required to be implemented by the puc. a portion of pg and e charges replaced with flat fee. >> the new rate employs time of use period and e eliminates the increase above that removes disincentive too use more power. with electrification. >> the puc system adopted rate package on the board for for review and we participate the rate will start in february. >>. the programs. prepared a summary of the 22 peek day pricing ending on october 21ch. peek day price suggest an upon demand response this incentivizes large commercial customers to ruse electricity consumption 4 p.m. and 9 p.m. on events days in the sum and early fall. >> event days called with the grid will being strained typically due to high temperatures. clone clean the season the end of october earned billed credit to participates customer january bills. this marks the fourth year that cleanpowersf offer third degree program. 36 accounts in the 2022 season. representing a 16% increase. compared to the 2021 season. >> we called 11 event days during participates red

although one of thing i think is probably for the puc. do we have anyone from the puc here or no? have anyone here. >> all right. well then, one that you can answer is, so, i'm trying to think about this lease for this park. >> uh-huh. >> what is the lessee get out of running a park? >> there's no financial incentive. part of it would probably be to run it in -- you're coordinating a lot of mixed-use actions that's going there so you can program, you can have special events that are easier coordinated that are tied into the mission rock development. >> so that's a not for profit. >> (indiscernible) as far as that structure could be, it's different but as far as leasing it over in long-term lease to reflect that. >> all right. and the question i guess i have for the puc that probably can't get answered today is, i mean, i don't feel bad about overpaying for this water because we're probably under paying or or the cost of portable water will probably go up because the climate is changing and we're all going to die and terrible fires and floods and everything, so reducing our relianc

today's puc presentation on slide 4 states the puc will return to the board for approval or award ofy is the 9.118 delegation needed which you can avoid this. either way, you should amend the subsequent sections because it's section 4 and not section 5 and page 10 and 11 need to be renumbered sections 4 and 5. there is no bla report. this is definitely a policy matter and bla background would help if this amendment is deemed substantive and you can review the item on your own or amend or forward to the board as amended. those are my comments. >> >> next speaker, please. >> public speaker: this came before the san francisco public utilities commission some time ago without any decision making. it's now come before this committee we have a new person in the contract monitoring. i believe that is beverly tan g. she should have been here to answer a few requests and contracting to answer a few questions. the way the puc is this will go directly to one or two of the board of supervisors and one of the board of supervisors who is in the chair was talking as if she knows a lot about this wh

and the puc. to make sure that as we progress and looking at the designs and further steps agenda everbeyond this step we are all in alignment. thank you. >> nodding from t. a. staff. is there a motion to approve item 7? >> moved by melgar. a second? >> by dorsey. call the roll. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye. why commissioner engardio. why aye. why commissioner mandelman. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner test neil. >> aye. why commissioner walton. >> aye. well are are 11 ayes. call item 8 >> final approval on first appearance adopt 22 annual report an action item >> executive director chang. >> good morning. my pleasure to present our highlights from 2022. the annual report. as you recall we have several irrelevants. >> are you supposed to show the slide. these are various roles funding. agency which is learning low a p

although one of thing i think is probably for the puc. do we have anyone from the puc here or no? have anyone here. >> all right. well then, one that you can answer is, so, i'm trying to think about this lease for this park. >> uh-huh. >> what is the lessee get out of running a park? >> there's no financial incentive. part of it would probably be to run it in -- you're coordinating a lot of mixed-use actions that's going there so you can program, you can have special events that are easier coordinated that are tied into the mission rock development. >> so that's a not for profit. >> (indiscernible) as far as that structure could be, it's different but as far as leasing it over in long-term lease to reflect that. >> all right. and the question i guess i have for the puc that probably can't get answered today is, i mean, i don't feel bad about overpaying for this water because we're probably under paying or or the cost of portable water will probably go up because the climate is changing and we're all going to die and terrible fires and floods and everything, so reducing our relianc

