the book on this tragedy sure there are signs and we have seen them since last year's ceremony and celebrations of the. of the quetta massacre back in ninety forty that's russia at ease and ready to talk about it more openly written to open its archives and read it and even even publish the documents re

both sides with the leaders from both countries stressing that they want to very much keep the polish and russian relationship on track and to day on monday we are expecting the presidents of both russia and poland invaded in the world to come here to small ends to attend a working lunch before coming to the crash site said she was tens of commemoration service their speeches will be held as we understand they said presently set of flowers days and then they too will move on to the size of the kitty memorial the interstate aviation commission which was a group set up by president medvedev immediately onto the crash was headed by the prime minister vladimir putin that consisted of aviation experts from russia from poland and from the u.s. and it was set up to investigate the causes of the crash and they released their own report on january the twelfth and they concluded that pilot error was mostly to plane always be severely compounded by. very poor weather conditions dense fog and reduced visibility and just psychological pressure being exerted from the passengers on board a flight to land the pl

killed by soviet soldiers that event was to be hailed as a real milestone in the easing of tense russian polish relations but since that plane crash we have seen a real public outpouring of grief from both sides and of course yesterday we saw huge in the numbers of mourners on the streets of iran a steady stream here in smolensk at the side of the crash and also outside the polish embassy in moscow led by the russian first labels a lot of it was. a year on or off of the plane crash where does the investigation action stand. well the interstate aviation that commissioner i.a.c. was a group set up by president medvedev immediately after the crash to identify the causes it was headed by the prime minister vladimir putin and consisted of aviation experts from russia poland and the united states and they delivered their report on january twelfth and found that pilot error was mostly to play well obviously severely compounded by very poor weather conditions and poor visibility and psychological pressure being exerted on the pilots to land by the passengers as soon as possible but essentially pilot er

the russian and polish presidents who did it and said come on stay on now attending a day of special commemorations here in small lands to get the very sites off the plane crash. pirtle gadhafi agrees to a cease fire plan proposed by the african union but the stalemate is unlikely to be resolved less the libyan leader steps down. and finley veiled racism slammed for its discrimination policies towards muslims as a law banning the burka goes into effect. two pm in moscow i mattress was very good to have you with us here on our t. our top story it's been a year since the polish president was killed in a plane crash in western russia both country's leaders will meet today to mourn the victims of the disaster dozens of poland's political elite also perished in the accident remember and ceremonies have been held to commemorate what's been described as poland's worst tragedy since the second world war was hibbert at the site of the crash. president. arrived here in his presidential plane landing just behind me on the on the f.b.o. this is of course the very same f.b.i. . plane that crashed

actions all round full still off at the airfield in this dense he politicians from both the polish and russian sides have been very keen to stress throughout this investigation. it's a process that promise six month stay out of the investigation and the improvement that we've seen in boston polish relations must continue. and said today certainly does come just a few days before this coming weekend commemorative events which will mark one year on since the plane crash in the events to be attended by both presidents. of. topics on a supporting now russian human rights council has started an independent investigation into the case so for more oil tycoon mikhail khodorkovsky russia's richest man he is currently behind bars for four and has appealed against his second prison sentence would now get more from us he's pretty high peter so. of course he has already been convicted by a russian court for most this investigation all about that. a lot of course he case was one of the most high profile in russian legal history he was the first president to be made get it was actually signed off approving t

but there's a part of you still feel russian well my i have three children. polish thank the russian perfectly. wrong door. lives in moscow since none too well tell me about the russian community that still you know here in paris well community here is a great hero because actually my association which is called. central. a visit to salt for the long. russian language should culture. now i must pass them to. speak english. gives a name in english because. paper. which is called in russia to score. in french it just call it. the french word goose or total longer. and now it. come out in english to tell me what you think of the relationship between russians and french people. trouble is that french people don't know any sick of all russian history. french people and english people in german people on everybody in europe know else and so i. can tell him that. he wants people to believe it and that's why i folded my paper because it is true give information about russia thank you very much for your time to me. thank you. so what house is influenced by russian culture in

balance the sma let's just go from warsaw that day was too long you know i see it's stage in the russian polish relations all of board that plane which used to attend a commemorative event to mark. the massacre of money team forty one thousands of polish prisoners of war with killed coming still viewed as soldiers and today certainly does come just a few days before this coming weekend commemorative events which will more one year on since the plane crash in the events to be attended by both presidents. i was supporting right now residents of. the home back bow being stormed by forces loyal to his rifle. incumbent presidents being locked up in his palace negotiating his departure from the country refused to cede power after losing that much disputed election last november tata is recognized internationally. president . followed saw hundreds of people killed and u.n. and french troops launched airstrikes as part of the mission to protect civilians. from visiting for democracy and cooperation in paris says they are pursuing their own goals. basically the crisis is crystallized around the rivalry

