for instance, after putin's invasion of the republic of georgia, and say putin though technically medvedev was in power although we do understand it was putin's plan, the united states granted russia a new -- [inaudible] policy. for putin it was a clear signal that he could do whatever he wanted in the post-soviet political space. and i believe, you know, it more or less doomed ukraine, because putin's next step in ukraine was based on his calculation that nobody would argue that he was, you know, kind of a master of the post-soviet universe. >> host: next call for garry kasparov comes from jay in asheville, north carolina. independent line. >> caller: yes, good morning. thank you for taking my call. russian investigators have estimated putin's personal wealth at $40 billion. one investigator, when asked if he thought putin was a criminal, answered -- [speaking russian] i would like to ask mr. kasparov how he thinks putin acquired this huge wealth. thank you. i'll take my answer off the air. >> guest: no, i think you're operating with very old news. i believe it's way, way, way above $40 b

putin was loyal. i think he still believes in loyalty as the number one attribute. >> yes, to serve the government and unfortunately, turned into a state where loyalty replaced every other quality for the promotion. >> rose: why does he have an approval rating of 90%. >> how do you know what his approval rating is. >> rose: let's assume it's high. >> it's high, but because the moment you go to numbers like 80 and 90, you understand that for many people it is just, you know, it's a question they want to avoid. you cannot calculate the feel factor. >> many of those were responding to the anonymous calls that were being made. so he had have sov yent experience and telling the truth about the president, the general secretary, the leader, whoever, it is kind of risky. and many of them don't want to be bothered. >> rose: but also, it is strong support for the policies too, is there not. >> probably but we can go back and say that hitler was, you know, very popular in germany, too costly and check vak ya wit

appointed putin and he came in they appointed putin. he came in and immediately i think he changed the situation. obviously it took time but in the united states i were foreign-policy, we went into the middle east and because of the neoconservatives, which quite frankly mr. kasparov that the only association i have seen of you is being affiliated with the neoconservatives in the united states. the neoconservatives promoted, encouraged, got us involved in the wars in the middle east. we have lost trillions of dollars. >> host: all right john, a locker on the table. anything you want to respond to? >> guest: you can look at it today and see how many billionaires, many dozens of billionaires in russia and almost all of them are correctly connected to putin so russia is second place to the united states and for information go back and check in the year 2000 when yeltsin let office. i'm not here to discuss the details of the economy. i can recommend you to read my book because i'm not telling you about the strong versioning democracy. i'm hi

maybe vladimir putin will try. and the united states today is - under the obama administration has been trying to walk away from the most dramatic conflicts that have been created over the years, pretending that if america is no longer involved, things will be resolved peace flyand everywhere will be -- peacefully and everyone will live happily ever after. >> it's not going to work in this fashion. if it was created, it would be created by other forces, by russia, iran, islamic state and who knows what happens next. >> fascinating conversation. thank you so much. "third rail" panel is next. >> this is literally about women's lives. >> do you think tax dollars are going to abortions? >> inherently they are. >>> welcome back to "third rail". planned parenthood's funding is under fire, should the group stop practicing abortion to save the rest of their services. >> a new battle ground. >> officials in texas barred the group receiving medicaid money. >> the tragedy is women in texas will be heard. 3% are abortion care

today to an event on putin and putin -ism. exactly what putin is a ms., are a steam panelist will be to discuss with you today. we are pleased to have, in particular brian taylor who will lead off, he is professor of political science at maxwell school at their qc university. his research focuses on the domestic political role of state course of organization such as military police. he is the author of two books, and another in progress. the first one was politics in the russian army which came out in 2003. his more recent book, state building and putin's russia came out with the same press in 2011. our next speaker who where fortunate to have all the way from moscow, one of russia's top political analysts and scholars working on russian politics today. nikolai petrov, he is the head of the center of political geographic research. he was previously a chair, as many of you know of the carnegie moscow society and in regions program. before before that he worked for the institute of geography and is authored of many publications.