today's puc presentation on slide 4 states the puc will return to the board for approval or award ofy is the 9.118 delegation needed which you can avoid this. either way, you should amend the subsequent sections because it's section 4 and not section 5 and page 10 and 11 need to be renumbered sections 4 and 5. there is no bla report. this is definitely a policy matter and bla background would help if this amendment is deemed substantive and you can review the item on your own or amend or forward to the board as amended. those are my comments. >> >> next speaker, please. >> public speaker: this came before the san francisco public utilities commission some time ago without any decision making. it's now come before this committee we have a new person in the contract monitoring. i believe that is beverly tan g. she should have been here to answer a few requests and contracting to answer a few questions. the way the puc is this will go directly to one or two of the board of supervisors and one of the board of supervisors who is in the chair was talking as if she knows a lot about this wh

although one of thing i think is probably for the puc. do we have anyone from the puc here or no? have anyone here. >> all right. well then, one that you can answer is, so, i'm trying to think about this lease for this park. >> uh-huh. >> what is the lessee get out of running a park? >> there's no financial incentive. part of it would probably be to run it in -- you're coordinating a lot of mixed-use actions that's going there so you can program, you can have special events that are easier coordinated that are tied into the mission rock development. >> so that's a not for profit. >> (indiscernible) as far as that structure could be, it's different but as far as leasing it over in long-term lease to reflect that. >> all right. and the question i guess i have for the puc that probably can't get answered today is, i mean, i don't feel bad about overpaying for this water because we're probably under paying or or the cost of portable water will probably go up because the climate is changing and we're all going to die and terrible fires and floods and everything, so reducing our relianc

and, with the lafco puc mou has not yet been approved by the puc. we continue to follow up with their commission on that and hope to see that brought back do to their commission soon, and with that being uncertain at the moment, and with the board of supervisors request for lafco to continue to advice on clean power sf, suggesting lafco could focus on more targeted oversight of clean power sf and digging into particular topics of interest. on the public banking work plan, the working group is aiming to complete their work by the ends of may and so we will look from guidance from the commission and reinvestment working group and board of surprisers to think how and if laugh row work in the area will continue with the completion of those reports. and on the gig economy portion of our work plan, the department of the environment pilot program for e-bikes is a launch next month and we will be playing advisory role and bringing regular updates and continuing to work with the department of environment and others looking for other funding opportunities and

and lafco puc meeting that addressed us on january 10th. meeting, puc staff, myself presented the mou with our staff recommendation. that the mou be approved and the commission authorized the general manager to execute the agreement. of during the discussion of the itemful the commission identified areas of concern. and commissioners indicated that they would loishg more time to consider the mou before taking action on it. of so my understanding at this point is there are conversations on the matter that will determine next steps. of course, we'll continue to stay in touch with the executive officer on this topic and we will -- have more in the future. >> with that i will jump in my presentation with the 10 minute in minds. for the bvenls my update i will cover our service statistics. new cleanpowersf generation rates. activities related our development and operation of customer programs and power supply procurement. our cleanpowersf program continues to successful low serve customers and participation in the program is stable. we seen anup

and, with the lafco puc mou has not yet been approved by the puc. we continue to follow up with their commission on that and hope to see that brought back do to their commission soon, and with that being uncertain at the moment, and with the board of supervisors request for lafco to continue to advice on clean power sf, suggesting lafco could focus on more targeted oversight of clean power sf and digging into particular topics of interest. on the public banking work plan, the working group is aiming to complete their work by the ends of may and so we will look from guidance from the commission and reinvestment working group and board of surprisers to think how and if laugh row work in the area will continue with the completion of those reports. and on the gig economy portion of our work plan, the department of the environment pilot program for e-bikes is a launch next month and we will be playing advisory role and bringing regular updates and continuing to work with the department of environment and others looking for other funding opportunities and

