american officials have so far decline to share any details. ralph ne meyer, chairman of the german council for constitution and sovereignty, says that germany's delivery of tags to ukraine breaks a number of international treaties and makes germany a direct party to the war in ukraine. it is a violation of article assassin off to you and charter, which clearly says that we cannot, nobody can legally send harms into a sum of conflict. so that is number one. secondly, what is all said, claire is that nato tre t. article 5 credit is violated. because ukraine is not a member of nato, and we only allowed to move our military was in the defense off nato territory. and of course german law because article 26 of our basic. busy which some people say is our constitution is prohibiting us from participating from anything other than defending ne to territory. since 1945, we do not have a peace treaty. we just have a ceasefire agreement to post them agreement. we never got our food. some righty. and up names now, russia can argue of course and say, well, germany has violated safe fire of 1945. so havi