we're have been happy to welcome you today to an event on putin and putinism. exactly what putinism is, our esteemed panelists will be happy to discuss with you today. we are pleess pleased to have in particular brian taylor who is professor of political science at the maxwell school at syracuse university. his research focuses on the domestic political role of state coercive organizations such as the military and police. he's the author of two books so far and another in progress. the first one is -- his first one was "politics and the russian army" which came out in 2003 with cambridge university press. and his more recent one is "a state building in putin's russia" which came out in 2011. then our next speaker -- so brian will lead off. then our next speaker who we're fortunate to have come all the way from moscow. i think it's fair to say one of russia's top political analysts and scholars working on russian politics today. nikolay petrov. he's the head of the center for political geographic research and he was previously chairs as many of you know of the c

is putin. he does not need to be the president or prime minister he can keep in power by himself. what is important i think is the country is coming to new election and new electoral cycle which should be held next september. i would wait almost immediately after this election so he could explain why election are early to address the nation and for putin to address the nation and declare the new scores because the elite understood that china cannot replace the west. in terms of money, in terms of keeping to the russian economy and he reserves to keep the course without credible changes coming to the end. thank you. [applause]. >> thank you. i think we can go ahead and open up discussion to members of the audience. to have microphones? identify yourself if you have a comment or question we can bring you a microphone. >> please identify yourself. >> i work for u.s. a id for five years. i certainly certainly have an interest in that situation. i was intrigued about your same that the general head

your history with vladimir putin? guest: i have never met putin.this man has been destroying the who is, he is a dictator quite desperate to stay in power. searchinge has been for enemies outside of russia as well as enemies inside the country. inevitable, history wishes to recycle. but i have been saying that vladimir putin was a russian problem for a long time and he will eventually be everyone's problem. the plans now that are spreading way beyond our borders. he has been elected and democratic elections and the other high approval rating? guest: let's look at these things. let's go back to the year 2000. in 2000-2004,tion they had thousands of real actions. it was not fair at all. in 2012, when he returned to power, but of course, he never left power. it was just a charade. and i have always said that in russia, we are not trying to win elections, we're just trying to have elections because it is putin's russia. register at political party without his debates, you can have and the elections were rigged. and he has never participated in a single

what will you listen for from president putin? and presidentment putin will speak.n for? >> i will listen to what the turks have to say because they were the first to break the news. i think the russian ministry of defense and russian officials are stunned by these developments. they certainly do not want any complications with turkey, and complications are coming to them , and very hard. you wrote an article on rush' possibilities. will russian military invention continue after today? let's bring this up to date? will russian military intervention change in syria with the downing of one of their jets? -- : they pavel: they have to. it is only the first of disasters and probably more to come because it is very easy to predict setbacks and disasters for this intervention. it was so poorly planned and so rashly executed. i thought it was more of a technical failure because crashes thisn summer. i think they lost eight planes. the problems on the border with turkey are also very clear. from the very beginning of the intervention there were violations. there were exchan

i was, at one point, a big ally of vladimir putin. and after this whole thing happens, and as i continue to do exposes of corruption, i'm no longer exposing his enemies. i'm exposing his own personal financial interests. and-- and on november-- 13th, 2005, as i was flying back to russia, having lived there for ten years, become the largest foreign investor in their country-- i was stopped at the vip lounge of sheremetyevo airport. i was locked up overnight. and then i was deported the next day and declared a threat to national security, never to be allowed back into russia again. at that point it became obvious to me that putin's interests had diverged. >> then things get-- go horribly wrong. the-- the-- the russian government goes after you. and they start going after some of your aides and all that. and you slowly manage to divest your interests-- your-- your investors' interests. you get your money out, which is great. and you get your staff out, in most cases. and you leave a few key people in russia who are not your employees, bu

putin will most likely retaliate.will choose time and space and most like ly he will retaliate against turkish interests inside syria. because turkey has vast interests inside syria. and in the days and weeks coming will show that putin will basically have his day. >> all excellent points, fawaz. thank you. we know erdogan asked to talk to putin. so much at stake. thank you so much, sir, from london. >>> coming up next, donald trump releasing a brand new response to backlash after he mocked a reporter with a disability. how the republican front-runner is responding to his critics on this holiday full of love and family and kindness. we'll be right back. sure, tv has evolved over the years. it's gotten squarer. brighter. bigger. thinner. even curvier. but what's next? for all binge watchers. movie geeks. sports freaks. x1 from xfinity will change the way you experience tv. >>> "the new york times" is calling it outrageous, comments that donald trump made ridiculing the disability of one of its reporters. campaigning in

