commissioner pulson. i have a comment and a question. and comment is this one, this is important and it is in the just this department and city wide i'm extremely -- glad to hear you say you believe we are the best and most enengageod this. this is the type of diligence this we are looking for as we move through this area. and we the public or private sector well is no , i gotcha question. things are complicated. has to do with sweetheart deals or electric of transparency. most of this stuff is in the woads of the of report this you are telling us. depending when department and you are -- compote with another department or there is a category that is always -- seems to be vaccance or turned over the weeds of details that you obviously are exploring. but one thing i noticed is we are a city that where the majority of the employees in the city are upon represented boy a labor organization. and -- and i have known that you know am they seem to be by having a voice you do have not just yourself but you have the representative in the union no

. >> commissioner pulson. >> aye >> commissioner stacy. >> aye y. you have 4 aye's. >> wonderful. >> item passes. thank you so much. i now we have public comment on the items we are discussing during the closed session. >> yes. >> item 18, public comment on matters to be addressed. members when wish to comment on item 20 to be heard with closed session a litigated claim the water control board administrative liable against the city 236, 500 limitation violation the southeast and ocean side water pollution plants for discharges between october 2013-october of 21. subject to board of supervisor's approval. do woo have anyone present to comment on closed session item 20? >> there are in callers at this time. ia thank you. public comment on item 20 closed session is closed. why excellent. can i have a motion whether to acert the attorney/client privilege. move not to acert. >> move. >> move to acert and seconded. >> thank you. approximate president ajami. >> aye >> vice president maxwell. why aye >> commissioner paulson. why aye >> commissioner stacy. >