does he need to go further in depth on this was cross live now to ralph nea meyer, chair for the german council for constitution and sovereignty. ralph, it's great to have you on the program today. now looking at what the chart president has said, one of the monitoring of russians as suggested by him amount to discrimination and a violation of basic e you was yes, definitely. and i must say, i'm really outraged by that because it cannot be that people are generally put on to a certain suspicion that is against human rights. that's against the un charlotte that's against any international law that we have. so i would completely reject that. and if the european union says that they are standing on the higher marolla the higher ground. yeah, they are terribly wrong when it comes to the russian citizens who would be impacted . how would that infringe upon their rights? and of course, are you surprised to see these calls being made in 2023? have we not learned anything in the decades since world war 2? a? well, that's a good question. and we, we see at the moment it's the, i'm spending off a