. >> keeping us up to date with putin and president hollande conference earlier. thank you. launching air strikes against the islamic state will make us safer. the message from the you u.k. prime minster. addressing the house of commons david come ran -- cameron tried to address the common house. >> reporter: in the wake of the paris attacks, at the house of commons, the british prime minster made his case stating the is group pose a series threat. >> we have to ask ourselves whether the risk of inaction is rather the risk of taking action action. >> reporter: labor leader jeremy corbin agreed that the group had to be stopped. it's a terror campaign in the middle east. >> without credible or acceptable ground forces, isn't the logic of an intensified air campaign, and western boots on the ground? can it today rule out the deployment of british ground forces to syria? >> we are not deploying for british combat force. we think the presence of western boots on ground will be counterproductive. >> reporter: the british prime minster stressed moderate forces should pla

is this putin's way or the highway? what can be achieved if the president again meets with vladimir putin in paris in the coming days? >> well, there's a fundamental contradiction between the russian position and the american position that president obama hasn't realized for nearly four years, and that is russia is going to continue to insist that assad stay in power in syria with him personally or with the regime. that's what the russians want. that's what iran wants. they're not going to back away on that. whereas president obama, secretary of state clinton, secretary kerry have said during that same four-year period that russia will help cooperate in easing assad out of power. it has never been the case. it was not the case then. it's not the case now. it's not going to be the case in the future. so until the obama administration gets over that illusion, i don't think there's any chance we're going to see cooperation. i think the two countries have fundamentally different interests. i think the russian primary motive

your history with vladimir putin? guest: i have never met putin.man has been destroying the who is, he is a dictator quite desperate to stay in power. searchinge has been for enemies outside of russia as well as enemies inside the country. inevitable, history wishes to recycle. but i have been saying that vladimir putin was a russian problem for a long time and he will eventually be everyone's problem. the plans now that are spreading way beyond our borders. he has been elected and democratic elections and the other high approval rating? guest: let's look at these things. let's go back to the year 2000. in 2000-2004,tion they had thousands of real actions. it was not fair at all. in 2012, when he returned to power, but of course, he never left power. it was just a charade. and i have always said that in russia, we are not trying to win elections, we're just trying to have elections because it is putin's russia. register at political party without his debates, you can have and the elections were rigged. and he has never participated in a single deba

>> i think he is exasperated with putin, but the point is, someone finally stood up to putin, i am not a fan of president erdogan of turkey, they did not react immediately, the russian planes have been violating turkish airspace for weeks, they are doing it because putin categor -- figured he could, and they got right angles of attack -- the rebels on the ground, and russia pilots are sloppy. they were getting warning after warning, russian figures they would not dare shoot us down, but erdogan is as brash and bold as putin is, they are on different sides of this struggle, putin talks fighting isis. but he attacking everyone else, the people we're backing, the people that the turks are backing. they were not going to take these violations of the airspace, i believe that turks did the right thing by calling putin's bluff. charles: to that point, france said that believe that 90% of the strikes in syria before paris, was all against int assad rebels, the people that american have been assisting and 10% targeted against isis, this illustrates that to a certain degree, but also feel like,

he was talking with the jordanian king, who is visiting putin in sochi. of course they are here to talk about syria. when the trip was planned, there was no indication that there would be discussion about like the downing of this plane. i basically implied that turkey is an associate of terrorism and this associate has stabbed russia in the back. he confirmed properly for the first time from the russian perspective at least today that this was an attack on a russian plane by turkish war planes. eggs that it had never threatened turkey and that that was an obvious fact. this according to putin is going to be an incident that severely impacts russian turkish relations. he said that russia had always treat turkey in a friendly way and so whose interest was this in, not ours, he said. so turkey after this happened, the first thing, he said obviously something that putin was angry about and something turkey did was go to his nato allies as if we, russia had downed one of the airplanes. he said does turkey want nato to wax in isil's interests, a very, very angr

what could putin do to retaliate? analysts say he could use oil as a weapon. >> putin's next move is probably going to focus on the energy markets and perhaps ties with turkey, turkish oil market is highly dependent on russia. will suffer because of it. >> reporter: but it's his potential military aggression that's scaring leaders from the middle east to washington. putin is moving anti-aircraft missiles what could hit planes over turkey to a base inside syria. experts say putin could bomb the ethnic turks who live inside syria and are allies with the turkish government. a u.s. official tells cnn there's concern tonight for the safety of american pilots flying in the area who could be caught in a crossfire. >> the russians for example have now said that their bombers are going to be flying with fighter escorts. one could imagine without too much difficulty even by mistake a dog fight involving six or seven turkish and five or six russian planes. >> now, steven piefer says an incident like that could escalate this into