and the puc. and it just to make sure that as we progress and looking at the designs and further steps agenda everbeyond this step we are all in alignment. thank you. >> nodding from t. a. staff. is there a motion to approve item 7? >> moved by melgar. a second? >> by dorsey. call the roll. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye. why commissioner engardio. why aye. why commissioner mandelman. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner test neil. >> aye. why commissioner walton. >> aye. well are are 11 ayes. call item 8 >> final approval on first appearance adopt 22 annual report an action item >> executive director chang. >> good morning. my pleasure to present our highlights from 2022. the annual report. as you recall we have several irrelevants. >> are you supposed to show the slide. these are various roles funding. agency which is lear

i came from puc my background is in accounting. i'm responsible for reconciling the grants in a timely and efficient manner. thank you. >> speaker: good evening, i'm tiffany knew ini just graduated last month from ucla and i worked at nasa as a social media specialist. i'm fashion at about utilizing communication as a tool to communities. so i'm very excited to be working here. >> and those are new members, so if everyone would join me in giving them a round of applause. [applause] >> welcome all. and i believe we still have to move to public comment on this item. >> we'll begin with public comment here in the room. are there any members of the public who are present and wish to speak? if so come forward one by one and speak clearly into the mic. seeing none, we will proceed to remotel public comment. for those on hold, wait until it's your turn to speak. >> seeing none, public comment is closed. >> next item. >> environmental and general plan policies. the speakers are lisa chen and planning department and danielle gogh, senior de

there are many close calls outside the san francisco puc building on golden gate avenue. witnesses say two massive sheets of metal fell from the top of the building on two parked cars. i was standing outside the embassy waiting for my cousin. and i heard like something like a big explosion in one car was inside when the middle shattered her window winds also ripped the roof off one home on russia avenue in the city's excelsior district and blew it onto another home across the street there at the corner noise. big loud bang. vanessa surveillance camera caught one giant free, crashing down into the parking lot of saint mary and saint martha church. the three first and then when i look to make sure everybody was okay. i saw my card all damage. our arborists are working through the night there. also on standby for the next two days is because it's going to continue. and you can see all the work here at 25th and harrison. they just told me that they're probably not going to be able to get the utilities or the power back on until tomorrow morning for people in this area. and on

chronicle said it was the puc. they w through the puc but to get on the road on the road they need the dmv approval. so i believe it is between the 2 companies. why thank you. why my last thing, i want to give a shout out to the folk who is work at the clothing depot. grateful for my visit there yesterday. they were grishs and it was fun and i got out fit in the my put the clothes to work. >> yea. >> i love the boots. bots are my favorites. they were terrific. hat's off. thank you. >> thank you. >> commissioner collins i know you were next then commissioner feinstein. commissioner collins? >> i want to thank chief postel for my tour of 6 fire houses yesterday. it is one thing to read i report it is another to go on site. and in reflection at the end of the day yesterday, i was appalled boy had i saw. in many of the fire house for live and working conscience. unacceptable. seismicly unsound buildings housing. some of our most important emergency response data and work. not acceptable. this is the way that it is but

that creates a pile of dollars that is tracked by the california puc. and the california puc gives pg&e the authority to spend those dollars. in event, we applied to fund our distributed, sorry our disadvantaged communities programs and they granted that request. >> but it's a charge that rate payers pay for? >> yes. and then the street light program. how is that funded? >> there is two funded sources. first is the revenue we received from the telecommunication carriers who lease the polls to attach antenna systems. you'll see these throughout the city, they're kind of rectangular. that's one source of revenue. once we exhaust those, then we spend tax payers dollars. so the funds are street light, maintenance system, it's one of our cost of doing business that is factored into the sets that are set for hetch hetchy customers. >> thank you. >> so it's very unusual for a city to fund those street lights that way, some how that's how it was in san francisco. >> is that a good thing? >> well it's a general fund, it's typically general fund type of service.