coming together to remember a common tragedy on sunday it will be exactly a year since a polish plane crash near the russian city of slovyansk ninety six people are on board including the polish president his wife and a knowledge part of the country's political elite grief united the two nations both presidents rejection of the investigation has threatened to divide the. country is in question for us now where commemoration ceremonies are due to begin the country and here at the site itself describe the scene that. well a year on there is only three stumps of the sites where the polish to one fifty four crashed causing a fire the plane was carrying polish president lech kaczynski his wife maria ninety four others other poland senior political and military elite now very soon relatives of those killed in the catastrophe will be gathering besides the delegation will be headed by the current president's wife and the komorowski and very soon up for a flower laying ceremony and a religious service they will also visit because the new memorial some twenty kilometers from here now we should forget what was the pur

plane crashed near the russian city of smiley and killing the polish president and ninety five others artie's company in the small and screeches where commemoration ceremonies are taking place as we speak you consider you know the tragedy united people but it's still hard for some polish politicians to overcome their suspicion of russia what's the mood there in small towns this afternoon. it's very solemn here on this day over a hundred people relatives of the victims of the courthouse really have gathered to have the site of the tragedy where the polish to one former main room crashed a year ago the plane carrying the president of poland lech kaczynski his wife maria and ninety four other all the country's political and military elite well today the current polish president's wife on the come out of skis leading the delegation from poland they returned to the flower laying ceremony and now there is a religious service again see and hear and growing on and sholay after ballots the delegation will also visit because the moral side which is trying to new

together to remember a common tragedy on sunday it will be exactly a year since a polish plane crashed near the russian city of my dance killing the polish president and ninety five others are she's kept going to grab is following the commemoration ceremonies at the crash site. it's very solemn here on these stay over one hundred people relatives of the victims of the catastrophe that have gathered at the site of the tragedy where the goal is to one fifty four main room rushed a year ago the plane carrying the president of poland left. his wife maria and ninety four other of the country's political and military elite well today the current polish president's wife on the come out of skis leading the delegation from poland. and the flower laying ceremony and now there is a religious service again see engineering going on and the show you after the delegation will also visit because the moral side which is trying to launch this from here of course you have to remember what was the purpose of that lied to russia by the polish delegation a year ago that was to commemorate something which carriage huge emoti

the plane carrying the late polish president lech kaczynski and ninety five others crass near russian city have my doubts our correspondents are bringing you the wages from the two grieving countries but alice in the summer announced region and a lesson here is have a polish capital warsaw right next to you first seems like how four of warsaw is out on the streets today behind you. that's not only warsaw that's indeed the whole of poland is here at the this is extremely sad and emotional day for poland i'm route right now in the middle of a huge commemoration rally which has a striking resemblance to the one last year in this very same square from the presidential palace several thousand people young and old have gathered here to commemorate those who died in one thousand six hundred eleven clued in the president and his wife who died last year in a small lens going in there in a tragic airplane crash now at exactly eight forty one am local time that is exactly the time when the plane went down in smolensk a minute of silence was observed here in warsaw ever since we've been hearing a

coming together to remember a common tragedy on sunday will be exactly here since a polish plane crashed and have a russian since response ninety six people are on board including the polish president his wife and a large part of the country's political in the grief united nations problems rejection of the investigation has threatened to divide the. country which is in this way it's going to commemoration ceremonies are due to begin. there's only a tree stumps left at the side the polish tupolev one fifty four plane crashed causing a fire a year ago the plane carrying the polish president his wife and ninety four there of the country's political and military elite very soon relatives of those killed in the catastrophe will be gathering here at these sites and the current polish president's wife on the schedule leaves its allegation from poland will be a follow laying ceremony a religious service and after that they'll be visiting because the moral which is some twenty kilometers from here you should remember what was behind that fatal flights of this region of russia a year ago to commemorate something tha

the crash certainly had a strong impact on russian polish relations or some argue it had a negative effect there are political experts who think it brought the two closer together last year to place a made of relations that had begun three months earlier and in fact the relations are in better shape now than they were two or three years ago so i believe it was a test for the. little countries have much of the past that it's a minority all for the polish public opinion believes there was a real plot to kill president country ski. in fact it. actually exists because to outsiders it's mostly the most looks like some you know paranoid if you but majority is tired of the struggle and even more tired of the political movements trying to exploit the tragedy and be something not something that was probably. stay with us here on our t.v. still to come the battle of the burka find out how the latest developments in france have a government facing accusations of stirring up racial tension. but we continue first to libya where an african union delegation is attempting to convince the rebels to embrace

to crush certainly had a strong impact on russian polish relations though some of said it had a negative effect political experts say that it brought the two countries closer together. last year's air crash took place and made i warm enough relations that had begun several months earlier and in fact the relations are in a better shape now than they were two or three years ago so i believe it was a test for about little relations and the two countries had much of the past that it's a minority all for the polish public opinion that believes there was a real plot to kill president kaczynski you. know it's unfortunate fact that this actually exists because to outsiders it's mostly it also looks like some you know a paranoid idea but i'm authority is tired of this struggle and even more tired of the political movements trying to exploit the tragedy and the sentiments of the polish public. when the news is not enough. when it's something really crucial. when you want to get down to brass tacks we bring you our special coverage a year on in a place already seen all of this with tragedy the worl