and russia was stabbed in the back and putin referred to turkey as terrorists. this means in the russian environment, what putin says is picked up by all the political loyalists in the country, so the talk will be even tougher. speaking about what russia is likely to do, i hope this will not be along the military lines. after all, turkey is a member of nato, but there are ways to act diplomatically and economically and i think we will see some movement from russia in those two points. >> as far as the international attempts to build some sort of coalition to take on isil in a much more coordinated way, do you th

marco rubio calling vladimir putin a gangster. putin isn't insulted by that word. >> i think it's important that we know what he's all about. we still have to deal with him. we possess over 90% of the nuclear weapons on earth. that doesn't mean we should be fooled about what how he makes his decisions. >> cheryl: donald trump says that labeling putin a gangster isn't a good idea. >> i've been dealing with people all of my life, sometimes you deal with people that are rough people and they end up very easy to deal with. you never know. it's a tough statement to make up front, you have to make up for a lot of lost territory when you make a statement like that. right here on the fox business network and the debate was the most watched program in fbn's history. >> nicole: policies blasted on tuesday night and rand paul saying the fed has rate -- >> by keeping rates below the interest rate, they're actually talking about negative interest. >> nicole: federal reserve will have a chance to respond today. rethinking on conventional moneta

but of course, putin and france have closer relations than do the united states and putin.ent coming into the room there, by the way, on the other side of the split screen. so we think the president and president hollande will be coming in very, very shortly. another thing to point out is that president hollande is facing political pressure from the right wing coalition there and also from former president sarkozy. he has been enhancing his political stature with his response. there you see the presidents. >> 12:00 noon exactly in the east. both presidents, u.s. and france, making their way to the stage. >> please be seated. president hollande, it has been an honor to welcome you to the white house before in happier times than this, but as americans, we stand by our friends in good times and in bad, no matter what, so on behalf of the american people, i want to once again express our deepest condolences to you and all of the people of france for the heinous attacks that took place in paris.

so if he goes to putin for help, what is putin going to hold out for? is it going to be backing of bashar al-assad? >> two things. i think backing of assad and france and europe are almost there, because they can not afford another strike on europe. it will tear european, europe apart and undermine completely entire european project of open borders, everything we've heard about. the second thing, that putin wants, is clearly europe, lift the sanctions for our intervention into ukraine. and our seizure of the crimea. he wants those sanctions gone. trish: we'll be watching. quickly before i go, what is the likelihood that putin is successful this he get what is he wants in europe. >> i think french will signal, weaken back assad, but don't make us say it. i think he can get that. trish: people need the help. they need to fight this territory. john, thank you very much. good to have you here today. >>> new reports everyone, out of belgium, the molenbeek marry seized a list of terror suspects one month before the attacks. that list included ones involved in

candidates would react to vladimir putin but how well they know the enigmatic leader. >> if putin wants go in, and i got to know him well when we were on 60 minutes. if putin wants to knock the hell out of isis, i am for it, 100%. we can't continue to be the policeman of the world. weo $19 trillion. >> we better be the world's leader. there is a huge difference. without us leading, voids are filled. >> mr. trump needs to know we should not speak to people from a position of weakness. boy not be talking to vladimir putin, i have met him as well, not in a green room, for a show, but in a private meeting. >> joining me now is bill burton, serving as white house deputy press secretary. >> i thought that was very interesting. jeb bush had a much better debate this time around. i'm in the sure if that is a turning point that was not good for him. he said if putin wants to kick the hell out of isis, what do we care? trying to say they're not hitting isis but he never said it. he never said that you know, you say we've got to do nation building that is barack obama's line. >> seems he only stru

putin's plan. the russian president has an idea for ending syria's civil war. his historic election. >>> and myanmar, what it means for the muslims living there. >>> and plus, a controversy at an annual veteran's day parade. new. and two top school officials. now two students are under arrest, accused of making online threats against blacks on campus. andy is live for us in columbia, missouri. >> reporter: tony, social media here on campus has just been a mess of threats and rumors and gossip, but there was one post that simply could not be ignored. it popped up on tuesday night. an anonymous message on the online forum, yick yak. i'm going to stand my ground tomorrow and shoot every black person i see. security was beefed up. and six hoursiator, this 19-year-old student was under arrest. the police tracked him down at his dorm room, 75 miles from the main campus in columbia. he's a sophomore in computer science, he had no weapons in his possession when he was arrested. >> i was obviously fearful. and i walked in on high alert. but it's something that we deal w