there are many close calls outside the san francisco puc building on golden gate avenue. witnesses say two massive sheets of metal fell from the top of the building on two parked cars. i heard like there was something like a big explosion. the woman in one car was inside when the middle shattered her window winds ripped the roof off one home on russia avenue in the city's excelsior district and blew it onto another home across the street. and on south van ness, a surveillance camera caught one giant free, crashing down into the parking lot of st mary and st martha church. when i look to make sure everybody was okay, i saw my card all damage. our arborists are working through the night there . also on standby for the next two days is because it's going to continue here at 25th and harrison cruz said. they probably won't be able to restore power or utilities until sometime wednesday morning. also city crews say that it's very important if you see it down tree called 311 and leave 911 just for life threatening emergencies reporting from san francisco, jana katsuyama ktvu, fo

we are assisting the puc. clearing catch basins to make surety leaves are not settling on top. that minimizes the flooding others have been issues sands bags to the public. thousands issued throughout public to prevent flooding at business and homes. we have an different direct your attention process. during january -- for 4 weeks we are doing every dame diverting cleaning crews and putting them on sand bags and catch basin cleaning. the next slide gives you a break down of all of the service requests coming in the largest one the street cleaning of steamers are 20%. packer trucks are about 2% and remaining is encampments. the next breaks it down by the month. and you see december and january you see the amount service performance levels within the green. area, which is close to our target. now we willium in graffiti this is public property. graf feetedy. we talked about earlier, staffing is an issue with graffiti program as limp can't paint out graf feet when he it is raining. january, 4 weeks of rain we put the graffiti folks doing catch bank clear and sand bags. to ke graffi

dpw and puc want to inflate their prices that isn't our fault. the city is inept in managing projects. that's not the workers fault. there is no cost effective energy green build design, it is just race to the bottom, who can get to the cheap est. why don't go to bang ladesh or china to get it cheaper and turn our backs on every working in san francisco and spending money in the community here. this is big problem and big issue. >> thank you. seeing no other comment, i guess i don't want to force you to the podium to tell us, but i'm going to assume what we are doing is legal. now i'll force you to the podium and force you to answer. >> good afternoon commissioners. i think one question we heard overall that maybe i can help is does 12x prohibit the acceptance of gift from a state for a company based in a state on the 12x list? does admin code 12x prothibt city accepting a gift from a company based in a state on the 12x list thin case nevada. commissioner mazzola you are right that 12x does not use the word gift. our office has understood and int

today we are joined by ivy (inaudible) from puc, bruce robberson from public work and judy (inaudible) i believe is remote from the airport. i like to begin with ivy fine to talk about the impact of 12x on the puc. >> good morning ing supervisors, ivy fine with public utility commission contract group. we have a couple slides today that show upcoming contracts in 2023 and 2024 that potentially will be impacted by the repeal of 12x on chapter 6 construction and professional service contracts. the san francisco public utilities commission has between 10 $10 million and 20million about 8 contracts that will be advertised for engineer estimate of about $113 million and for design bid build so construction contractors greater then $20 million. we have 7 contracts for total of $630 million and we have alternative delivery contracts that have a engineer $7 contracts for total of $630 million and we have alternative delivery contracts that have a engineer estimate over 20million. two contracts that total $240 million. where 12x impacts construction is on high dollar value contracts as well as

the 311's we refer some items to operations to reper se but also issue forward, lot of them to mta or puc and other case utilities like pg and e and the telecoms. so we get, lot of case where the box are broken and it is a tripping hassard. and usual low they are pg and e ownership the water department. we'll sends those and follow up with them and to get them to take care of it. and do have cases where we have long standing issues we can't figure out the owner. and those take, lot of research and time. >> okay. thank you. also -- i mention third degree at other commission meetings, there must be a way for people passing by in this age of technology, isn't there a way to connect to have an app about what is going on for the location. if there is something that you see. upon even if it is your block where you live or place the lot you know the address and you can -- look up. and finds out that is the first step. what the work is being sdmn if you are move nothing a car or walking or passing by on public transportation. our phones know our location. say, you know what -- couldn't we partner