r g. c. well rostock i merely go to my job we're talking about how to value caffeine. q. ok crisp and i go back you learn and we've talked and we've talked about individuals and we've talked about governments here but you know when we talk about happiness and consumption is i mean for our most of all of our life all of our lives consumption has been the key factor here and consumption and capitalism have almost everything together i mean is this something the capitalist ruling class was interested in they just want people to buy stuff ok they're not particularly happy if you're if you're worried about if you're happy about it later or not ok i mean if we look at the debt crisis of the last decade they didn't worry about our well being they just wanted us to keep borrowing so i mean my point is what is the role of capitalism in the economy in all this. well people pursue the happiness. regardless of whether to pursue economic growth or whether they pursue wealth people primarily and instinctively pursue happiness and they can do that in one of the ways they can or both way