putin plans to do, do you think? the russian people are quite angry that that russian war plane was shot down by turkey. and that russian's citizens were lost in this war on isis or assad or whoever putin is fighting within syria. >> you have to remember about putin, here is a man that after the united states passed legislation, targeting some of his nationals for human rights violations, he stopped the adoption to the united states of disabled children. this is his thought process. but then over time things ease. and i think that is exactly what we as the united states and as western -- the western coalition just has to let him blow off this steam. it is going to impact trade. it is going to impact tourism. but i think the long-term is, if we get too engaged with this fighting, or this moment in time of the downing of the jet, we will lose sight of the -- -- of assad and assad leaving syria whether voluntarily because the russians give him or out or because he can't survive what is going on will. >> julia thanks for

dana perino has met salad mvlad putin more than any?-- he thought bush had fired dan rather and it was my first br f briefing with the foreign leader, it was bazaar. >> bush didn't actually fire dan but it was great. thank you. the best of everything is even better during red lobster's ultimate seafood celebration where new seafood combinations like the new grand seafood feast are stepped up, spiffed up, jazzed up... yeah, this stuffed lobster tail, handcrafted brown butter scampi, and jumbo hand-battered shrimp are that good. or try the new ultimate wood-grilled feast. that bourbon brown sugar glaze gets ya preeetty fired up. with new dishes like these, why wait to celebrate? but just like this time of year, this is too good to last. so hurry in. big day? ah, the usual. moved some new cars. hauled a bunch of steel. kept the supermarket shelves stocked. made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. what's up for the next shift? ah, nothing much. just keeping the lights on. (laugh) nice. doing the big things that move an economy. see you

left unsettled, but left open by putin.assad be the sticking point in the coalition against isis? for insight, let's bring in senior correspondent matthew chance in moscow. matthew, bashar al assad, the sticking point in the discussions. what will it take to get putin to ease on support of assad? guarantees that russia's base in syria can remain open or relaxation of sanctions in ukraine? >> reporter: i'm not sure that for the kremlin these issues are linked. the russians have strong military presence. it is getting stronger by the day. they have strong economic ties there. it is more than that. they see syria as the last foothold in the middle east. this is about russian powers abroad. it is maintaining the influence on the global stage. the russians will be reluctant to let go of that. any assurances from washington will not change their mind. when russia is divided over bashar al assad, russians are backing into the hills. saying he doesn't have a future or role to play in syria. that problem has not yet been resolved. i

but mayor putin? >>. >> this man is day dictator who is desperate to stay in rus power in searching for enemi enemies that is what happened before and i have said for a long time eventually would be everyone's problem and now has spread beyond the soviet gueset'orders. >> but to be elected in democratic elections? >> go back to the year 2000 with the rapid in 2012 after he had power for four years n'd that was just a charade. one tries to run elections in other tries to have themoul'' because then the putin in russia with the fund-raisingged. you could not have a normal debates and the election was weak with the politicalpated in career just to explain in every petty understands hetionsi is there for life. elections will not change anything. just to pretend of a democratic institution.te >> host: if your book you write bruited russia is the biggest in the most: dangerous threat facing the world today. >> absolutely. right barack dave was right but-- wasn't ready to go beyond that is a thank you have t

russi vladimir putin said that russia must do everything possible putin said someone needed to take personal responsibility. well, monday the anti-doping agency recommended russia be suspended from athletics including olympic games on systemic, repeated doping offenses. >> i ask the sports minister and all of his leagues to give it his utmost attention. we must carry out our own internal investigation to ensure the most open. i want to stress this, the most open professional cooperation with international anti-doping structures. here in russia we must do all we can to get rid of this problem. >> rory challands has this update from moscow. >> what was interesting before vladimir putin's address, and it was a brief one, was that he didn't actually criticize the report into russian athletic doping at all. that has been done. but vladimir putin focused on what thetive response to this should be. now putin is a leader who sees himself as an athlete. he practices martial arts. he plays ice hockey. he goes skiing. he was also immensely proud that russia hosted a winter olympics in 2004, and he obvi

this is a smoke screen by putin. what is putin afraid of?losing the confidence of russian people, the russian will defend the mother land, they will suffer tens of millions of casualties too protect their own territory, but when it comes to foreign adventurism, russian public is fickle about that. so putin is afraid he will be embarrassed by the loss of marine, and a air force pilot. so he tries to paper over the mistakes, the russians do not have a high tolerance for casualties when they are involved in foreign adventurism. tom: egos have started wars. >> you are right. and president erdogan is also a guy with a reputation of being a chest thumper, but putin is involved in a foreign adventurism, he has been pulled to two wars, one in ukraine, and one in syria, he has not won either one. he has a media blitz going on to paper over his mistakes. >> thank you so much major general bob scales. >> thank you. tom: vote in tonight's poll, a political question, with some conservative super pac now going after donald trump, trump saying those attack

now putin's far more aggressive than ten years ago what happen's important to undersand that putin iscause many times before you would say, no, the suggestions from -- >> they don't -- they think he's kind of bloviating, they don't believe him. >> no, in 2008 he invaded the tiny republic of georgia. no reaction. let's start a new sanction policy. then ukraine. they thought, ukraine, end of the story. first crime mera, now in syria. he will keep moving before he stop because dictators never ask why, they ask why not. there's still the variety of methods that the united states, even -- can use to send a message, not to putin but russian elite and middle clasp people in -- there that's what it's going to take? >> exactly. >> take the oligarchs. >> but you know, also create problems for this million of russians from the middle class, that now feeling something is wrong but still believe putin will prevail because the way putin acted in europe, this reluctant handshake with obama spent hours practicing it. he knows image is everything. the russian propaganda presented it as a big triumph o

vladimir putin said that it is up to the syrian people to decide on the fate of assad.ussia considers assad to be its primary ally in syria because in the fight against i.s.i.l. the syrian army is the only effective ground force and therefore it has to be treated as an ally, if you are going to be serious about taking on i.s.i.l. then you need a ground force and that ground force belongs to the syrian government so we have to work with it, that is the perspective so for the russians saying that assad has to go is nonsensical because if you are serious about tackle terrorism and tackle i.s.i.l. then that would be a self defeating thing to demand. so that is where the russians believe, of course that is not what the united states and that is not what france and it's not what other members of the u.s. led coalition believe but that is why there is so much difficulty about getting a resolution in syria. >> rory many thanks and as we were discussing in turkey tensions remain high with russia of a downing of a jet and last tuesday the turkish president mr. erred wad -- erdoga

course president putin also threatening to pull out of the u.s.-lead coalition after the downing of one of his fighters. >> either they were not controlling what their allies were doing or they're leaking information all over the place. >> china's shanghai composite after a state investigation into chinese brokerages sends shares lower into the close. >> online and in stores the black friday frenzy gets off to an early shop with customers understooding shops and online retail shops to make the best of the sales. >> now this just out in the last ten minutes or so. turkey's president erdogan has requested to meet vladimir putin in paris on monday. the kremlin declined to speak but president putin intends to accept the request. let's get back out to hadley. >> good morning, carolyn. what a difference a day makes. all we have been talking about is who must be advising him to keep him from at least issuing some kind of message to russian president vladimir putin and the question of course being what is going to come next? what is this going to mean for

here he found a receptive vladimir putin. after several hours of talks, the only fruits of cooperation were these. >> translation: we agreed today to reinforce our anti terrorist work, improve exchange of operational information fighting terrorism, set up a constructive relationship between our military specialists in order to avoid duplication and incidents. >> reporter: that is still a long way from a grand coalition. disagreement over putin's ally president bashar al-assad is the stumbling block. >> translation: we want the discussions in vienna to lead to a political solution. the executive power must be given to an independent unity government during transition which will have as its gold as constitution, elections covering all sections of society and members of the diaspera. it is clear that bashar al-assad does not have a place in the place of syria. >> reporter: in syria there were more russian air strikes. this was raqqa. the planes have also bomb elide on tuesday. moscow is showing turkey its teeth. >> translation:

then he's going to moscow to talk to putin. putin is the essential ingredient. that's the tragedy. we are not leading in the. jenna: vladimir putin is advocating in syria, he said let president al-assad day. that's a hard logic after the paris attacks and being worried about what's going to happen in the united states and the united states issuing a travel warning. isis number one and al-assad down that list. >> in world war ii we had to hold our nose and deal with allies who may in otherwise agree with anything. maybe this time around we need to hold our nose and have allies willing to enter the fight with us against radical islam. but i have been struck by the president on one hand dismissing the threat of radical jihad and isis while saying it's media hype, while at the same time the state department is issuing a warning for travel and saying shelter in place. that's a disconnect over what is the threat and what is the threat to americans. we expect president francois hollande to step to the microphone. what about worst case scenario. we have an idea how he lead on this particul

vladimir putin cured the turkish government acting in support of i.s.i.l. president erdogan rejected those claims. >> translation: turkey doesn't need to fight corn to the foreign-- according to the foreign agenda. i.s.i.l. is an international game. they wanted to be a fool for islamphobia. in syria they use i.s.i.l. as a guise to attack the groups that are fighting the regime >> reporter: the fallout from tuesday's events risks relationships between the country but also economic ramifications >>> we have heard from the p.m. saying that the joint projects can be cancelled, can be effected. we have two main big projects. one is the nuclear plant and the second one was the industry. moreover we also heard that the turkish investors, they say the russian invest might decline. >> reporter: the war in syria has been a source for disagreement between moscow and ankara for some time now. >>> we had many disagreements. there is always big agreements. now what we see is actually deescalation is important, but not yet on the table. all of the parties are not getting

petersburg and putin will find and punish those responsible. u.s.tary of state john kerry has met francois hollande in paris talking about how to strengthen cooperation in the international fight against i.s.i.l. and the group claimed responsibility for attacks in paris which killed at least 129 people and wounded hundreds more. the president of yemen has returned home from saudi arabia and abd rabbuh mansur hadi sought refuge in riyadh in march about war and it's the second time he returned to the port aiden. a crash of an airliner in egypt last night and tim williams manager of the corporate firm and good to have you with us tim and what did you make of the timing of the confirmation it was a bomb that brought down the airliner and the russians expected a bomb for sometime. >> yes, i think that is right. russia actions over the last ten days or so have suggested that they knew this was a bomb or they strongly suspected that and i think the timing of this announcement is very much political when putin went into syria there was a mixed reaction from

president putin said the talks had been very constructive.e said the russian military actions were very effective in syria and they had destroyed infrastructure and financing leading to islamic state. he also said that he had discussed concrete practical plans with the french president to form an anti-terror coalition, and president hollande gave some more detail about that. he said there were plans to increase the exchange of information and intelligence between the forces operating in syria, and it's interesting to note as well that vladimir putin said that he was prepared to work with opposition groups. he said that before regarding the syrian conflict, but the french president said they had talked in more detail about that. they had agreed not to strike the forces who work with terrorists. he said, just those who work with daesh or so-called islamic state. this is basically to avoid hitting the run groups. he said there would be an understanding about the targets. they would be hitting together. this seems to perhaps point to a shift wher

putin does not want to be accused of doing nothing.tish prime minister cameron called putin, telling him the results of british secret service. every reasonable head in russia would protect his citizens, bring them back from a dangerous place. this is what british authorities have been doing. russian authorities pulled the wool over russian citizens eyes. after the world started to speak on this alleged bomb on board, the political pressure on putin became noticeable. he had no other choice than to show that he is worrying about his citizens. he is doing something. >> thank you so much for your continued coverage of this story. as we have been reporting, many holidaymakers remain stranded in sharm el-sheikh. let's get you the latest. ruth michelson is at sharm el-sheikh airport. our flights taking off? >> we understand that some flights it definitely took off today. at least one, perhaps to, of the easyjet flights scheduled to tak british tourists back managed to bring them back home. the british ambassador promised before that at leas

so does that mean it had to be putin? it could have been someone else with access to -- >> come on, come on, you're not going to engage in an act of nuclear terrorism in downtown london without the knowledge of the office of the president. >> today we begin the open hearings in the inquiry into the death of alexander litvinenko. >> reporter: in january 2015, a public inquiry opened in london. it's a victory for marina, who, along with her attorneys, fought not eight-year legal battle to make it happen. on the opening day, her attorney argued the evidence leads to one disturbing conclusion, which litvinenko himself reached before he died. >> mr. litvinenko came to the awful realization that he had been the victim of a political assassination by agents of the russian state. >> reporter: and in march 2015, an expert witness testified the polonium that killed litvinenko could have only come from russia. the kremlin ignored the inquiry. president putin's spokesman declined our request for an interview. and in 2015 putin gave l